Who was better?

[Dragsters]

G

George Rose
Henry Tatana or Craig Smith

Tatana by a toe poke!

Mitch Breanan or Ricky Walford?

 

[_Johnsy]

Tatana by a toe poke!

Mitch Breanan or Ricky Walford?

Ricky EDOTW

Ian Heron or Nick Zisti

 

[Old Timer]

Tatana by a toe poke!

Mitch Breanan or Ricky Walford?

Tough question loved them both but Ricky Walpole was a great player, clubman and ambassador and just loved it when Rex Mossop f**ked up his name.

 

[RedVDragon]

Tough question loved them both but Ricky Walpole was a great player, clubman and ambassador and just loved it when Rex Mossop f**ked up his name.

Walford.

Matt Head or Noel Goldthorpe

 

[Old Timer]

Walford.

Matt Head or Noel Goldthorpe

Head of course
Dorahy or Goodwin

 

[RedVDragon]

Goodwin any day.

Mary or Mick Beattie

 

[gregstar]

Goodwin any day.

Mary or Mick Beattie

mary.

a harder one is graham quinn or beattie.

 

[chewbacca]

Beattie
Nathan Long or a Cardboard box?

 

[gregstar]

beattie was awesome up until the major semi final in '85. he got injured & was never the same afterwards.

 

[gregstar]

Beattie
Nathan Long or a Cardboard box?

depends which side of the field long is playing on.

but to be fair, the box ran better angles.

 

[SBD82]

Beattie
Nathan Long or a Cardboard box?

The cardboard box. Closer than you'd think though.

Brad mackay or Shaun Timmins?

 

[gregstar]

The cardboard box. Closer than you'd think though.

Brad mackay or Shaun Timmins?

now that is a f*cking tough one!

maybe mackay by an absolute bees dick because he could roll for 80 mins.

but f*ck that's a tough one because i loved pig dog!

 

[Old Timer]

now that is a f*cking tough one!

maybe mackay by an absolute bees dick because he could roll for 80 mins.

but f*ck that's a tough one because i loved pig dog!

I think Mackay as he was not the most gifted player of all time but grew a leg in big games and rep football.
The Penguin or Beattie

 

[Too old too slow]

I think Mackay as he was not the most gifted player of all time but grew a leg in big games and rep football.
The Penguin or Beattie

The Penguin... Although Beattie was a gun runner... Allegedly

Bruce Starkey or Pat Jarvis

 

[RedVDragon]

The Penguin... Although Beattie was a gun runner... Allegedly

Bruce Starkey or Pat Jarvis

Pat Jarvis

Wayne Bartrim or Graeme O'Grady

 

[roach_83]

Colin ward or Chris liekvoll

 

[RedVDragon]

Colin ward or Chris liekvoll

Ward

Steve Funnell or Scott Gourley

 

[Saint_JimmyG]

Gourley.

Cameron Wade or Andrew Frew?

 

[Uplifting]

Gourley.

Cameron Wade or Andrew Frew?

Andrew who?

 

[Old Timer]

Pat Jarvis

Wayne Bartrim or Graeme O'Grady

They ignored you Red V but Barto for mine.
They ignored you too roach_83 but Leikvol for mine.