Who was better?

[Old Timer]

Phil Blake or Benji

 

[RedVDragon]

Tony Trudget or Trent Barrett

 

[Saint_JimmyG]

Andrew who?

A noted speedster who played mostly on the wing, Andrew Frew played more than 100 first grade games featuring for such clubs as Parramatta and the Northern Eagles.

He also played a solitary match for the Dragons in 2004.

Blink and you would've missed it.

 

[Saint_JimmyG]

Tony Trudget or Trent Barrett

Trudgett (as he won a premiership)

Quentin Pongia or Josh Miller.

 

[loose arm]

Trudgett (as he won a premiership)

Quentin Pongia or Josh Miller.

Quentin
Harry Bath or Wayne Bennett

 

[Saint_JimmyG]

Quentin
Harry Bath or Wayne Bennett

Bennett.

Johnson or Boyd.

 

[RedVDragon]

Bennett.

Johnson or Boyd.

Bath and Boyd

Mark Shulman or Steve Rogers

 

[Uplifting]

Phil Blake or Benji

Great comparison. Both gifted 'individual' players. Too hard to call...

 

[dragon-83]

Noel Goldthorp or Benji

 

[Old Timer]

Bennett.

Johnson or Boyd.

Boyd has turned into the complete package but bloody hell just loved Brian Johnson in full flight.
The game was so different back then but I do believe if Johnson had played in the current era under Bennett or Bellyache he would have been the equal of any FB.
Re Bath and Bennett I understand the Bennett record speaks for itself but Bath's efforts in 77 & 79 were the equal of any achievement of any coach anywhere and in particular 77 probably even more so.

 

[SBD82]

Noel Goldthorp or Benji

For us? Goldthorpe.
For their respective careers? Benji.

 

[SBD82]

Brett firmin or Matt head.

 

[Sigurd]

Boyd has turned into the complete package but bloody hell just loved Brian Johnson in full flight.
The game was so different back then but I do believe if Johnson had played in the current era under Bennett or Bellyache he would have been the equal of any FB.
Re Bath and Bennett I understand the Bennett record speaks for itself but Bath's efforts in 77 & 79 were the equal of any achievement of any coach anywhere and in particular 77 probably even more so.

Here is a tough one for you. I know they were in different positions but close enough.

Reg Gasnier or Gareth Widdop?

 

[BrissyRedV]

Brett firmin or Matt head.

Matt head
Coyne or Cooper

 

[Old Timer]

Here is a tough one for you. I know they were in different positions but close enough.

Reg Gasnier or Gareth Widdop?

Conclusively proves you have a obsessive compulsive disorder.
Absolutely no comparison to Gasnier anywhere in the world and you offer up a 5/8 you have issues with.
Why not try and be constructive with all your nervous energy and contribute in a decent manner instead of your constant fishing trip?.

 

[SBD82]

Matt head
Coyne or Cooper

Cooper, but I'd take coyne and coops as a centre pairing any day of the week.

Blacklock or bmoz?

 

[BrissyRedV]

Cooper, but I'd take coyne and coops as a centre pairing any day of the week.

Blacklock or bmoz?

Tingha

Liekvol or Rose

 

[Sigurd]

Conclusively proves you have a obsessive compulsive disorder.
Absolutely no comparison to Gasnier anywhere in the world and you offer up a 5/8 you have issues with.
Why not try and be constructive with all your nervous energy and contribute in a decent manner instead of your constant fishing trip?.

Take your meds and just breathe. It was a legitimate question. Gasnier apparently filled in at 5/8 on numerous occasions. Anyway, noted you refused to answer.
How about this one: Johnny Raper or Gareth Widdop?
Raper also filled in at 5/8 on numerous occasions. And I believe was also the captain for a period.

 

[Dragonbey]

Chris leikvoll

Jeremy smith or neville costigan

 

[BrissyRedV]

Chris leikvoll

Jeremy smith or neville costigan

Jezza

Potter or patten