'13 | R13 | Sun | Panthers 18-20 Tigers | Centrebet

[super_coach]

I think the tigers are in a similar boat to Penrith with their second tier salary cap with such a massive injury toll they may struggle to get 17 players for next week. Anyway they showed heaps of ticker to win against the odds

 

[Vic Mackey]

Seriously the way panthers fans are carrying on you'd think they had Greg inglis, sonny bill and Lebron James ruled out by the nrl

 

[Caged Panther]

Seriously the way panthers fans are carrying on you'd think they had Greg inglis, sonny bill and Lebron James ruled out by the nrl

For us Moylan might as well be Inglis...

 

[Adman]

The Tigers played the game for 80 (surprisingly) and the Panthers didn't. Simple as that. Thoroughly deserved with 13 or how ever many sitting on the bench and 16 on the field.

Tigers keep on fighting.

 

[gronkathon]

Another game won in spite of Marshall not because of him.

f**k me he is ordinary

 

[Marshall_magic]

A good win but geez Marshall is living off his reputation big time. We won because some of our lesser names stepped it up. Benji was a big time passenger. Good to get a win without Robbie though, will definitely help some of these young guys.

 

[gronkathon]

The Moylan thing was a bad situation made worse by how Panthers management handled it.

It was like a ready made excuse to lose that the players bought in to lock, stock etc.

 

[HankScorpio]

If any panthers fan blames no moylan for that loss they are deluded. You were camped on our line for multiple periods during the second half and couldn't score, if you were good enough you would have won.

Completely right. We should've closed it out but got lazy and they took their chances. Good win Tigpies, hopefully we'll get you next time.

 

[Tipster]

Superb wins by the Tigers

One of the best in recent seasons

 

[mxlegend99]

Panthers with Moylan - 80% win rate (4/5 games)
Panthers with Wes Naiqama - 14% win rate (1/7 games)

Outside of a win in Round 1, Panthers have looked deadset shit in every game Wes has played for us. He is terrible and the results with him in the team are awful, while the results without him in the team are excellent. Our season is well and truly over if we are forced to select him just because he is available.

He is a non existent last line of defence. He offers nothing in attack and he has no ball playing skills. Yet the NRL would rather have him running around then a future star of the game.

 

[franklin2323]

If any panthers fan blames no moylan for that loss they are deluded.

Not just him. Robinson was ruled out then got a reprive. Grant & Roberts ruled out on Game eve. Giving us a terrible preparation. These things happen.

Though on Moylan watch our attack yesterday to our 1st 6 weeks. Practically identical the change has been Moylan. Moylan has the deft touches like for our 1st try against Dragons. We need to create numbers. Not to mention 3 or linebreaks he would of supported.

That grubber in the ingoal Naiqama was no where. Simona break no support so he's not going to draw & pass he just hung back. In close games those things help.

That aside having Ciraldo & Newton as your only bench forwards leads to a loss. Segeyaro & Manu had some terrible 5th tackle options. Also didn't help

 

[Red Bear]

How good is Aaron Woods

 

[murraymob]

make no mistake penrith lost that game.The tigers are not that good.We will not win another game if wes naquima ciraldo newton are together in the same 17

Naquima is easily the worst fullback to ever pull on a panther jersey.Most good fullbacks will at least get to a ball after its kicked on the last by the 2nd bounce.He was getting there by the time it nearly has stoped

Newton has way to many mistakes in him to carry.His poor attempt at a off load just before half time cost a try and 6 points
Ciraldo is one of the biggest bodies in the club but as the saying goes built like tarzan runs like jane offers nothing

But as it stands we can not promote anyone from windsor as most of them would come under the same s3econd tier cap

Maybve its time to look at promoting some of the u20 boys who have had a few games at windsor it certainly cant be worse than the above 3

 

[Navjot]

We won that game with virtually an under 20 's and nsw cup strength side so if the tigers are not that good ,what does that say about Penriff, and losing koro in the first half on top of that!! 20 + injured players in alll grades they said, top win against the odds.

 

[super_coach]

Another game won in spite of Marshall not because of him.

f**k me he is ordinary

The last ten minutes when we had to defend a lead his kicking game was pretty good and he took the smart options, now plenty of times in the past he would have had a brain snap,like a chip kick or fifth tackle dash.

The other 70 minutes Iam with you, uninterested, lethargic and lack of involvement are thoughts that come to mind. Come 2014, throw Anasta the no6 jumper, he seem to be giving 100% every week and let Benji go to the highest bidder

 

[murraymob]

We won that game with virtually an under 20 's and nsw cup strength side so if the tigers are not that good ,what does that say about Penriff, and losing koro in the first half on top of that!! 20 + injured players in alll grades they said, top win against the odds.

And thats what i said we lost it.We had the game well under controll.The pushing passes by players who do not have that ability cost dearly as i said we sucked

 

[murraymob]

The last ten minutes when we had to defend a lead his kicking game was pretty good and he took the smart options, now plenty of times in the past he would have had a brain snap,like a chip kick or fifth tackle dash.

The other 70 minutes Iam with you, uninterested, lethargic and lack of involvement are thoughts that come to mind. Come 2014, throw Anasta the no6 jumper, he seem to be giving 100% every week and let Benji go to the highest bidder

just curious you see him a lot.Do you think he is worth the upgrade to 1 million he is asking for and i hear a 4 year deal with it

 

[pantherz9103]

Can't we just pay Naiqama to get injured? We should've won even carrying him in the team but with Moylan I think we would've got away with that game. Our short lived top 8 hopes now dashed thanks to the NRL's draconian laws.

 

[Wizardman]

You lost panther fans,......deal with it

 

[MrAnonymous]

We won that game with virtually an under 20 's and nsw cup strength side so if the tigers are not that good ,what does that say about Penriff, and losing koro in the first half on top of that!! 20 + injured players in alll grades they said, top win against the odds.

Yeah cause we dont have any injuries.