Who was better ?

[beave]

Lozza for mine.


Oh and I miss Matty Sing, best winger we've ever had in our 17 seasons.

 

[RABK]

Sean Hoppe or Mat Rogers

 

[PARRA_FAN]

Both speedster wingers at the start, but Rogers could play anywhere in the backline.

Dean Pay or Darren Britt

 

[gUt]

Darren Britt looked like the least fun bloke to try and tackle since Sirro, I'll go with him.

Nigel Vagana or Willie Talau?

 

[Loudstrat]

Vagana. 5 tries v Souffs and then a bow to a Souffs fan. A rare classy act in a Dogs jumper.

How about the battle of the twinkle-toed masters of finesse - Geoff Robinson or Martin Lang?

 

[RABK]

Vagana, much more dangerous IMO and was quality for longer.

Better Atmosphere - Tigers vs Dragons 2005 preliminary @ SFS or Warriors vs Canberra 2003 semi @ SFS

For those lucky enough to attend both you might recall, like i do, just how electric the atmospheres were.

 

[Loudstrat]

Oh, and Kenny by a length. Golden boot, Lance Todd trophy, 2 GF tries 3 years in a row and pushed Wally out of the test side on a Kangaroo tour.

And the Saints/Tigers semi was awesome on TV - only semis that come close were Eels v Dogs in 09 (With almost twice the crowd), Brisbane v Melbourne in 08 and Brisbane v Saints this year.

Dallas Johnston or Trevor Gillmeister?

 

[beave]

The axe, hospital bed and all that shit, to this day I always wondered if that story was tru or not???

Scott Gourley or Jason Stevens?

 

[Loudstrat]

Good one Beave. Though Gourley was a fantastic backrower, but Stevens in a whisker.

This one I think should be a three way one:

Henry or Robbie Paul - or Lance Hohia?

 

[gypsy]

This one I think should be a three way one:

Henry or Robbie Paul - or Lance Hohia?

Hohia because he plays in the toughest comp in the world, and isn't a cat.

Barry Ward or pre-drugs Danny Wicks?

 

[Moffo]

Wicks

Ward was a plodder

Muir vs Fletcher

 

[gUt]

Muir was one of those presence (read: feared) players while Fletcher played with skill. Muir for mine.

Brad Mackay or Luke Lewis

 

[gypsy]

Muir was one of those presence (read: feared) players while Fletcher played with skill. Muir for mine.

Brad Mackay or Luke Lewis

Brad Mackay. One of my favourite players, never seemed to have a bad game. Regardless of the scoreline he'd be one of the best on the field. Lewis has more skill, but with injuries etc. it's hard to go past Mackay.

Richie Williams or Arana Taumata?

 

[typicalfan]

Brad Mackay. One of my favourite players, never seemed to have a bad game. Regardless of the scoreline he'd be one of the best on the field. Lewis has more skill, but with injuries etc. it's hard to go past Mackay.

Richie Williams or Arana Taumata?

Arana Taumata. Only bad behaviour has kept him out of first grade.

Paul Langmack or John Cross

 

[Moffo]

geebus

have to say langmack, did more. cross was just a solid club player

thurston vs langer

 

[Silent Knight]

Allan Langer. While Thurston is the premier halfback in the NRL he hasn't achieved yet what Langer did several times...win a premiership. Both have represented their state and country with distinction but Langer wins on the premiership count. As well as that damn Origin comeback.

Gordon Tallis vs Ben Kennedy.

 

[PaddyBoy]

Allan Langer. While Thurston is the premier halfback in the NRL he hasn't achieved yet what Langer did several times...win a premiership. Both have represented their state and country with distinction but Langer wins on the premiership count. As well as that damn Origin comeback.

Gordon Tallis vs Ben Kennedy.

Thurston won at Canterbury in 04.

 

[typicalfan]

Allan Langer. While Thurston is the premier halfback in the NRL he hasn't achieved yet what Langer did several times...win a premiership. Both have represented their state and country with distinction but Langer wins on the premiership count. As well as that damn Origin comeback.

Gordon Tallis vs Ben Kennedy.

Both at their best is very close but Tallis was at his best just that bit more often.

Mark Carroll or David Gillespie.

 

[Raider_69]

David Gillespie for mine, tough one

Adrian Purtell or Jason Bulgarelli?

 

[beave]

Allan Langer. While Thurston is the premier halfback in the NRL he hasn't achieved yet what Langer did several times...win a premiership. Both have represented their state and country with distinction but Langer wins on the premiership count. As well as that damn Origin comeback.

Gordon Tallis vs Ben Kennedy.

Without trying to look like the typical clown in here that jumps to the defence of players of their fave team ( I would say this even if I wasn't a NQ fan) but I think you are being a little harsh on Thurston there mate. The cowboys have had some f**king disgraceful nuffies play for us over the last few years dragging the team down, he can't do it all by himself every week.

But he did win a premiership in 04 though.........