Who was better ?

[Frenzy.]

Luke was probably quicker but Joel was more dogged.

I'll plump for Rooney.

Fred Jones or Elwyn Walters?

 

[WarriorDefence]

Never heard of them
Ashley Harrison or Dane carlaw? Both debuted for the broncos bout the same time

 

[Lambretta]

Fred Jones or Elwyn Walters?

Welsh surname vs Welsh first name? Tough choice

I'll go with Elwyn because first names come first so he wins by default

Brent Tate or Justin Hodges

 

[@MarTiger]

Welsh surname vs Welsh first name? Tough choice

I'll go with Elwyn because first names come first so he wins by default

Brent Tate or Justin Hodges

Damned if you, damned if you don't as both have been plagued by injury and both have had their moments. I lean toward Justin Hodges.

Garry Jack or Gary Belcher?

 

[Lambretta]

Never heard of them
Ashley Harrison or Dane carlaw? Both debuted for the broncos bout the same time

Ashely Harrison - I just reckon he has a bit more class about him than Carlaw on top of the work rate.

 

[@MarTiger]

Ashely Harrison - I just reckon he has a bit more class about him than Carlaw on top of the work rate.

It's not even close. Dane "Look Like Tarzan Play Like Jane" Carlaw is and was a myth.

 

[Lambretta]

Damned if you, damned if you don't as both have been plagued by injury and both have had their moments. I lean toward Justin Hodges.

Garry Jack or Gary Belcher?

Gary Jack on reputation alone (as I never saw them play)

Mat Rogers or Benji Marshall

 

[Lambretta]

It's not even close. Dane "Look Like Tarzan Play Like Jane" Carlaw is and was a myth.

Yeah - "bit" is subjective. :lol:

 

[@MarTiger]

Gary Jack on reputation alone (as I never saw them play)

Mat Rogers or Benji Marshall

Benji Marshall in a landslide surely? :? Do we need reasoning here?

Ben Kennedy or Paul Gallen?

 

[typicalfan]

Benji Marshall in a landslide surely? :? Do we need reasoning here?

Ben Kennedy or Paul Gallen?

BK. Proven big game player.

Adam MacDougall or Hazem El Masri

 

[Desert Qlder]

BK. Proven big game player.

Adam MacDougall or Hazem El Masri

El Masri, an exemplar of professionalism his whole career and not a drug-taking arsewipe like the other guy.

Jason Smith or Jim Dymock?

 

[NAS]

El Masri, an exemplar of professionalism his whole career and not a drug-taking arsewipe like the other guy.

Jason Smith or Jim Dymock?

Tough one..... I'll say smith on account purely of the few extra years he played.

Michael Bani or Shannon Hegarty?

 

[Fire]

Tough one..... I'll say smith on account purely of the few extra years he played.

Michael Bani or Shannon Hegarty?

Hegarty, simply for playing rep footy.

Wendell Sailor or Lote Tuqiri?

 

[Frenzy.]

Lote. He has better hair.

fire or hardbaby?

 

[Miller was a legend]

Lote. He has better hair.

fire or hardbaby?

Can't split this one. Like them both

 

[WarriorDefence]

What about the old classic- Lewis or Kenny

 

[Armageddon.]

Lewis

Ricky Stuart or Jonathon Thurston?

 

[Frenzy.]

JT by a whisker. I put him ahead of Sticky because of his speed and goalkicking.

Sludge or Bozo

 

[typicalfan]

Bozo was an absolute natural and at times a class well above the opposition. Deserved immortal so I go with him.

Ben Cross or David Fa'alogo

 

[Flapper]

Fa'alogo floored Anasta, he wins.

Asa Milford or Laloa Milford?