Worst Prop IN the Game - Is It Bryce Gibbs??

[Packy]

Adam Ritson.... Oops..

To be honest though.. He would probably still go better than some of teh names in this thread.

 

[ucantseeme]

I'd vote for Bryce Gibbs as worst prop in the comp at the moment.

Every time he runs the ball I have to cross my fingers and hope he doesn't drop it with an incorrect play the ball. In defense I hope he doesn't give away stoooopid penalties. Especially on 5th tackle.

If the Tigers extend his contract they must be loopy.

 

[Azkatro]

I emailed Andrew Voss for Boots n' All a few years ago and said a big part of the Cowboys fall from grace was the departure of Paul Rauhihi. He disagreed. We only need to take a glance at the plethora of world class props that have powered through hitup after hitup and made the Cowboys ruck one of the most defensively dominant in this era.

Seriously though, what era would you have to go back to in order to find a less mobile prop than Shane Tronc? Maybe the lower division in England in the 1960's? The less said about the performances of guys like Kaufusi, Sargent, Cashmere and Scott the better. Carl Webb has some ability at least but I would struggle to think of someone I'd like to play alongside less.

 

[Beavers Headgear]

Don't know if he has been mentioned, but White is terrible imo

 

[Charlie124]

Since the thread is about the worst prop IN the game, my vote is easily for Bryce Gibbs.

Webb has been very poor but he isnt even the worst prop (even though he is playing in the back row) we currently have in our own team, let alone the comp.

Shane Tronc is so soft i saw him run into a 5 year old girl and not even hurt her feelings...

 

[typicalfan]

Its embarrassing to think Gibbs has made it to the City side.

 

[adamkungl]

Since the thread is about the worst prop IN the game, my vote is easily for Bryce Gibbs.

Webb has been very poor but he isnt even the worst prop (even though he is playing in the back row) we currently have in our own team, let alone the comp.

Shane Tronc is so soft i saw him run into a 5 year old girl and not even hurt her feelings...

:lol: epic lulz

 

[Eelementary]

Nathan Cayless. Sorry, but it's true.

 

[Syko]

the tigers forwards are all soft, corey payne is a bitch boy and gibbs is best at being a grub, he should go back to that.

 

[kia ora storm]

Brent Kite

 

[hybrid_tiger]

the tigers forwards are all soft, corey payne is a bitch boy and gibbs is best at being a grub, he should go back to that.

Agree on Payne and Gibbs for sure. However the likes of Ellis, Heighington, Payten and Galloway are not soft.

 

[joel caine number 1 fan]

imo hes one of the best defending forwards at the tigers,hes attack is crap but at least he can defend something none of our other forwards can do :roll:

 

[Didgi]

No way is Galloway soft, it's just the rest of 'em that are pathetic.

 

[Dragon_psa]

Brent Kite

Is that the same Brent Kite that tore you c--ts a new arsehole in last years GF?

 

[TV Ted Ellery]

the tigers forwards are all soft, corey payne is a bitch boy and gibbs is best at being a grub, he should go back to that.

Those soft bastards that beat St George every time? ;-)

The Tigers forwards are largely crap with some exceptions, namely Ellis, Heighington, Galloway & Payten. Even amongst those four it seems that Galloway is the only one capable of denting the defensive line.

 

[CliffyIsGod]

Brent Kite

Yep.

 

[proto]

Cayless has at least put in the yards & has an excuse

Gibbs & Ross are the 2 worst high profile IMO

 

[sooperdooper]

ben ross is alright...
Gibbs is a shocker, acts like a tough man but cant back it up...
cayless is not going well either. I think a switch to the back row would be better

 

[Eelementary]

Cayless has at least put in the yards & has an excuse

Gibbs & Ross are the 2 worst high profile IMO

World Cup-winning skipper who plays like a pillow isn't high profile enough?

 

[proto]

i mean, its what his 13th season?

he should go to UK next year. he's done really well IMO but it's time