What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2017 Origin I - QLD 4-28 NSW @ Suncorp

Game I: QLD v NSW


  • Total voters
    49
  • Poll closed .

slamminsam246

Juniors
Messages
525
it's funny how much criticism cronk has avoided because of his reputation, his kicking game was diabolical not counting the crossfield oates try. it was one of his most ordinary games i've seen and the reality is pearce outplayed him

Criticism should mainly be pointed at the selecters/coach who chose 1/3 halves that has a (origin level) kicking game. Nsw knew Cronk would do 90% of the kicking so Graham was assigned the reletively easy job of putting pressure on him
 

GongPanther

Referee
Messages
28,676
The entire NSW puts in an incredible game with every player contributing, not a single bad performance across the park, and some absolutely stunning dominant displays by Teddy and Fifita.....

....... and the poor widdle Pearce haters still can't stop ramming a dildo up their own arses trying to convince themselves that he deserves to be dropped.

The only thing better than watching NSW whitewash the maroons this series is knowing you wankers won't be able to enjoy it
Deleted post OzP.
 
Last edited:

Paullyboy

Coach
Messages
10,473
I can't be stuffed reading all this, did Klemmer get sighted for his coward shot when he dropped his elbow at full force into the back of a Queenslanders neck towards the end of the first half?

Or Fifita for his ridiculously obvious high shot on gillett?

Obviously nsw weren't going to get penalised, as it wasn't in the pre determined script, but do the match review committee just ignore it too?
 

Paullyboy

Coach
Messages
10,473
Credit to the Blues, they killed us all over the park. Absolutely no answer to Fifita and Klemmer, even Woods provided some handy offloads. Everyone else was an obvious beneficiary of that. Qld's wingers were probably their best players which says something about NSW's dominance.

I feel QLD stuck too solid with a conservative attacking plan for much of the game and failed to adapt to match the Blues. It's all well and good to go hit up after one out hit up in the middle of the field and bomb on fifth to trap the opposition down in their territory when you have Price, Petro or Scott in your pack, but you can't grind out a victory when your forwards are outmuscled that badly.

Perhaps the early kick so Morris/Fergo/Tedesco couldn't take the ball on the full was the option, or an earlier spread to Milford was the way to go. Milf looked very strong on his edge but stayed there. Not sure if he was overawed, or Walters told him to stay there to simplify his role.

Hard to see where QLD improve from here. They'll never match NSW's firepower in the middle of the field, but Wallace and Hess seem like an obvious upgrade from Lillyman/Myles/Guerra. Perhaps Thurston as another kicking option would improve things too. O'Neill was picked as a solid player and because Gagai was given a bath at centre by Hayne when the Knights played him. Perhaps throwing Gagai in there couldn't be worse given what O'Neill dished up.

As a one-eyed Bronco I defended Boyd's selection, but he'll be dissapointed with that performance tonight. Slater's involvement around the ruck was missed, but he was by no means the difference. Forwards were absolutely pummeled.

Pretty much summed up my thoughts
 

moffla

Bench
Messages
3,451
Quire clear both sides got away with a hell of a lot. Myles on Hayne, Fifita high shot are just 2 of many moments. Good to see it's left on the field and both teams are okay with it.
 

Paullyboy

Coach
Messages
10,473
Quire clear both sides got away with a hell of a lot. Myles on Hayne, Fifita high shot are just 2 of many moments. Good to see it's left on the field and both teams are okay with it.
It's not good though, it changed the game. NSW worked out at about the 20th minute mark that they could do absolutely anything and wouldn't get punished. The refs thought they were opening the game up, but in reality they just ruined it because NSW were only ever back 7 or 8 meters prior to each of their dirty shots.

Now it's fair to point out that NSW were the better team, but the refs made it a farce
 

Nice Beaver

First Grade
Messages
5,920
I can't be stuffed reading all this, did Klemmer get sighted for his coward shot when he dropped his elbow at full force into the back of a Queenslanders neck towards the end of the first half?

Or Fifita for his ridiculously obvious high shot on gillett?

Obviously nsw weren't going to get penalised, as it wasn't in the pre determined script, but do the match review committee just ignore it too?

So Skeepe isn't the only Canberra supporter unhinged.

Good to know.
 

Munted

Bench
Messages
4,216
It's not good though, it changed the game. NSW worked out at about the 20th minute mark that they could do absolutely anything and wouldn't get punished. The refs thought they were opening the game up, but in reality they just ruined it because NSW were only ever back 7 or 8 meters prior to each of their dirty shots.

Now it's fair to point out that NSW were the better team, but the refs made it a farce
Haha. Suck a f**k you salty merkin.
 

The_Shield

Juniors
Messages
1,895
I don't think there will be to many changes for game 2. But they have to make some. For instance bringing Slater to fullback, Thurston to 5/8, Chambers right centre, Holmes on the wing, Milford to replace Morgan on the bench, Wallace to replace Myles, Kaufusi and Hess to replace Guerra and Lillyman
 

Latest posts

Top