Opinion
Sydney’s rusty rail network poses political pitfalls for Premier
The Premier may be losing sleep over Sydney’s repeated and inevitable rail failures, but commuters are losing their time, patience, and tempers.
James O'DohertyState Political Editor
Daily Telegraph
May 23, 2025 - 11:46AM
https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/n...tical-pitfalls-for-premier/news-story/5e8b6c66ecc7438e25c60614918d6c7e#comments
Sydney’s rail network is so fragile, so flimsy and so frail that Premier Chris Minns is literally losing sleep over it.
“I stay up nights worrying about this,” Minns declared on Wednesday, after a single overhead wire fault sent a city of more than five million people into total meltdown.
Those sleepless nights are entirely justified. Failures of the mass transport networks do not just leave countless commuters in the lurch; they can also lose governments elections.
Nothing else within the state government’s power has the terrible capacity to screw up everybody’s day, every day, twice a day.
Transport boffins are still yet to work out the exact cause of Tuesday’s catastrophe, which means they cannot promise that it will not happen again – whether that’s tomorrow, next week, or next month.
Commuters were left stranded for more than 24 hours due to Tuesday’s disaster. Picture: Thomas Lisson
The network breakdowns would be bad enough on their own, but they are made worse by the fact that train performance is in the pits, even on a good day.
The government has not met its on-time running targets, where 92 per cent of services arrive within five minutes of their scheduled arrival time, since January last year.
For the majority of this year, one in five trains has run late. And we haven’t had a consistently reliable service since the end of 2021.
Passengers queued for hundreds of metres for buses at Lidcombe on Wednesday. Picture: Justin Lloyd.
Minns announced he would hold a “short and sharp” review into the rail network following this week’s debacle.
That is not going to cut it, particularly when the government is still yet to implement findings from the last review into exactly the same thing.
That review, we revealed this week, cost almost $700,000 in contractors alone.
All lines but the T4 were impacted in the latest rail meltdown.
It took crews 12 hours to clear the damage. Picture Thomas Lisson
It identified maintenance backlogs which are yet to be fixed (delayed, in part, by industrial action) and failings in incident management.
Any review must look into how the network can be untangled.
There was a reason that commuters on the T4 Eastern Suburbs and Illawarra line were spared the brunt of the rail chaos this week; that line runs independently to the rest of the network.
A respected former transport boss also thinks that the government should carve up the bureaucracy and begin again.
Power was only turned back on after 7am on Wednesday. Picture Thomas Lisson
Former transport tsar John Lee argues that amalgamating the rail operations into Transport for NSW has diluted the capacity of Sydney Trains to keep things running.
He thinks the government should go back to the future with a new railway “authority,” similar to the State Transit Authority he once ran for the bus network.
“At the turn of the century the railways in Victoria, NSW and Queensland were literally run by authorities,” Lee says.
Those authorities could exert “command and control of operations”, he says, who could actually get things done.
Trains were running at limited capacity all of Wednesday. Picture Thomas Lisson
“There’s been a devolution of that authority over time, and what it has done is reduce the focus.”
In a perfect world, we would do away with heavy rail for good for suburban commutes, by building more Metro lines.
This week, it was the Metro that came to the rescue. The only problems people faced getting onto services in the city was that it was too popular, and the escalators to the platforms were going the wrong way.
Chris Minns says he is losing sleep over the state of the rail network. Picture: NewsWire / Nikki Short
While trains were sitting idle, Metro services were actually increased to handle the extra load.
If Opposition Leader Mark Speakman was smart, he would use the repeated rail meltdowns to announce he would go all in on Metro lines.
Unshackled by Labor’s aversion to privatisation, Speakman could promise to court private investment to fund the infrastructure of the 21st century.
If the Sydney City Metro had been opened before the last state election, then-premier Dominic Perrottet would have used the immense popularity of the network to push ahead on other lines that have since been delayed, pushed back, or shelved.
Voters will punish Labor at the polls if rail chaos continues. Picture: NewsWire / Nikki Short
Instead, construction of new Metro rail links to Sydney’s west will not start until 2040, if they are ever built at all.
Labor made the right call in going ahead with Metro West, but there are other crucial links – particularly to the Western Sydney airport – that he has put on the back burner.
For Minns, offering a paltry fare-free day on Monday will do nothing to assuage commuters’ anger, particularly when the entire city ground to a halt for more than 24 hours.
Minns described the failure as a “big, red, loud warning,” acknowledging that commuters have the government on a “very short leash”. That leash is getting shorter.
The Premier needs to spend those sleepless nights working out how he is going to ensure Sydney has a rail network that is actually up to the job.