What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2019 FW3 Fri - Raiders 16-10 Rabbitohs @ GIO

Finals Week 3: Raiders v Rabbitohs


  • Total voters
    41
  • Poll closed .

Silent Knight

First Grade
Messages
8,182
Souths are going to f**king destroy these fecal raider merkins.

The Viking clap has to be the most embarrassing thing in world sports.

Ricky Stuart is a perpetual f**king flop.

f**k you green merkins

Nope calling yourself the Pride of the League when you play in a mostly vacant home stadium, as well as Dane Gagai’s defensive technique are more embarrassing.
 

Galeforce

Bench
Messages
2,602
U wot m8?

Walker shouldn’t have been sin binned? Douhei got head slammed? :joy: it was nothing more then an old fashioned facial

I said in the game day thread both manlys sin binnings were correct. You can say a penalty try should have been awarded to Roberts, I disagree. Either way you scored when they had 12 men anyway, so you actually got more of an advantage then a straight penalty try.

Manly scored 2 tries after mistakes? You know how many tries Souths scored after penalties? 5. You didn’t need to work your way downfield once.

9-3 penalty count. 60 mins against 12 men. Did I say any of these were wrong? No. But if you don’t think that’s an example of things going your way then I don’t know what you could think is. Then again you’re a Souths fan so I guess winning lop sided penalty counts is just something you’re used to. This isn’t even mentioning that Manly were missing 3 of their best players against a full strength line Souths.

I can only assume you believe they’ll win on Friday given your post. I wish you all the best.

I am saying , if everything was going Souths way , as you stated
then ,
1)Walker would not have been sin binned , and if he was so should have the Manly player
2) Souths should have gotten a penalty try , they did not , which only proves , NOT everything went Souths way
3) Penalty count was due to Manly giving away penalties for illegal plays.......e.g. second half 4 penalties to Souths.......1) for trip on Roberts, 2) for taking Roberts out in the air 3)for Jake's grabbing Gagai illegally 4) for Manly giving away penalty for taking too long to do a line kick. Other than those , the refs allowed both teams to do whatever .Nothing to do with things going Souths way .......Manly did things that required a penalty for all to see.

4) Souths played with 12 men for 70 minutes , had 1 try against them during the 12 man period

5) Manly played with 12 men for 60 minutes , scored 1 and had 2 scored against them

6) giving away a penalty for illegal play is same as losing the ball when in your territory.
BOTH bad , both give advantage to other team. What is your point? My point , is if Souths maintained their discipline with the ball , THEN they would have taken advantage of the Manly illegal plays and Manly would not have been in the game.

I think Raiders derserve to be favourites and DEFINITELY Souths will need everything to go their way to beat the Raiders at their home. However against Manly , Souths showed plenty of heart to win in game where they gave Manly too many chances to stay in the game.
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,261
I am saying , if everything was going Souths way , as you stated
then ,
1)Walker would not have been sin binned , and if he was so should have the Manly player
2) Souths should have gotten a penalty try , they did not , which only proves , NOT everything went Souths way
3) Penalty count was due to Manly giving away penalties for illegal plays.......e.g. second half 4 penalties to Souths.......1) for trip on Roberts, 2) for taking Roberts out in the air 3)for Jake's grabbing Gagai illegally 4) for Manly giving away penalty for taking too long to do a line kick. Other than those , the refs allowed both teams to do whatever .Nothing to do with things going Souths way .......Manly did things that required a penalty for all to see.

4) Souths played with 12 men for 70 minutes , had 1 try against them during the 12 man period

5) Manly played with 12 men for 60 minutes , scored 1 and had 2 scored against them

6) giving away a penalty for illegal play is same as losing the ball when in your territory.
BOTH bad , both give advantage to other team. What is your point? My point , is if Souths maintained their discipline with the ball , THEN they would have taken advantage of the Manly illegal plays and Manly would not have been in the game.

I think Raiders derserve to be favourites and DEFINITELY Souths will need everything to go their way to beat the Raiders at their home. However against Manly , Souths showed plenty of heart to win in game where they gave Manly too many chances to stay in the game.
haw haw haw
 

Meapro Ham

Juniors
Messages
1,813
I am saying , if everything was going Souths way , as you stated
then ,
1)Walker would not have been sin binned , and if he was so should have the Manly player
2) Souths should have gotten a penalty try , they did not , which only proves , NOT everything went Souths way
3) Penalty count was due to Manly giving away penalties for illegal plays.......e.g. second half 4 penalties to Souths.......1) for trip on Roberts, 2) for taking Roberts out in the air 3)for Jake's grabbing Gagai illegally 4) for Manly giving away penalty for taking too long to do a line kick. Other than those , the refs allowed both teams to do whatever .Nothing to do with things going Souths way .......Manly did things that required a penalty for all to see.

4) Souths played with 12 men for 70 minutes , had 1 try against them during the 12 man period

5) Manly played with 12 men for 60 minutes , scored 1 and had 2 scored against them

6) giving away a penalty for illegal play is same as losing the ball when in your territory.
BOTH bad , both give advantage to other team. What is your point? My point , is if Souths maintained their discipline with the ball , THEN they would have taken advantage of the Manly illegal plays and Manly would not have been in the game.

I think Raiders derserve to be favourites and DEFINITELY Souths will need everything to go their way to beat the Raiders at their home. However against Manly , Souths showed plenty of heart to win in game where they gave Manly too many chances to stay in the game.

That’s nitpicking
 

SBD82

Coach
Messages
17,849
I am saying , if everything was going Souths way , as you stated
then ,
1)Walker would not have been sin binned , and if he was so should have the Manly player
2) Souths should have gotten a penalty try , they did not , which only proves , NOT everything went Souths way
3) Penalty count was due to Manly giving away penalties for illegal plays.......e.g. second half 4 penalties to Souths.......1) for trip on Roberts, 2) for taking Roberts out in the air 3)for Jake's grabbing Gagai illegally 4) for Manly giving away penalty for taking too long to do a line kick. Other than those , the refs allowed both teams to do whatever .Nothing to do with things going Souths way .......Manly did things that required a penalty for all to see.

4) Souths played with 12 men for 70 minutes , had 1 try against them during the 12 man period

5) Manly played with 12 men for 60 minutes , scored 1 and had 2 scored against them

6) giving away a penalty for illegal play is same as losing the ball when in your territory.
BOTH bad , both give advantage to other team. What is your point? My point , is if Souths maintained their discipline with the ball , THEN they would have taken advantage of the Manly illegal plays and Manly would not have been in the game.

I think Raiders derserve to be favourites and DEFINITELY Souths will need everything to go their way to beat the Raiders at their home. However against Manly , Souths showed plenty of heart to win in game where they gave Manly too many chances to stay in the game.
This rant was bullshit the first time.
 

veggiepatch1959

First Grade
Messages
9,841
I am saying , if everything was going Souths way , as you stated
then ,
1)Walker would not have been sin binned , and if he was so should have the Manly player
2) Souths should have gotten a penalty try , they did not , which only proves , NOT everything went Souths way
3) Penalty count was due to Manly giving away penalties for illegal plays.......e.g. second half 4 penalties to Souths.......1) for trip on Roberts, 2) for taking Roberts out in the air 3)for Jake's grabbing Gagai illegally 4) for Manly giving away penalty for taking too long to do a line kick. Other than those , the refs allowed both teams to do whatever .Nothing to do with things going Souths way .......Manly did things that required a penalty for all to see.

4) Souths played with 12 men for 70 minutes , had 1 try against them during the 12 man period

5) Manly played with 12 men for 60 minutes , scored 1 and had 2 scored against them

6) giving away a penalty for illegal play is same as losing the ball when in your territory.
BOTH bad , both give advantage to other team. What is your point? My point , is if Souths maintained their discipline with the ball , THEN they would have taken advantage of the Manly illegal plays and Manly would not have been in the game.

I think Raiders derserve to be favourites and DEFINITELY Souths will need everything to go their way to beat the Raiders at their home. However against Manly , Souths showed plenty of heart to win in game where they gave Manly too many chances to stay in the game.
1) South Sydney played 80 minutes with 15 men on the field.

So there....
 

GongPanther

Referee
Messages
28,676
Souths are going to f**king destroy these fecal raider merkins.

The Viking clap has to be the most embarrassing thing in world sports.

Ricky Stuart is a perpetual f**king flop.

f**k you green merkins
Souths do have it in them to get the Raiders. Two or three quick tries by a Rabbits outfit that IMO is the speediest in the comp, and the Raiders will be in all sorts. Problem is, if Souths score 4 tries, can they prevent the Raiders from scoring 4 to 6?

I still think Canb by 44-4.
 

GongPanther

Referee
Messages
28,676
So the Under 20s Grand Final this weekend is also between Souths and Raiders but NSWRL won’t play the game before the Prelim. Good job.
They want to play the GF next week on the same day as the Reserve grade GF next Sunday at Parra Park.

On Saturday, the Sydney Shield and the Ron Massey cup will be at Parra Park.

All games live on NSWRL.com or NRL.com

On GF day, the woman's GF ( I always could do with a laugh) will be firs, then the nation championship Reserve grade game between the winners of both NSW and Qld comps. Then the NRL borefest after that.
 
Last edited:

2 weeks

Coach
Messages
16,586
I reckon this is Josh Hodgson's favourite song

I've been caught stealing
Once when I was 5
I enjoy stealing
It's just as simple as that
Well, it's just a simple fact
When I want something,
I don't want to pay for it
I walk right through the door
Walk right through the door
Hey all right!
If I get by, it's mine
Mine all mine!
My girl, she's one too
She'll go and get her a shirt
Stick it under her skirt
She grabbed a razor for me
And she did it just like that
When she wants something, she don't want to pay for it
She walk right through the door
Walk right through the door
Hey all right!
If I get by, it's mine
Mine all mine!
We sat around the pile
We sat and laughed
We sat and laughed and waved it into the air!
And we did it just like that
When we want something, we don't want to pay for it
We walk right through the door
Walk right through the door
Hey, all right!
If I get by, it's mine, mine, mine, mine, mine, mine, mine. . .
 

Mr Spock!

Referee
Messages
22,502
U wot m8?

Walker shouldn’t have been sin binned? Douhei got head slammed? :joy: it was nothing more then an old fashioned facial

I said in the game day thread both manlys sin binnings were correct. You can say a penalty try should have been awarded to Roberts, I disagree. Either way you scored when they had 12 men anyway, so you actually got more of an advantage then a straight penalty try.

Manly scored 2 tries after mistakes? You know how many tries Souths scored after penalties? 5. You didn’t need to work your way downfield once.

9-3 penalty count. 60 mins against 12 men. Did I say any of these were wrong? No. But if you don’t think that’s an example of things going your way then I don’t know what you could think is. Then again you’re a Souths fan so I guess winning lop sided penalty counts is just something you’re used to. This isn’t even mentioning that Manly were missing 3 of their best players against a full strength line Souths.

I can only assume you believe they’ll win on Friday given your post. I wish you all the best.
Cough...Dylan Walker sin bin....cough.....

Moanly's own fault for not winning that.
 

AlwaysGreen

Post Whore
Messages
50,125
I reckon this is Josh Hodgson's favourite song

I've been caught stealing
Once when I was 5
I enjoy stealing
It's just as simple as that
Well, it's just a simple fact
When I want something,
I don't want to pay for it
I walk right through the door
Walk right through the door
Hey all right!
If I get by, it's mine
Mine all mine!
My girl, she's one too
She'll go and get her a shirt
Stick it under her skirt
She grabbed a razor for me
And she did it just like that
When she wants something, she don't want to pay for it
She walk right through the door
Walk right through the door
Hey all right!
If I get by, it's mine
Mine all mine!
We sat around the pile
We sat and laughed
We sat and laughed and waved it into the air!
And we did it just like that
When we want something, we don't want to pay for it
We walk right through the door
Walk right through the door
Hey, all right!
If I get by, it's mine, mine, mine, mine, mine, mine, mine. . .
Hmmmm.
Tim Allen has pretty much used the same material for his whole career, albeit successfully.
Maybe stick to your gifs.
 

2 weeks

Coach
Messages
16,586
Hmmmm.
Tim Allen has pretty much used the same material for his whole career, albeit successfully.
Maybe stick to your gifs.

VD6ZmGq.gif
 

pantherz9103

First Grade
Messages
9,617
Surprising that the Raiders home record is actually quite ordinary this year, only 50%.

They still should beat the Rabbitohs and make their first Grand Final since 1994. However a Bennett's Bunnies ambush and Raiders bottle job is not unthinkable, just unlikely and undesirable.
 

Latest posts

Top