Who was better ?

[Tommy Smith]

Joel Thompson.

Issac Luke or Craig Wing...

 

[Mogsheen Jadwat]

Wing. Had more versatility and was instrumental in the Roosters early 2000 run.

Sean Rudder or Shane Perry?

 

[jono]

perry......rudder couldn't steer a train on a track

 

[Sydney Knight]

Marty Crequer or Eion Crossan

 

[Jimmy-o]

Remi Casty or George Rose?

 

[Captain Apollo]

Remi Casty or George Rose?

Casty. He at least shows that he is trying.

 

[Mogsheen Jadwat]

Remy Casty sounded like a dessert so Rose ate him, so I guess Rose by default

 

[blaza88z]

Scott Minto or Leon Bott

 

[Twatface Magee]

Scott Minto or Leon Bott

Bennett Jr


Remi Casty or the State of Origin streaker from 2 years ago?

 

[mongoose]

Morgan.

Austin might be flavour of the month at the moment but Morgan's a more complete player.

Dylan Walker or Michael Jennings?

And Morgan isn't flavour of the month?

 

[Tommy Smith]

Well Morgan has been absolutely brilliant since the beginning of 2014. So that's 18 months of sustained form, which disqualifies him from being a mere 'flavour of the month'.

 

[roostersrule2]

Well Morgan has been absolutely brilliant since the beginning of 2014. So that's 18 months of sustained form, which disqualifies him from being a mere 'flavour of the month'.

Indeed, whereas Austin was only decent last year but has really stepped up a gear the last month.

 

[Jimmy-o]

Moghseen Jadwat or Bill Harrigan?

 

[Mogsheen Jadwat]

gentleman please this ain't even a contest

 

[Mogsheen Jadwat]

bill by the length of the flemington straight

 

[Jimmy-o]

Beaver Menzies or Nathan Hindmarsh?

 

[Ibleedblue]

Both were fantastic loyal players but I would just give it to Menzies due to his strike rate and that he won a couple of premierships. Plus I've never been a Manly fan but Ive always liked them because of this man.

Sam Burgess v Adrian Morely

 

[Canard]

Beaver Menzies or Nathan Hindmarsh?

It's hard to compare someone who stood out in the backs all day to a forward.

 

[Mogsheen Jadwat]

yeah, those 3rd man flops would've been pretty taxing on flopmarsh.

 

[Brutus]

Rohan Teevan or Craig Teevan