Who was better ?

[Meth]

Michael by a mile, he played for Australia, Craig was lucky to play first grade.

Steve Renouf or Justin Hodges?

Renouf. Maybe it's nostalgia, but he was a try scoring freak. Hodges is a very good player who has had a couple of top shelf seasons.

Tim Brasher or Garry Jack?

 

[Bobby DIGital]

I'm gonna say Brasher. I only caught the end of Jack's career and he was a brilliant defender, but didn't have the speed and evasive skill of Brasher.

Brasher also kept the best fullback in the world Brett Mullins out of the NSW fullback spot in 94 & 96.

Noa Nadruku or Akuila Uate?

 

[WarriorDefence]

Nandruka had the luxury of playing outside better players but I gotta go uate.

Stacey jones or Gary Freeman

 

[Jack_Napier]

Jones. Was brilliant, would love to see him in the current warriors/NZ set up.

Bradley Clyde or Paul Gallen

 

[sensesmaybenumbed]

Gandalf..... serious ball skills IMO

:lol:

 

[Jason Maher]

Clyde was the best lock I've seen play. Very complete player. Gallen is more an inspirational workhorse who just doesn't know when to quit.

One from a classic GF I saw the other day:

Paul Sironen or David Gillespie

 

[mongoose]

Clyde was the best lock I've seen play. Very complete player. Gallen is more an inspirational workhorse who just doesn't know when to quit.

One from a classic GF I saw the other day:

Paul Sironen or David Gillespie

Both great players but Sirronen was a step above Gillespie.

Brett Finch vs Peter Wallace

 

[WarriorDefence]

Gotta go finch- I think he's a bit under rated actually.
Meninga or inglis

 

[Jason Maher]

Both benefited playing next to superstars (Fittler/Cronk and Lockyer respectively). Points decision to Wallace because of his solid defence.

Trent Merrin or Aaron Woods

 

[sensesmaybenumbed]

At this stage, Aaron Woods, but Merrin is no slouch either. Both very good front rowers for their age.

Robbie Farah or Danny Buderus?

 

[Dogs Of War]

Nandruka had the luxury of playing outside better players but I gotta go uate.

Stacey jones or Gary Freeman

Jones by a mile. Freeman was a grub

 

[WayneBennett]

:lol:

:dcoke or pepsi ya merkins???

 

[Wizardman]

Stacey by a mile.

Ben Elias or Robbie Farah?

 

[Tommy Smith]

Gotta go finch- I think he's a bit under rated actually.
Meninga or inglis

Inglis. I think he's a more complete player than Meninga.

Id also take Buderus over Farah every time. Bedsy in his prime was a class above Farah.

 

[Red&BlackBear]

Andrew Leeds or Matt Seers?

 

[Jason Maher]

Seers. At his peak was a delight to watch. Unfortunately he was stuck behind one of the all time great fullbacks in Mullins.

Darren Lockyer or Anthony Minichello?

 

[mongoose]

Lockyer. If he didn't move to 5/8th he would have finished his career as the best No. 1 to ever play the game.


Mark Gasnier vs Justin Hodges

 

[Jason Maher]

Have to say Gasnier due to my intense dislike of Hodges. He could have been so much better than he was though.

 

[typicalfan]

Lockyer. If he didn't move to 5/8th he would have finished his career as the best No. 1 to ever play the game.


Mark Gasnier vs Justin Hodges

Gasnier as played much better at rep level.

Ben Hornby v Kurt Gidley in their prime.

 

[eozsmiles]

Gidley, better bench player.

Blacklock or Merritt?