Worst player by position

[Spike]

Who do you rate as the worst player currently via position to play first grade?

Fullback:
Winger:
Centre:
5/8:
Halfback:
Lock:
Second Row:
Hooker:
Front Row:

At the end I'll poll the most nominate players via position to find out who people rate as the worst player to ever play the game.

 

[Mixmasterreece]

this year ?

 

[Join The Bandwagon]

Fullback: Simmons from Cronulla
Winger: Eric Grothe
Centre: Steve Matai
5/8: John Morris
Halfback: Joe Williams
Lock: Liam Fulton
Second Row: Warangi Koopu
Hooker: Adam Perry
Front Row: Brent Kite

 

[Spike]

aaahhhh whatever, I've got bad stomach cramps and am farting like an ape at the moment courtesy of a new type of whey protein powder I bought...... I think it's going to get worse before it gets better.

 

[thehattrickrabbit]

FB: David Simmons (SHA)
W: Luke Macdougall (DRA)
C: George Carmont (NEW)
FE: John Morris (WST)
HB: Luke Walsh (NEW)
PR: Bryce Gibbs (WST)
HK: Adam Perry (BUL)
SR: Shannan McPherson (SOU)
LK: Reegan Tanner (NEW)

 

[Deleted member 10972]

Grothe? Matai? Fulton? Koopu? Kite? :crazy:

This year:

Fullback: Trent Cutler
Wing: Darius Boyd
Centre: Shannon Hegarty (Brad Tighe would be close)
5-8: Shane Muspratt
Halfback: Brett Firman
Prop: Brendan Worth (Chris Beattie & Josh Perry would come close)
Backrow: Matt Bartlett
Lock: Luke O'Dwyer

 

[Cheesie-the-Pirate]

People don't see to understand the difference between "worst" and "over-rated".

 

[_Johnsy]

I will pick players of kangaroo tours, picking nuffies would be too easy.

Fullback: Mark McGaw (played fullback v Cumbria W 42-10 6,750 Workington 1990 tour)
Winger: Shannon Hegarty
Centre: Luke Lewis
5/8: Greg Florimo (love the guy though)
Halfback: Steve Martin
Lock: Jim Sedaris
Second Row: Steve Kneen
Hooker: Kerrod Walters
Front Row: Don McKinnon

 

[Big Mick]

Fullback: Shannon McDonnell
Winger: Shannon Hegarty
Centre: George Carmont
5/8: John Morris
Halfback: Brett Kimmorley
Lock: Ashley Harrison
Second Row: Tony Puletua
Hooker: Adam Perry
Front Row: Brendan Worth(less)

 

[God-King Dean]

Fullback: Simmons from Cronulla
Winger: Eric Grothe
Centre: Steve Matai
5/8: John Morris
Halfback: Joe Williams
Lock: Liam Fulton
Second Row: Warangi Koopu
Hooker: Adam Perry
Front Row: Brent Kite

You're a crack addict.

 

[Spike]

Fullback: David Simmons
Winger: Mark O'Halloran
Centre: Brad Tighe
5/8: Joe Williams
Halfback: Shane Perry
Lock: Reegan Tanner
Second Row: Todd Lowrie
Hooker: Adam Perry
Front Row: Brendon Worth

 

[Iafeta]

Fullback: Simmons from Cronulla
Winger: Eric Grothe
Centre: Steve Matai
5/8: John Morris
Halfback: Joe Williams
Lock: Liam Fulton
Second Row: Warangi Koopu
Hooker: Adam Perry
Front Row: Brent Kite

He had a good end to this year, carved up the Eagles ;-)

Around 2004-2005, he was probably in our top three for consistent performers, and then he got a bad shoulder injury. I'm not quite sure I'd class him the worst second rower going around, I think Logan Swann is a better pick TBH.

 

[Surely]

I will pick players of kangaroo tours, picking nuffies would be too easy.

Fullback: Mark McGaw (played fullback v Cumbria W 42-10 6,750 Workington 1990 tour)
Winger: Shannon Hegarty
Centre: Luke Lewis
5/8: Greg Florimo (love the guy though)
Halfback: Steve Martin
Lock: Jim Sedaris
Second Row: Steve Kneen
Hooker: Kerrod Walters
Front Row: Don McKinnon

You left out ryles.

 

[_Johnsy]

You left out ryles.

So now you're telling me who I think are the worst players on a kangaroo tour, knobwad. I would hate to let bias cloud my judgements. Nice to see you have again had great input into a thread, clown

 

[Canard]

Nobody has put any though in to it if Minto isnt nominated.

Shame on you.

 

[Aotearoa_NewZealand]

is this based on actual playing ability or just whether you hate them!

 

[Sheros los Deros]

1.Toshio Lasieni
2. F Anderson
3. G. Katsogiannias
4. C Saab
5. J Anderson
6. A Watts
7. B Sheehan
8. D Tweddle
9. D Bosnich
10. S Wessels
11. N Patterson
12. M Luck
13. B Tuuta

Any person who has been selected to play first grade footy is deserving of some respect.

 

[Misanthrope]

Fullback: David Simmons
Wing: Shannon Hegarty
Centre: Brad Tighe
5-8: Shane Muspratt
Halfback: Shane Perry
Prop: Anthony Tupou
Backrow: Matt Bartlett
Lock: Reegan Tanner

HB: Luke Walsh (NEW)

Step #1 - Remove head from ass
Step #2 - Place head in oven

 

[Tonearm Terrorwrist]

follow your own advice for nominating tupou

 

[Misanthrope]

follow your own advice for nominating tupou

Most overrated forward in the game. Hasn't done anything in recent years to justify his continued selection in representative teams. There are probably worse props going around, but when I think of ordinary front rowers - I think of him.