'10 | R5 | Fri | Dragons 34-16 Broncos | WIN

[andrew057]

Thaiday was the best player on the field.

 

[thommo4pm]

Thaiday was the best player on the field.

He sure was Brisbane's best player on the field.

 

[Apey]

I love it too being a PJ fan, it's been used the last few weeks. I've noticed it on a few of the games. /thumbs up

that's where else I noticed it, fox are doing it too. awesome! PJ love.

 

[_Johnsy]

Dragons should've slaughtered this Broncos side with 8 players out and all the soft penalties going their way...

Do you forget 2003, Saints had 9 regular first grade players out and beat Brisbane (full strength) in Brisbane.

Are you really using excuses already, were not even 6 weeks in ?

 

[Anon]

Mate its pretty simple stuff, you can not run behind a player, its a shepard and has been ruled a penalty all season, bar a try for Manly that Finch came out and said the refs made a mistake.

The penalty was for obstruction (there is no such offence as a shepherd). In every scenario provided in the laws of the game you will find that for an obstruction penalty to be awarded a defending team player must first have been obstructed.

 

[Ulysseus]

Do you forget 2003, Saints had 9 regular first grade players out and beat Brisbane (full strength) in Brisbane.

Are you really using excuses already, were not even 6 weeks in ?

lol, I remember it all right.
Creagh scored after jumping up and grabbing a bomb and in the end it came down to Piggy kicking a penalty goal from some spastic distance to clinch it by one point.

and just in case anyone forgot how much of a reserve grade team it was:

[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]Fullback: 17. Reece Simmonds, Wingers: 24. Hassan Saleh, 5. Ben Creagh
Centres: 23. John Wilshere, 20. Chris Nero,
Five Eighth: 1. Ben Hornby, Halfback: 7. Mathew Head,
Front Row: 8. Luke Bailey, 9. Mark Riddell, 10. Chris Leikvoll*,
Second Row: 11. Brent Kite, 13. Dean Young, Lock: 6. Shaun Timmins (c).
Interchange:12. John Cross*, 14. Ashton Sims, 15. Craig Stapleton*, 21. Robbie Simpson.[/FONT]