2003 GF Scott Sattler tackle vs 2004 GF Andrew Ryan tackle

[Didgi]

56-1 now :lol: ByRd did you accidently click the wrong button? :sarcasm:

 

[redvscotty]

WHAT THE f**k??!?! CREED??!?! REALLY?!?!?!

 

[Red Bear]

That's racist mang.

sh*t, been trying to cut down on that.

 

[Ghoulies]

WHAT THE f**k??!?! CREED??!?! REALLY?!?!?!

I'm voting Ryan because Creed are f**king awful.

 

[pantherz9103]

lol Sattler in a landslide

 

[aqua_duck]

Ryan was entitled to make that tackle, Crocker was his man and Crocker hadn't broken the line yet, it was good slide defence during a crucial part of the game.
Sattler ran down a winger (even if he was a slow one) and also a much younger man

 

[aids]

scatler

 

[gsweeper]

this shouldn't even be a poll, easily sattler

 

[ByRd]

56-1 now :lol: ByRd did you accidently click the wrong button? :sarcasm:

:lol::lol: i knew it was going to be a landslide so i thought id give Ryan one vote just for kicks, i see someone else has joined me lol

 

[ByRd]

:lol::lol::lol:

 

[keeney]

Simpson in 2001, bested both these douchebags.

 

[Bulldog Force]

I'll go (against the flow) with Ryan. Trying to be unbiased here, but this is my reasoning:

• Sattler's tackle occurred in the 54th minute, so the if the Roosters scored, the Panther still had 26 minutes to try and find a reply. If they couldn't find a reply, did they really deserve to win?
• Ryan's tackle occurred with 15 seconds left on the clock, and unlike Sattlers tackle, this ensured that the Bulldogs won the Grand Final.

 

[adamkungl]

:lol: It was blatantly obvious that was your opinion all along BF

 

[natheel]

sattler, that penrith win in 2003 seriously was one of the best feel good moments ive seen by a winning team

 

[redvscotty]

I'll go (against the flow) with Ryan. Trying to be unbiased here, but this is my reasoning:

• Sattler's tackle occurred in the 54th minute, so the if the Roosters scored, the Panther still had 26 minutes to try and find a reply. If they couldn't find a reply, did they really deserve to win?
• Ryan's tackle occurred with 15 seconds left on the clock, and unlike Sattlers tackle, this ensured that the Bulldogs won the Grand Final.

I love Bulldogs fans.

 

[redvscotty]

sattler, that penrith win in 2003 seriously was one of the best feel good moments ive seen by a winning team

I was watching the clip last night, and couldn't help but think 'f**k I hope Priddis is scoring like that for the Dragons come October'.

So good.

 

[Doga]

No Contest

 

[Eels Dude]

I'll go (against the flow) with Ryan. Trying to be unbiased here, but this is my reasoning:

• Sattler's tackle occurred in the 54th minute, so the if the Roosters scored, the Panther still had 26 minutes to try and find a reply. If they couldn't find a reply, did they really deserve to win?
• Ryan's tackle occurred with 15 seconds left on the clock, and unlike Sattlers tackle, this ensured that the Bulldogs won the Grand Final.

Against the flow... It's 85-3. Of those 3 votes one was yours so doesn't count, and another was ByRd who admitted the Sattler tackle but gave Ryan the vote just so he wasn't on zero.

 

[aqua_duck]

I'll go (against the flow) with Ryan. Trying to be unbiased here, but this is my reasoning:

• Sattler's tackle occurred in the 54th minute, so the if the Roosters scored, the Panther still had 26 minutes to try and find a reply. If they couldn't find a reply, did they really deserve to win?
• Ryan's tackle occurred with 15 seconds left on the clock, and unlike Sattlers tackle, this ensured that the Bulldogs won the Grand Final.

Why does the time in which the tackle occured determine how good the tackle is? By your reckoning Darren Albert's try in 97 will forever be the best try ever in all of rugby league

 

[Johns Magic]

I'll go (against the flow) with Ryan. Trying to be unbiased here, but this is my reasoning:

• Sattler's tackle occurred in the 54th minute, so the if the Roosters scored, the Panther still had 26 minutes to try and find a reply. If they couldn't find a reply, did they really deserve to win?
• Ryan's tackle occurred with 15 seconds left on the clock, and unlike Sattlers tackle, this ensured that the Bulldogs won the Grand Final.

But Crocker wasn't going to score???