Who was better ?

[typicalfan]

Yeah thought that might be a close one.

Larson, for a couple of reasons, loyalty to one club, longevity (especially for Queensland, 24 straight matches for a forward is awesome) and the fact he would do push ups between sets at the gym. Supremely fit man. Tough one though, Lindner was no slouch.

Kavin Campion or Bryan Fletcher?

Different styles of player. Fletcher the more talented I would suggest, Campion tough as nails and a winner.

Personal bias says Campion.

Nathan Cayless or Darren Britt

 

[Desert Qlder]

Probably quite similar in talent with those two. Cayless is more fresh in my memory so I'm going to go with him, Britt is a little hazy for me.

Skippering a WC win for NZ is a big deal too.

Greg Alexander or Geoff Toovey?

 

[Moffo]

mmm tough, just going to say alexander, i think he was more of a footballer

jason hetherington vs luke priddis

 

[Desert Qlder]

We all know Priddis is a better player and achieved more, but I'm going with Hetherington just because he sounds like one tough bugger. He is so Aussie his mother must have mated with a redback spider.

Price or Civo, Ebony or Ivory?

 

[typicalfan]

We all know Priddis is a better player and achieved more, but I'm going with Hetherington just because he sounds like one tough bugger. He is so Aussie his mother must have mated with a redback spider.

Price or Civo, Ebony or Ivory?

Civ, more impact.

I would have went with Toovs as well. Sure Brandy was more talented but Toovey starred at all 3 levels, Brandy didn't. But those are opinions.

Corey Hughes or David Penna

 

[beave]

Civ for mine as well.

 

[typicalfan]

mmm tough, just going to say alexander, i think he was more of a footballer

jason hetherington vs luke priddis

Priddis comfortably. Hetherington was tough but so are most hookers.

 

[Moffo]

hughes. even though hughes was shit for most of his career he was still better then penna

wes patten or ewen mcgrady?

 

[beave]

Mcgrady, he won a Rothmans's didn't he???

 

[Loudstrat]

The General by heaps

Benny Elias or Robbie Farah?

 

[beave]

Loudy, you sure you got the right Patten there mate??

 

[Baron Vo Mandor]

Paul Doolan or Roy Bell?

 

[gUt]

The General by heaps

Benny Elias or Robbie Farah?

Elias, he pushed Walters all through his career, miles away from the Ennis/Farah cripple fight.

Peter Sterling or Ricky Stuart?

 

[RABK]

Ricky Stuart, both played in champion teams and were as vital as any player in those sides but i think Stuarts ball distribution and kicking game were both superior to Sterlings and arguably amongst the top 3 ever in both skills.

Paul McGregor or Matt Cooper

 

[alexwilliams_66692007]

Timana Tahu of 2002 or Akuila Uate 2010 lol

 

[axl rose]

Paul McGregor or Matt Cooper

McGregor when injury free. NSW rarely lost a game/series with him at centre.

Steve Roach or Glenn Lazarus

 

[Bobby DIGital]

Lazzo by plenty. Was the cornerstone of 5 premiership winning packs. Roach won zero. Lazzo was also a huge part of NSW golden run in the early-mid 90s. Roach was replaced in 92 and NSW started winning.

Robbie McCormack or Jim Sedaris.

 

[Walt Flanigan]

Jimmy Sedaris was a fairly handy player.

Ricky Walford or Ewan McGrady?

 

[Mr Saab]

Walford

Jody Rudd or Nigel Roy

 

[Noa]

Elias, he pushed Walters all through his career, miles away from the Ennis/Farah cripple fight.

Peter Sterling or Ricky Stuart?

Sterlo.

Better organiser, better leader, better tactical kicker, split hair in skills.

Would much rather a prime Sterlo as my 7 then Stuart.

Ian Russell or Dallas Johnson