What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Why we still hate Union

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mango

Juniors
Messages
172
So far several hundred amateur Rugby players have successfully made the change to proffessional mungo rugby, we are still waiting for a leaguie to make the change to proffessional RUGBY.
MANGO.
 

Alan Shore

First Grade
Messages
9,390
Mango said:
So far several hundred amateur Rugby players have successfully made the change to proffessional mungo rugby, we are still waiting for a leaguie to make the change to proffessional RUGBY.
MANGO.

Mat Rogers. :roll:
 

Mango

Juniors
Messages
172
Get with it son. Rogers was an OZ schoolboy at RUGBY. I hope Wendal. Lote and who ever follows makes it, but until they do then they havn't.
MANGO.
 

iggy plop

First Grade
Messages
5,293
Rogers played league before any of that kick n'clap shit. He only first played rugby because his highschool played nothing else, just like Wally. true league men first before the toff school scenario.
 
Messages
2,807
Mango said:
Get with it son. Rogers was an OZ schoolboy at RUGBY. I hope Wendal. Lote and who ever follows makes it, but until they do then they havn't.
MANGO.

Wendell and Lote have already made it, haven't they? They played in the 3N, and are about to play in the WC. Also. Jason Robinson of England and Brad Thorne of the AB's seem to have "made it."
 
Messages
2,807
Is this a surprise? An article by Gordon Bray, praising the Warriors' style of play and saying the Wallabies should try to emulate it:

Time for Eddie to be flair dinkum
By Gordon Bray
September 18, 2003

HERE'S hoping Eddie Jones and his World Cup Wallabies took time out from their steamy, heavy-duty training sessions in the Territory last weekend to catch the rugby league action at the Sydney Showground.

How good were those New Zealand Warriors in their 48-22 demolition of the Bulldogs? Don't bother dispatching our coaches to England on study tours - the real football fireworks are happening on our doorstep.

Watching the high-risk skills of that Polynesian and Maori-dominated NRL side rekindled images from the beaches of Fiji, Tonga and Samoa where kids play dazzling, ball-in-hand rugby for sheer fun.

You'd swear the Warriors grew up playing that same style: joyful, improvised and free of coaching restraints. The artistry of Francis Meli & Co. set an entertaining benchmark for all football codes.

The Wallabies can't, and won't, assimilate the Warriors' boldness overnight but they could take inspiration from such an adventurous approach.

Essentially, the Warriors play to their strengths of catch-pass-run with pace, power and flair.

In contrast to some of the current Wallabies, these players were clearly enjoying the game. Remember this was a cut-throat final, yet the Warriors backed their spirit of adventure - and had a damn good time in the process.

Their Aussie coach Daniel Anderson claims these virtuoso displays will soon give him a heart attack, but he's also the man who's had the courage to give his charges a licence to thrill.

Could this be the spark missing from Australian rugby at the moment? Are we unknowingly suffocating natural talent and inventiveness through so-called "scientific" coaching?

I dusted off the ABC's historic video of the 1984 Wallaby Grand Slam tour and was transfixed by the attacking skills of three youngsters in particular.

Sure, Nick Farr-Jones, Mark Ella and David Campese enjoyed a dream platform from a mighty forward pack but there was no denying the individual artistry on display. The swift clearance and short running bursts of a rookie Farr-Jones; the ball-to-the-line running and lightning hands of Ella; the explosive timing and bewildering stepping at full speed by Campo.

There's little doubt this year's World Cup champions will need to have the capacity to play open, attacking rugby - with strength and pace.

How revealing that it's taken a Kiwi league team to remind us
 

Mango

Juniors
Messages
172
Many of the 1908 Wallabies and about 100 since. I didn't notice any mungo supporters denouncing the lack of depth in their code when all the talented RUGBY players were purchased to bring much needed running skills, defensive patterns and tactical kicking skills to a proffessional code that often lacked initiative due to it's limited international exposure. Unfortunately, any game that lacks genuine international competition can look to be at the top of the tree simply because there is no forest to measure against. In true international sport we can witness a great contest between two minnows and think we have just witnessed a great match of high intensity and highly developed skills. The following week one of these combatants may play a world power and we will realise the shortcomings of the week earlier. Domestic or limited international codes such as league are classic examples of giant trees in a desert.
 

Mango

Juniors
Messages
172
Mungo rugby is rugby league. You can't get any closer than that. Check your history son, you are a mungo.
 

Anonymous

Juniors
Messages
46
Having played both League and Union, I fing Union tougher but League faster.

The story in the beginning of this thread is a discrace and shouldnt be allowed to happen though.
 

jack coburn

Juniors
Messages
475
union tougher than league :lol: :lol: i,ve also played both although only about 10 games of union before i went back to league,got to bored with kick and clap it just lacks the intensity although it was always a good social day out.mango i'm trying to think in the last 20yrs what union players were walk up starts to the kangaroos i,m sure you can help me out.
 

Stevo_G

Juniors
Messages
696
Mango said:
Mungo rugby is rugby league. You can't get any closer than that. Check your history son, you are a mungo.

mate i would rather support this mungo league that u refer it as than the the game they play in heaven :lol: :lol:
 

dimitri

First Grade
Messages
7,980
i'm trying to think in the last 20yrs what union players were walk up starts to the kangaroos

not many at all

guys like rogers, sailor, and tuquri were lucky to play 3 matches of kick and clap before they were playing for the wannabees
 
Messages
4,331
dimitri said:
i'm trying to think in the last 20yrs what union players were walk up starts to the kangaroos

not many at all

guys like rogers, sailor, and tuquri were lucky to play 3 matches of kick and clap before they were playing for the wannabees

How many league-to-union converts were Kangaroos at the time they converted?
 

dimitri

First Grade
Messages
7,980
why does that matter?


guys like lenny beckett, ryan mcgoldrick, and duncan mcrae certainly werent
 
Messages
4,331
Sorry, long day. I meant it the other way round - how many union-to-league converts were Wallabies at the time of conversion? It's a genuine question - I don't know the answer - but my point is that Sailor, Tuqiri and Rogers were at the top of their code prior to switching. Are there any comparable players who were Wallabies, then converted? (Barring the obvious 1908 Wallaby exodus, of course).
 

dimitri

First Grade
Messages
7,980
i think ray price was

darren junee and peter jorgenson were as well

but they were nothing special in yawnion

what about ricky stuart?

and michael oconnor
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top