Who was better ?

[anjado]

Nigel Roy for me he had more longevity i can barely remember anything about Rudd's career after he left the steelers.

Dallas Johnson was superior to Ian Russell who was a handy player but not in Johnson's class.

Anthony Minichello or Gary Belcher

 

[gUt]

Timana Tahu of 2002 or Akuila Uate 2010 lol

Aku, he's more capable of creating summat from nowt.

Anthony Minichello or Gary Belcher

Minichello was a bee's dick behind Lockyer as a fullback when both were in their prime, you'd have to give it to him.

Scott Hill or Des Hasler?

 

[MSIH]

Scott Hill.

Graham Eadie or Garry Jack?

 

[Noa]

Nigel Roy for me he had more longevity i can barely remember anything about Rudd's career after he left the steelers.

Dallas Johnson was superior to Ian Russell who was a handy player but not in Johnson's class.

Anthony Minichello or Gary Belcher

For mine Mini was over-rated and Belcher was very under-rated. Personal preference is for Belcher.

FTR Id take Russell, under-rated back in the day and if he was playing today we'd be raving about his ball-skills and how their a dying art.

 

[DoggiesBro]

Sbw or tallis

 

[beave]

we've had the pleasure of both Ian Russell and Dallas Johnson playing up here and Dallas wins by a country mile for mine.

Russell was probably a little past his use by date when he got up here but I wouldn't trade Dallas for anyone tbh.

 

[gypsy]

Sbw or tallis

Good one, in my opinion it's SBW. The most gifted player i've seen. I know he divides opinion, but he had the lot in my opinion. Great defence, good offload in traffic, lifted his team....and I remember in pre season testing at the bulldogs he was the quickest player over 40 metres. Shame he chose Nasser as his manager. Sonny seemed pretty modest when he first came into grade, over time Nasser/Mundine and co turned him into a tosser.

Nathan Brown or Simon Woolford

 

[DoggiesBro]

Good one, in my opinion it's SBW. The most gifted player i've seen. I know he divides opinion, but he had the lot in my opinion. Great defence, good offload in traffic, lifted his team....and I remember in pre season testing at the bulldogs he was the quickest player over 40 metres. Shame he chose Nasser as his manager. Sonny seemed pretty modest when he first came into grade, over time Nasser/Mundine and co turned him into a tosser.

Nathan Brown or Simon Woolford

100% Agree, overall i think SBW has shat on any forward in the game ever.

Based on pure ability that is, although as far as accomplishments far off alot including Tallis.

What you said was the absolute truth and 100% right too, when he came into first grade he was such a quiet kid, so loyal and honored to be apart of the Dogs and would never of left us if it wasn't for those tossers. Sadly it didn't just cost the Dogs the best forward i think that would of ever played it cost the NRL and any league fan one hell of a player to watch.

He could rip the game open in attack on his own like only a handful can and i think the only forward i've seen capable (others like hayne etc can but are backs), as far as running at him everyone knew not too. No matter how big or strong you were.

To answer your question Nathan Brown all day!

 

[[FKN-SIK]]

Brett Mullens or Tim Brasher?

 

[gUt]

It's a bit of a stretch comparing what, 3 seasons of injury-interrupted brilliance against the legacy of terror that the pre-injury Tallis brought over a long time.

Robbie Kearns or Luke Bailey?

 

[Sans Souci Sainter]

It's a bit of a stretch comparing what, 3 seasons of injury-interrupted brilliance against the legacy of terror that the pre-injury Tallis brought over a long time.

Robbie Kearns or Luke Bailey?

Big Bull for power.

Carne or Hancock?

 

[gUt]

Hancock comfortably.

 

[Sans Souci Sainter]

Hancock comfortably.

Well done.

Have you been reading this thread long?

 

[Sans Souci Sainter]

Mundine vs Daley.

Lulz

 

[gUt]

Well done.

Have you been reading this thread long?

Only since post #2. Not sure what you're getting at.

 

[betcats]

Mundine vs Daley.

Lulz

Umm Daley.

Sterling or Langer.

 

[gypsy]

lol@gUt

Sterling for sure.
Langer couldn't pass, tackle, kick or run...plus he was a redneck midget to go with it.

Josh Hannay or Steve Bell

 

[gUt]

Sterling for sure.
Langer couldn't pass, tackle, kick or run...plus he was a redneck midget to go with it.

Josh Hannay or Steve Bell

:lol:

How did he manage to win all those premierships and rep jumpers and that? I think Sterlo and Langer were pretty much on par.

Steve Bell craps on Hannay from a great height.

John Buttegeig or George Rose

 

[Mr Saab]

Buttegeig when he was in hos prime

Worst goal kicking routine - Riddell or Soward

 

[betcats]

Buttegeig when he was in hos prime

Worst goal kicking routine - Riddell or Soward

Soward the ugly little prick, that fairy dance is terrible.

Better origin career Locky or Wally.