Worst Defender

[borat]

Lets put it this way, Campbell & Bowen are both about the same size. Yet who would you rather have defending the line? Campbell by a mile so how his name comes up as the worst defender.

You are kidding right. Preston Campbell gets shifted top the wing more than any player in the comp beacsue he can't defend. Every team in the comp targets him because his defence is so poor. I would rather Bowen any day of the week.

 

[God-King Dean]

I'd prefer Campbell over Bowen. Bowen misses between 40-50% of his tackles, which is terrible especially for a fullback

 

[God-King Dean]

I'd love to know how the hell people could say Gasnier is the worst defender. I'll compare Gasnier & Cooper

Gasnier Appearences-12
Tackles-150
Mistackles- 11

Cooper Appearences-23
Tackles-430
Mistackles- 31

Keep in mind that Cooper is considered by many to be the best defensive centre in the League. You will find that their percentages tackles made are pretty much the same, & Cooper has played double the matches Gasnier has. Worst defender my arse

 

[melon....]

Fat Hodgo....left his winger to mark 2 most of the time.

The master blaster is Matt "The lord of Oh Gawd!" Sir Turnstiles Gidley.

 

[God-King Dean]

Nick Youngquest

Funnily enough, he has better tackling stats (& metres gained) than all of the Sharks wingers

 

[Greenblooded]

Brad Drew is terrible, although only partly his fault as he was born with kangaroo arms. :lol:

 

[SaintTPP]

I'd love to know how the hell people could say Gasnier is the worst defender. I'll compare Gasnier & Cooper

Gasnier Appearences-12
Tackles-150
Mistackles- 11

Cooper Appearences-23
Tackles-430
Mistackles- 31

Keep in mind that Cooper is considered by many to be the best defensive centre in the League. You will find that their percentages tackles made are pretty much the same, & Cooper has played double the matches Gasnier has. Worst defender my arse

Its quite obvious that St george have the two best defenders and attacking centres in the game, lets see how many games they will play together though.

 

[rock_on_knights]

The master blaster is Matt "The lord of Oh Gawd!" Sir Turnstiles Gidley.

oh ur soo funny :roll:

as johns_magic and red and blue knight pointed out...
tahu 84.5% gidley 84.1% compared with some other combo's.
6. Matt Gidley(15.2 tackles per game for 1.6 mistackles)

yeh real sh*t :roll:

anyway, i think walker is the worst defender

 

[God-King Dean]

Brad Drew is terrible, although only partly his fault as he was born with kangaroo arms. :lol:

.....& looks an aweful lot like the guy in your avatar :lol:

 

[Greenblooded]

Brad Drew is terrible, although only partly his fault as he was born with kangaroo arms. :lol:

.....& looks an aweful lot like the guy in your avatar :lol:

Touche :lol: :lol:

 

[God-King Dean]

Matt Gidley's 'turn-styleness' is so exaggerated it's not funny