OVP said:Surely Brett Finch is the winner.
He spent one year beside Laurie Daley(or was it two ?) at Canberra and produced jack sh*t, and then two years alongside Brad Fittler at the Roosters. You would seriously think by then this kid is going places wouldnt you ? 4 years besides two of the greatest 5/8's to lace on a boot, and what did he learn to do when it was his turn to lead his team around ? 100% of kicks went down the opposition fullback's throat, field goal attempts that sailed over the black dot of the corner post, passes that made the wards at the Prince of Wales hospital light up, and grubber kicks into the stands.
Yes that boy sure as sh*t has learnt a sh*tload from two of the greatest players in the game hasnt he ?
panthersballboy said:For the panthers:
Ben Roarty
Paul Franze
Matthew Rodwell
Trevor Gilmeister (He was a good player, just not for us)
Fibroman said:John Lang.
Fibroman said:John Lang.
drake said:Disagree completely.
Gasnier certainly added to Best's try tally, but Gaz running out of the line and leaving Best with 2 on 1 was the culprit for the bad defence in most instances.
And how can you Knights fans say George Carmont!? Stranger reckons he's better than Nathan Blacklock, the leading try scorer 2000-2003.
U've got to be kidding. Kite is our only frontrower to constantly make 100+ metreseffnic said:Definetly Brent Kite the guy has done nothing for us but drop balls.
Caged Panther said:I'm not sure whether to take you seriously or not.
We've had some doozies but not for a while.Raiders Plight said:Im waiting for someone to do a list for the cowboys...
He is not even half the player he was at the saints.Disco said:U've got to be kidding. Kite is our only frontrower to constantly make 100+ metres
nqboy said:We've had some doozies but not for a while.
The last I can remember was Paul McNicholas, big as a mountain but an absolute nuffy for us.
Before that, let me see... We mortgaged the clubhouse for Brett Hetherington when Sheensy told us he was the next big thing. He got injured at the start of each season three years in a row and left with a motza, never to be heard from again.
Paul Green and Ivan Henjak, bought at the same time. The committee met one night and one bloke said, "Guess what? I've signed a halfback for next year." And the other bloke said, "Yeah, me too." D-OH!!! Neither was much chop for us.
Of course, there've been any number of locals and young hopefuls that tried out without ever making it but I'm trying to think more of the big names that came up here and took our money for very little return.
There are probably plenty of others in the early days when we had to pay overs for good players in the twilight of their career (as they were the only ones who would come up here) or damaged goods from othe clubs but I just can't think of any off-hand.