What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Do you want Brad Arthur as coach

Do you want Brad Arthur as coach

  • Yes

    Votes: 108 48.4%
  • No

    Votes: 115 51.6%

  • Total voters
    223

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
11,967
BRAD ARTHUR - Eels

Entering his 11th full season at the Eels with just one grand final and zero premierships, Brad Arthur will be feeling the heat.

He may have made the 2022 decider, but his side slumped badly to miss the finals last season.

While it is not Arthur’s fault the Eels have the longest premiership drought in the NRL dating back to 1986, with every year that drought continues, the pressure grows on the coach at the helm, especially one that has been there more than a decade.

The Eels missed the finals for a number of reasons last season, including the departure of key players, injuries and suspensions, but given the roster he has at his disposal there will be no excuses if they can’t get back to the finals and push for the top four in 2024.

The Eels have arguably the third best halves pairing in the NRL in Mitchell Moses and Dylan Brown and the playmakers need to earn their big money contracts, given that the club has struggled to replace hooker Reed Mahoney since his defection to the Bulldogs.

With one of the best packs in the game and excellent backs including skipper Clint Gutherson and centre Will Penisini, the Eels have the players to make a deep finals run.

Arthur has been consistent as a coach for the Eels over a long period, but unless he can get them a lot closer to their ultimate goal in 2024, it might be in both parties’ best interests to go their separate ways.

1707872824546.png

 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
11,967
Are we in agreement that a preliminary final appearance is the minimum KPI for BA in 2024?
Hard to disagree we have a squad that is capable of making the top 4.

I think we will make the Prelim anyway that was my prediction in the thread.

When you think about 3 or 4 games we lost on Goal-Kicking was the difference between 4th and 10th last year.

Throw in all the other stupidity that happened from senior players with suspensions. Take all that away we should be in the 4.

Drown & Moses have been together now for 5 seasons and should be in the top 3 or 4 halves combinations in the game.

Throw in a NSW state of origin front rower in RCG and a warrior at the back in Gutho.

Top 6 should be the bare minimum and capable of making a prelim from there we have enough big game experience now to win finals if we make it.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
11,967
To be fair, I would argue they already are. They just didn't play together enough last season for obvious reasons.
Well yeah your right whose better at club land and been around for as long as those 2 have been together.

Cleary and Luai
Munster and Hughes

Are the only 2 halves pairings I reckon that may have more experience playing together then our two.
 

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
52,030
Are we in agreement that a preliminary final appearance is the minimum KPI for BA in 2024?
We’ve had 10 years to assess whether we want him. Any decision to punt him should be based on his overall input, rather than what he does in one year.

He’s stayed because we have never realistically had an opportunity to jag a coach that’s a tier above (Bennett, Bellamy, Robinson, Cleary).

That changes now that Bennett signs with us for 2025.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
151,177
We’ve had 10 years to assess whether we want him. Any decision to punt him should be based on his overall input, rather than what he does in one year.

He’s stayed because we have never realistically had an opportunity to jag a coach that’s a tier above (Bennett, Bellamy, Robinson, Cleary).

That changes now that Bennett signs with us for 2025.

if Benny is CD it doesn't mean BA is gone, be interresting to see how it plays out should it happen tho
 

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
52,030
if Benny is CD it doesn't mean BA is gone, be interresting to see how it plays out should it happen tho
Agreed. Gould is CD at the Dogs, but only an idiot would think he isn’t intimately involved with coaching decisions. Crooked ankle Ciraldo is just a puppet.

I’d see the same with Bennett at the eels.
 

Latest posts

Top