Who was better ?

[Loudstrat]

Lamb, base purely on competitiveness alone. Alexander was probably more of a spot defender.

Brian Johnson or brian johnstone

Johnson. Better singer.

 

[gypsy]

Johnson. Better singer.

Joel Caine or Lee Murphy

 

[_Johnsy]

Lamb, base purely on competitiveness alone. Alexander was probably more of a spot defender.

Brian Johnson or brian johnstone

Johnson. Better singer.

I didn't know either of them sang ;-)

OR

 

[jack coburn]

paul carige - feliti talanoa
Both gave supporters heartburn

 

[_Johnsy]

Carige has his own thread

 

[jack coburn]

enough said

 

[tonesy87]

stacey jones or brett kimmorley?

 

[Gallen=God]

stacey jones or brett kimmorley?

Had this one at the beginning of the thread but I'd say Jones based on consistency.

Paul Gallen or Glenn Lazarus

 

[KiamaSaint]

Had this one at the beginning of the thread but I'd say Jones based on consistency.

Paul Gallen or Glenn Lazarus

Hmmm, one won premierships with three clubs and the other has won nothing. Tough choice.

 

[Rhino_NQ]

Had this one at the beginning of the thread but I'd say Jones based on consistency.

Paul Gallen or Glenn Lazarus

Out of shear work load i'd go with Gallen, rep player, worn the C next to his name, just no premierships but happens to play for a club that is cursed in that department

Battle of the Phantom Speedsters

leon Bott or joven clarke?

 

[Gallen=God]

Hmmm, one won premierships with three clubs and the other has won nothing. Tough choice.

Lol bait much?

One played in better sides than the other. Pretty hard to win a premiership with a bunch of nuffies around you. This year shall be interesting however.

 

[bellyache]

Lazarus.... What about the Fergo's..
Chicka or Blake?

 

[Loudstrat]

Chicka. Go the mighty Bluebags!

Stephen "The Leds" Kearney or Brian "Bluey" McLennan?

 

[bellyache]

Chicka. Go the mighty Bluebags!

Stephen "The Leds" Kearney or Brian "Bluey" McLennan?

Kearney!
Popeye or Alwaysgreen?

 

[KiamaSaint]

Lol bait much?

One played in better sides than the other. Pretty hard to win a premiership with a bunch of nuffies around you. This year shall be interesting however.

Gallen is a Nuffie.

 

[God-King Dean]

Ali Lauitiiti or Feliti Mateo?

 

[KiamaSaint]

Paul Gallen or Papalii

There you go, fixed it for you, although Jon Green would have been an acceptable alternative.

 

[Frenzy.]

Ali Lauitiiti or Feliti Mateo?

Both go/went missing in games.

Mateo. Just a bit more class.

Apisai or Inosi Toga?

 

[KiamaSaint]

Inosi Toga.

Dane or Kurt Sorenson?

 

[Frenzy.]

Inosi Toga.

Dane or Kurt Sorenson?

Dane for consistency. Kurt for plain old brutality.

I'll go with Dane.

Chang or Les Johns?