Who's better?

[Zadar]

I'm only 40, so Lazzo.

Rod Wishart or Willie Carne?

Wishart.
Sam burgess or Adrian Morley?

 

[Westernised Panther]

Wishart.
Sam burgess or Adrian Morley?

Sam Burgess

Mark Geyer or Trevor Gilmeister?

 

[Ghostface Killah]

Sam Burgess

Mark Geyer or Trevor Gilmeister?

The Axe

Brett Kimmorley or Noel Goldthorpe

 

[Bobby DIGital]

The Axe

Brett Kimmorley or Noel Goldthorpe

Gotta go with Noddy. He took Goldthorpe's Mariners jersey right after Goldthorpe won the SL Origin tri series for NSW in the first ever real golden point game. Noddy then went on to play for the SL Roos at the end of that season. A remarkable turn of events tbh.

Ian Roberts or Paul Harrogan?

 

[I Bleed Maroon]

Can't go past Chief. One of the best props NSW have ever produced. Had a bit of mongrel in him too, although it got the best of him at times (getting knocked out clean by Mark Carroll comes to mind).

Peter Sterling or Ricky Stuart?

 

[This Year?]

Peter Sterling - More complete player and was always planning for 2 or 3 tackles later. Ricky Stuart had the best kicking game I've ever seen.

Jamie Soward or Jahrome Hughes?

 

[mozza91]

I’ll go Soward. Although if Hughes continues on his current trajectory he’ll end up the better player.

Tim Brasher or Brett Mullins?

 

[Vee]

Ian Roberts or Paul Harrogan?

Tough one. I think Chief is probably remembered better but Roberts was a wonderful player, one of the toughest to play the game.

 

[Vee]

Can't go past Chief. One of the best props NSW have ever produced. Had a bit of mongrel in him too, although it got the best of him at times (getting knocked out clean by Mark Carroll comes to mind).

Peter Sterling or Ricky Stuart?

Sterlo, no contest, as good as Stuart was and change the game as he did.

 

[Vee]

I’ll go Soward. Although if Hughes continues on his current trajectory he’ll end up the better player.

Tim Brasher or Brett Mullins?

Another good one. Mullins had more flair but Brasher was so competitive, he bridged the gap.

 

[Generalzod]

Steve Rogers
Mal Meninga

 

[Vee]

Steve Rogers
Mal Meninga

Sludge for mine.

Bob Lindner or Wayne Pearce?

 

[Captain Apollo]

Agreed. Jack’s less selfish and will happily change positions to give his mate a go.

- Arthur Beetson; or
- Glenn Lazarus?

Beetson by a proverbial mile. He could get yardage like Lazarus, and a quick play the ball too. However he was quicker over 20 metres than Lazarus and had the ball playing skills most halfbacks would die for. Also a top notch defender.

 

[I Bleed Maroon]

Beetson by a proverbial mile. He could get yardage like Lazarus, and a quick play the ball too. However he was quicker over 20 metres than Lazarus and had the ball playing skills most halfbacks would die for. Also a top notch defender.

You didn't leave a new comparison to keep the thread going

 

[Someone2]

Sludge for mine.

Bob Lindner or Wayne Pearce?

Pearce

Brad Fittler or Johnathan Thurston

 

[Ghostface Killah]

Pearce

Brad Fittler or Johnathan Thurston

El Frederico > Coffs Harbour.

Matt Cooper or Dylan Farrell.

 

[Captain Apollo]

El Frederico > Coffs Harbour.

Matt Cooper or Dylan Farrell.

Cooper by quite a way. He was a top notch centre who stayed in first grade for most of his career (unlike Farrell). Also won a first grade premiership to boot (also, unlike Farrell).

Ray Price or Jim Dymock?

 

[Ghostface Killah]

Cooper by quite a way. He was a top notch centre who stayed in first grade for most of his career (unlike Farrell). Also won a first grade premiership to boot (also, unlike Farrell).

Ray Price or Jim Dymock?

Ray Price.

Ray Price or Bradley Clyde.

 

[soc123_au]

Ray Price.

Brett Stewart or Tom Trbojevic

 

[mongoose]

Tom will be the better player

Todd Carney or Jarrod Mullen