Would you trade Cross for Snowden?

[aqua_duck]

Just trying to get a gauge of what everyone thinks based on the discussion Pika, RIBK and I have been having

 

[Chicken_Hunter]

no...

 

[TooheysNew]

For this season? Or long term?

On Cross's money? Or Snowdens?

In their prime? Or right now?

 

[Pika]

Grrrr

Loaded question!

Right now I would take Snowden over Cross.

One is up and coming and improving every week, the other is on the way out.

My point on the other thread was that right at this moment, I still think Cross is better footballer than Snowden.

 

[Alex28]

I'd have Snowden AND Cross.

Please.

Didn't see the fascination in Snowden last year, but he is coming on as a very good player.

I'm a fan of Cross. Have no problems in having him here.

 

[Jono078]

Easy for me. Wouldn't even think twice about it.

 

[Whats Doing]

I would have both.

 

[Misanthrope]

It's a bit of a no brainer, really. If you wanted to make it interesting, you really should have done something like:

Ben Cross

or

Kade Snowden and a kick in the nards

 

[Yosh]

Easy for me.

Young, talented and upcoming frontrower who is yet to reach their prime who is also home grown

vs

Experienced, hardworking, passionate but overall not really all that talented injury prone non-head gear wearing brick wall?

 

[Big Tim]

Cross now.

Snowden in 1-2 years.

Too much context to make a simple black and white.

 

[The_Joey_Show]

At any other club, it's an easy decision.

Here however, there is the very real possibility of Snowy returning to old, poor habits.

Right here, right now, Cross. Better the devil you know.

 

[roopy]

I remember arguing with Raiders fans years ago about how good our prop in reggies was and they reckoned theirs was better.
Now they have Dane Tilse, and we have Ben Cross.
I wonder if they would swap back - they were pretty adament that Cross was much better than Tilse in those days.

 

[macavity]

Cross > Tilse

atm Cross > Snowy too

but as we aren't going to get within cooee of doing anything this year, I picked Snowy - because he is going to be better than Cross very very soon and has 10 years ahead of him.

Agree with TJS btw, if there is a club that can bring out the worst in players, it is ours.

 

[Tom155]

15 to 1 in snowdens favour. who voted cross?