Who's better?

[MugaB]

Robbie Farah or Api Koroisau

Api, just won 2 GF! And did it at souffs too prior,
Farah only won 1, did sweet f'all at souffs

W.Pearce or B.Clyde

 

[Pippen94]

Api, just won 2 GF! And did it at souffs too prior,
Farah only won 1, did sweet f'all at souffs

W.Pearce or B.Clyde

Clyde. Never stopped in 89 grand final

Jason Martin
Matthew Rodwell

 

[Vee]

Farah, more consistent

Imports: Adrian Morley or Gareth Ellis?

Ellis, one of the best backrowers I've seen.

 

[MugaB]

Clyde. Never stopped in 89 grand final

Jason Martin
Matthew Rodwell

Matthew Rodwell
Had the balls to play for Perth on that fkn hard as shit cricket field

 

[Captain Apollo]

Api, just won 2 GF! And did it at souffs too prior,
Farah only won 1, did sweet f'all at souffs

W.Pearce or B.Clyde

Clyde. Whilst both were tough players, I think Clyde had better ball skills than Pearce.

Kerry Boustead or Terry Fahey?

 

[Rhino_NQ]

Edit, I buggered the order up

 

[Still Nutty]

Clyde. Whilst both were tough players, I think Clyde had better ball skills than Pearce.

Kerry Boustead or Terry Fahey?

Bowie...two very different players but Bowie was a better finisher for mine and a classic winger for that era.

As much as I liked Terry Fahey (who was built and ran like Mal Meninga) I most remember him for having one of the worst semi-final games in first grade history playing for Souths against Manly I think (missed tackles, dropped balls and let 3 tries in before half time from memory)...it was such a shocker that even Rex Mossop (a Manly legend and hard man) said he felt sorry for him in the commentary.

Ben Kennedy or Gary Larson?

 

[Wb1234]

Bowie...two very different players but Bowie was a better finisher for mine and a classic winger for that era.

As much as I liked Terry Fahey (who was built and ran like Mal Meninga) I most remember him for having one of the worst semi-final games in first grade history playing for Souths against Manly I think (missed tackles, dropped balls and let 3 tries in before half time from memory)...it was such a shocker that even Rex Mossop (a Manly legend and hard man) said he felt sorry for him in the commentary.

Ben Kennedy or Gary Larson?

Bk

Arthur beetson or bozo fulton

 

[Captain Apollo]

Bk

Arthur beetson or bozo fulton

A lot harder to compare considering one played front row or second row, whilst the other played centre or five eight.

Though I'd go for Beetson personally. Whilst he may not have had the "flash" that Fulton did, he was incredibly skillful with ball playing skills that were incredible, he could run very quickly over 20 metres as he had great acceleration, was strong as an ox, and could hit like an axe when tacking. Fact he played for as long as he did, in an era where playing in the forwards was brutal, he gets my vote. Also his organisational sense, he could read a game as well as players like Wally Lewis, Peter Sterling, Ricky Stuart and Andrew Johns did at their peak.

Norm Provan or Gene Miles?

 

[Someone2]

Boyd Cordner or Isaah Yeo

 

[mozza91]

Yeo. Cordner was promising early but turned into an honest toiler. Yeo has gone from honest toiler to quality ball player.

Willie Mason or Mark O’Meley?

 

[Wizardman]

Mark O'Meley did his job better than Mason did his.


Lote Tuqiri or Wendell Sailor?

 

[Generalzod]

Einstein or Archimedes

 

[mongoose]

Einstein or Archimedes

these two?

 

[Chins get the wins]

Yeo. Cordner was promising early but turned into an honest toiler. Yeo has gone from honest toiler to quality ball player.

Willie Mason or Mark O’Meley?

Also the best defender in the sport. Yeo is the best lock since Clyde

 

[Generalzod]

these two?

View attachment 96166

View attachment 96167

You are a genious...

 

[Pippen94]

Mark O'Meley did his job better than Mason did his.


Lote Tuqiri or Wendell Sailor?

Why are you comparing lote & Wendell?!