What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Your NRL All Stars Team

Titanic

First Grade
Messages
5,938
Although they didn't play last year it's still called the Harvey Norman Annual event, so 2016 may be a chance still. I'll watch it out of rugby league starvation but don't care who selects or plays and cross every extremity I've got that there are no injuries.
 

Johnnie Red

Juniors
Messages
631
I am not a fan of the all star game but the indigenous team and community seem to benefit from it. But the all star team seems to just be a passenger in the indigenous celebrations / recognition.

As an NBA fan, even their all star game is pointless. There is no passion or intensity and is simply the equivalent to a soccer 'friendly'. Its not really great viewing. But the whole weekend is interesting.

If the NRL were to adopt more events like the NBA/MLB all star event then I could see some more merit (no not Nathan Merritt) in the concept.

The NBA has a 3 point comp, dunk comp and a rookie game. MLB has a home run comp.

NRL could have a goal kicking shootout, agility/ obstacle course, highest bomb, longest kick or drop goal, 100m sprint or some other gimmicks to make it more interesting. It would take it from a 2 hour game to a half day spectacle. Oh and let the fans vote on all the players.

That would be a good way to kick off the season.
 

rabbitohs95

Bench
Messages
4,711
Honestly i'd rather have an NRL All Stars vs a Super League All Stars event. Either that or an Indigenous vs Māori game.
 

Canard

Immortal
Messages
35,614
Is there any requirement for a club to release a player for this game if selected by Bennett?

Doubt it, even if it was, it doesn't seem to be enforced. Lots of players have withdrawn from it over the years.

Id reckon Wayne (and others) would speak to all of the players prior to there selections anyway to avoid that sort of thing.
 

AJB1102

First Grade
Messages
6,339
Well its bi annial so no it would not see 2016

I thought it only got shelved due to the WC clogging up the schedule.

If it is the case that its now only played every 2nd year then it was a good call from me about '16 ;-)
 

insert.pause

First Grade
Messages
6,461
Doubt it, even if it was, it doesn't seem to be enforced. Lots of players have withdrawn from it over the years.

Id reckon Wayne (and others) would speak to all of the players prior to there selections anyway to avoid that sort of thing.

Its been reported that he's consulting with coaches to see who is available before selecting the side, so hopefully there shouldn't be any sudden withdrawals.
 

oikee

Juniors
Messages
1,973
Its been reported that he's consulting with coaches to see who is available before selecting the side, so hopefully there shouldn't be any sudden withdrawals.

Yes, and that is another problem the game seems to be inheriting.
Clubs allowing players to pull out.
What these clubs dont realise is that we are in a market that needs to grow, or other leagues will simply come in and take our place.
Rugby union has a under-current of issues with juniors and head injuries at school level, Gridiron America is ready to take all in it's wake, a 7 billion college system can afford to swamp the smaller codes, and dispense them.

If our clubs and players cant see the benefits of playing Nines, All-stars and other off-shoots, such as World Club Challenge , and even internationals, then they should stand aside and allow visionaries to run their clubs, because they will become instinct if they dont grow.

And that is what Dave Smith talked about not long ago. The growth of world sports, growing at 15% a year.
Wheather that is through live, overseas growth and TV, you need a good product to sell, with decent players.
Surely Unions world growth is teaching us something. Their is a audience out their screaming out for product.
We have that product, being jeopodised with small-minded club managers.
Sack the lot of em, and ban the players from Origin, watch them scream then.

These players have got to start over-ruling their clubs wishes. We all get injuries, we all have to play in every club game. We all have to train, so why make excuses.
Man up, and get out.
Your boring me as 7 billion and growing college sport NFL in America will eat you for breakfast.
You want that, ??? Little Johnny waking up and putting a helmet on, and you knowing he will never make the grade, is that our future.

Time we woke up. Boycott the players who dont start playing these events, they are part of our future, or our failure.
As Moses said, "Forgive my people as they dont know what they have done".

Same applies to league players, they see dollars, that is far as they can see.
The club managers ion the other hand need to be reeled in,. and have their tongues cut out.
 

Mr Angry

Not a Referee
Messages
51,816
I have no idea why people dis this game.

I would rather my player play this, mix with others, forge friendships, on both sides.

Instead of a trial your club plays..

I just do not get the objection.
 

pHyR3

Juniors
Messages
955
I have no idea why people dis this game.

I would rather my player play this, mix with others, forge friendships, on both sides.

Instead of a trial your club plays..

I just do not get the objection.

id rather my player not get injured a couple of weeks before the season starts.

a star will be unlucky to play more than a half of footy in a trial, which is far below NRL or even all stars intensity.

well to be honest, scrap everything preseason except 9s, 1 trial/WCC.
 

insert.pause

First Grade
Messages
6,461
2015 All Stars teams revealed

NRL.com
12:20pm Mon 19th January, 2015

The Indigenous All Stars and NRL All Stars teams have been revealed ahead of the Harvey Norman Rugby League All Stars game at Cbus Super Stadium on Friday, February 13.

North Queensland Cowboys halfback Johnathan Thurston and South Sydney Rabbitohs fullback Greg Inglis headline a star-studded Indigenous All Stars squad. The two finished as the most popular selections from a public vote of more than 15,000 fans, and were separated by just 33 votes when the polls closed.

Thurston and Inglis will join the likes of Justin Hodges, Sam Thaiday, Greg Bird and Ben Barba in the Indigenous All Stars squad, which will be coached by Laurie Daley. Thurston will join new Cronulla signing Barba in a dynamic halves pairing which will be hoping to help the squad retain the Arthur Beetson trophy following their 2013 win at Suncorp Stadium.

For their opponents, Newcastle Knights enforcer Beau Scott will lead an NRL All Stars team featuring stars Kieran Foran, Mitchell Pearce and James Graham.

The NRL All Stars squad includes rising superstars Matt Moylan (Penrith), Dylan Walker (South Sydney) and Luke Brooks (Wests Tigers) alongside established representative stars including Manu Vatuvei (Warriors), Jared Waerea-Hargreaves (Sydney Roosters) and Paul Gallen (Sharks).

Brooks buoyed by All Stars selection

Along with the game, All Stars week will also feature a range of community-based events, including the annual Indigenous Player Camp, Indigenous Leaders Dinner and the NRL Youth Summit.

The All Stars game will follow several other exhibition matches: the Murri v Koori Interstate Challenge, the Harvey Norman Touch Football All Stars Game, NSW v QLD Indigenous Under 16s matches, and the Indigenous Women's All Stars up against the NRL Women's All Stars.

Tickets are available for the Harvey Norman Rugby League All Stars at ticketek.com.au/allstars.

2015 Indigenous All Stars team
1. Greg Inglis (Rabbitohs)
2. Alex Johnston (Rabbitohs)
3. Will Chambers (Storm)
4. Justin Hodges (Broncos)
5. Josh Hoffman (Titans)
6. Ben Barba (Sharks)
7. Johnathan Thurston (Cowboys)
8. George Rose (Dragons)
9. Ray Thompson (Cowboys)
10. Ryan James (Titans)
11. Tyrone Peachey (Panthers)
12. Sam Thaiday (Broncos)
13. Greg Bird (Titans)
14. Chris Sandow (Eels)
15. Tom Learoyd-Lahrs (Storm)
16. Dane Gagai (Knights)
17. Kyle Turner (Rabbitohs)
18. Jack Wighton (Raiders)
19. Kierran Moseley (Titans)
20. Brad Tighe (Titans)

NRL All Stars team
1. Matt Moylan (Panthers)
2. Manu Vatuvei (Warriors)
3. Jarrod Croker (Raiders)
4. Dylan Walker (Rabbitohs)
5. Antonio Winterstein (Cowboys)
6. Kieran Foran (Sea Eagles)
7. Mitchell Pearce (Roosters)
8. James Graham (Bulldogs)
9. Michael Ennis (Sharks)
10. Jared Waerea-Hargreaves (Roosters)
11. Beau Scott (c) (Knights)
12. Jason Taumololo (Cowboys)
13. Paul Gallen (Sharks)
14. Jesse Bromwich (Storm)
15. Luke Brooks (Wests Tigers)
16. Will Hopoate (Eels)
17. Trent Merrin (Dragons)
18. Corey Parker (Broncos)
19. Jeremy Smith (Knights)
20. Dave Taylor (Titans)


http://www.nrl.com/2015-all-stars-teams-revealed/tabid/10874/newsid/83420/default.aspx
 

Noname36

First Grade
Messages
7,067
The Indigenous boys should win if the forwards can hold their own. They're far superior in most of the key positions.

Bennett must want to make sure they win...only possible explanation for Pearce.
 

Latest posts

Top