Who is the most over rated player in NRL?

[parra pete]

Who is the most over rated player in the NRL.
My top three Braith Anasta, Petero Civoniciva, Trent Barrett.

 

[Phillips]

my top 4:

1. Gower
2. Tate
3. Barrett
4. Kimmorley
5. Simpson

 

[PJ Marshal]

Anasta is the cream of the crop

 

[raz]

No one should overrate players in the firstplace

 

[mickdo]

I would put Sonny Bill Williams at the top of my list. He had a half decent game against an 'off with the fairies' Parra defence and all of a sudden he was going to be the next superstar of the game. Funny all the silence after his next two performances. :lol:

 

[Pazza]

As if Petero Civoniciva is over rated! He is a really good prop!

Anasta, everything the dogs screwed up on Friday night, Anasta was in the centre of it! Shocking player!

 

[booligal bill]

1.Anasta
2.Anasta
3.Anasta

 

[eelegant]

my top 4:

1. Gower
2. Tate
3. Barrett
4. Kimmorley
5. Simpson

Bob Carr School of Mathematics?

 

[Eelementary]

To me, Campbell is slightly over-rated. Very good player, but I don't think as a 5/8 he can compare to Fittler or Barrett.

The most over-rated player now is Bill Williams. He had a great game against us when our defence sucked major. Now he's played against sides with better defence and he hasn't done anything.

Another over-rated talent is Andrew Walker and Chris Walker.

 

[Avenger]

Anasta. People who say Gower do not know what they are talking about. He is a champion

 

[Freak]

Anasta and Matt Gidley for sure!
Jason Stevens is another although not rated in the saame quality as the other 2.

 

[Team55]

timana tahu - was sick - now just very overated

 

[JessEel]

Timana Tahu - needs joey to look decent.

he's my boyfriends favourite player, you should hear the arguements that causes

 

[Misty Bee]

Tahu is the odes best attacking winger next to Gidley IMHO.

Most ovverrated: Tallis.

 

[stuke]

got to be willie - plus he let it all go to his head.

 

[Maroubra Eel]

Two players overrated by themselves: Chris Walker and Justin Hodges.

What a pair of tossers!!!

 

[GoParra]

Two players overrated by themselves: Chris Walker and Justin Hodges.

What a pair of tossers!!!

Yea well Anasta fits pretty well into that category as well :lol:

 

[queanbeyhole hindy fan]

lol @ maroubra eel! I agree!
Willie Mason, Anasta would have to be most overrated in my books.
Another player who just seems to do very little is Todd Byrne from the roosters. I dunno, i just think he's a very ordinary player.

 

[Redback71]

trent barrett for sure, every time he plays the dragons loose.
you think they would learn and just stick with side that beat the warriots cause theyd probably win more games.

 

[Agent Mulder]

Matt Gidley
Brad Meyers
Brett Hodgson