'15 | Origin 2 | Wed 17 Jun | NSW 26-18 QLD | MCG

[Pete Cash]

Let us just check the rulebook again Bileduct

Out of Play 2. An offside player shall not take any part in the game
or attempt in any way to influence the course of the
game.

 

[bileduct]

Let us just check the rulebook again Bileduct

I just quoted you the rule book and showed you photographic evidence Pete.

Too many cones today?

 

[Pete Cash]

What part of not taking "part in the game" are you struggling with mate ?

 

[Pete Cash]

I mean even the above picture you put does not put Inglis onside imo because his front foot never gets behind where Myles touched the ball but ignoring that he clearly started moving towards the ball before he put himself "onside"

 

[bileduct]

What part of not taking "part in the game" are you struggling with mate ?

Read this until it sinks in:

A player is placed onside if: (e) he retires behind the point where the ball was last touched by one of his own team.

 

[Pete Cash]

A player can't run around and get involved in the game and then run back onside ? That isn't how it works lmao.

 

[bileduct]

I mean even the above picture you put does not put Inglis onside imo because his front foot never gets behind where Myles touched the ball but ignoring that he clearly started moving towards the ball before he put himself "onside"

Your interpretation of the offside rule is literally the dumbest interpretation of any rule in the game I have come across.

How about you actually read the rule book I gave you the link to. Even in the example that they provide of a player coming from an offside position to pick up the player is doing EXACTLY what you claim to be illegal play.

 

[bileduct]

A player can't run around and get involved in the game and then run back onside ? That isn't how it works lmao.

Please hook me up with your dealer, you are clearly getting better shit than I am.

 

[Pete Cash]

Your interpretation of the offside rule is literally the dumbest interpretation of any rule in the game I have come across.

How about you actually read the rule book I gave you the link to. Even in the example that they provide of a player coming from an offside position to pick up the player is doing EXACTLY what you claim to be illegal play.

I am sorry that you think the correct interpretation is dumb but thems the rules mate.

 

[bileduct]

I am sorry that you think the correct interpretation is dumb but thems the rules mate.

Not really because that's not what the refs ruled, is it Pete.

 

[Pete Cash]

Please hook me up with your dealer, you are clearly getting better shit than I am.

No need to get sulky because you are wrong

 

[Pete Cash]

Not really because that's not what the refs ruled, is it Pete.

The rules clearly say that a player who is offside cannot get involved with the play until he is onside ?

Is this incorrect.

 

[bileduct]

The rules clearly say that a player who is offside cannot get involved with the play until he is onside ?

Is this incorrect.

Did the referees rule that Inglis was offside Pete?

 

[Pete Cash]

Did the referees rule that Inglis was offside Pete?

They didn't have to because QLD clearly knocked on in the lead up to try :lol:

Talk about clutching at straws.

 

[Pete Cash]

Clearly never gets both feet behind the point where Myles touched the ball. Please invest in some new glasses. He in fact starts playing at the ball as soon as play breaks down.

 

[bileduct]

Clearly never gets both feet behind the point where Myles touched the ball.

Pics I showed you before clearly show otherwise.

I'm sorry you're having a bad day, mate.

 

[Pete Cash]

Nice attempt at a recovery bileduct but you were wrong. Cool.

 

[beave]

It was the right call for f**ks sake, get over it.

 

[bileduct]

They didn't have to because QLD clearly knocked on in the lead up to try :lol:

Talk about clutching at straws.

So now you're saying that picking up the ball from an offside position while the ball is still in play is not a penalty, is that correct?

 

[Pete Cash]

So now you're saying that picking up the ball from an offside position while the ball is still in play is not a penalty, is that correct?

I am saying that the play was dead when Inglis did it ?