08 :: R16 Sat :: Sea Eagles 28 Knights 12 @ Bluetongue

[Dutchy]

No, but gee it'll be embarrassing for you lot when you lose to a Knights side missing Buderus, Gidley and Cross :lol: when you're at full strength minus Stewart

Kids and Stewy cancel out
King and Cross cancel out

Only Bedsy out

 

[Jobdog]

Kidley ----> Stewart
Cross ----> King

Bedsy ------------> the whole Manly team

 

[Dutchy]

Kidley ----> Stewart
Cross ----> King

Bedsy ------------> the whole Manly team

Rofl

Rofl

Yeah, Bedsy = God.

 

[macavity]

you would take King over Cross?

:lol:

oh, and Gids ------> Stewart too

 

[macavity]

Oh fuggin please. You're in the top eight aren't you? The Bulldogs have no Origin reps, they're crap, and they're at the bottom of the ladder - I'm not complaining about the draw we've got. Some of you Knights fans dead set aren't happy unless you're bitching about something you perceive as unfair.

wow, you really are stupid sometimes.

draw = unfair.
newcastle = worst draw in comp
dogs = shyte regardless of draw

its pretty simple.

 

[Dutchy]

you would take King over Cross?

:lol:

oh, and Gids ------> Stewart too

There is no way Gidley is better than Stewart

Whos NSW #1 again?

Stewart was NSW's best in SOO2, Gidley was one of the worst when he was on the field. Stewarts try scoring record speaks for itself and the past 2 seasons has become a great defensive fullback as well.

 

[Jobdog]

There is no way Gidley is better than Stewart

Whos NSW #1 again?

Stewart was NSW's best in SOO2, Gidley was one of the worst when he was on the field. Stewarts try scoring record speaks for itself and the past 2 seasons has become a great defensive fullback as well.

Only because NSW were down by 20 when he came on so he tried to spark things, which obviously didn't come off. You can't blame him for that.

 

[wittyfan]

Minichiello's constant injury worries is the only thing keeping Stewart in the team.

 

[Dutchy]

Mini will never play rep footy again.

NSW spot is Stewarts to keep.

 

[Timmah]

wow, you really are stupid sometimes.

draw = unfair.
newcastle = worst draw in comp
dogs = shyte regardless of draw

its pretty simple.

Maybe if you tried understanding my point you'd be getting it. Newcastle are playing well enough to be in contention, regardless of the draw. Melbourne are clearly the hardest done by this year with the draw.

 

[perverse]

gidley and stewart are on par in regards to their value as a fullback... but they play completely different games. gidleys utility value is still too tempting to ignore for selectors - which is the reason they are not directly competing for the number 1 jersey.

stewart has the spot nailed down, no doubt... but he certainly doesn't want to get injured or have a drop in form.. because once gidley gets a shot in his best position he too will be hard to displace. personally i think it's great that NSW have great depth in at least 1 position on the field.

 

[Jatz Crackers]

:lol: 1997 still tears you up inside, doesn't it? Bee ay eye tee eye enn gee

Not at all. Manly is top of the table & will make the GF this year. Newcastle are an afterthought.

Of course the real bonus ius im not a dikhead newcastle supporter.

Comfortably happy I am, whilst also dodging the b a i t i n g

 

[Jobdog]

Not at all. Manly is top of the table & will make the GF this year. Newcastle are an afterthought.

Of course the real bonus ius im not a dikhead newcastle supporter.

Comfortably happy I am, whilst also dodging the b a i t i n g

:lol: No, you're just a dickhead Manly supporter.

And Manly will make the Grand Final will they? Got that trusty crystal ball out I see :crazy:

 

[Jatz Crackers]

:lol: No, you're just a dickhead Manly supporter.

And Manly will make the Grand Final will they? Got that trusty crystal ball out I see :crazy:

Dont need it.

 

[Harold Bishop]

you would take King over Cross?

:lol:

oh, and Gids ------> Stewart too

Based on form before his injury King was going a lot better than Cross. He has been a nonentity for the Knights.
Perry and Kite obviously are better than him as well

 

[Maroon and White]

you would take King over Cross?

:lol:

oh, and Gids ------> Stewart too

In all seriousnous, I would take Cross over King, by the length of the straight, and Stewart over Gidley by the same margin

 

[Maroon and White]

wow, you really are stupid sometimes.

draw = unfair.
newcastle = worst draw in comp
dogs = shyte regardless of draw

its pretty simple.

Biggest whingers - the NZ cricket team or the Newcastle Knights? Only a struck match between them

 

[Maroon and White]

gidley and stewart are on par in regards to their value as a fullback... but they play completely different games. gidleys utility value is still too tempting to ignore for selectors - which is the reason they are not directly competing for the number 1 jersey.

stewart has the spot nailed down, no doubt... but he certainly doesn't want to get injured or have a drop in form.. because once gidley gets a shot in his best position he too will be hard to displace. personally i think it's great that NSW have great depth in at least 1 position on the field.

Gidley? The classic good club footballer/average rep footballer. He has done absolutely nothing of note in rep football

 

[Hutty1986]

Mini will never play rep footy again.

NSW spot is Stewarts to keep.

Stewart is a better player than Gidley, simple as that!

 

[Timmah]

Stewart is a better player than Gidley, simple as that!

Wouldn't call one better than the other IMO - one's a career fullback, the other a versatile utility who is best used at fullback.