franklin2323
Immortal
- Messages
- 33,546
Maybe but that's a different topic entirely to Girds being concerned about his size.
If Girds is right though then need a plan B
Maybe but that's a different topic entirely to Girds being concerned about his size.
I see Ivan going this way unfortunately but we'll see in the trials.
Luai plays 6 in first grade or 6 in reggies. He has no ability to be anything else
Cleary has this label of not being super creative but he really is an excellent half and has developed each year he has been in first grade.Interesting comments by Ryan Girdler here. He thinks we'll struggle to score points, and that Nathan just isn't creative enough. He also doesn't think Luai is up to the rigours of FG.
https://wwos.nine.com.au/nrl/nrl-gr...s-season/5c814373-8bae-4aac-9350-19d8d10f70bc
If Girds is right though then need a plan B
Well he's wrong about the weight thing. The outcome of not scoring could be true but it was in 2019 so it's not exactly a revolutionary thought. He's really just tipping them not to have any improvement.
Didn’t say no improvement just will struggle in attack. Given it is the most inexperienced spine then it is a decent prediction.
I think we make the 8 but I think we do winning games like 14-8 etc. I think we will pick a solid side that is not to lose games instead a side to blow teams away
By saying will struggle in attack he's saying we'll be the same as last year since we've sucked since at least 2017.
I agree with your assessment of how our year will go. We have new combinations and now Dill injured will hurt our ladder position a little even more so with some spots decided by F/A.
Our spine has been changed up every year since then. The issue this year isn’t lack of talent just needing time to develop as is the case with the centres
Predicting us struggling to score is a fairly logical prediction tbf, we struggled mightily in this area last season and we have lost a noted attacking half in Jimmy. Now I personally think we will make improvements in this area and Jimmy won’t be a massive loss, but I can see how someone would predict we are going to struggle. Our hope is the new attacking coach plus Cleary and Jerome stepping up behind a very good pack as well as a creative and classy hooker being added. I’m not expecting miracles by any means but I do think we will get better.
Predicting us struggling to score is a fairly logical prediction tbf, we struggled mightily in this area last season and we have lost a noted attacking half in Jimmy. Now I personally think we will make improvements in this area and Jimmy won’t be a massive loss, but I can see how someone would predict we are going to struggle. Our hope is the new attacking coach plus Cleary and Jerome stepping up behind a very good pack as well as a creative and classy hooker being added. I’m not expecting miracles by any means but I do think we will get better.
Definitely. We need some combinations in the spine long term. Even Tedesco and Cronk took half a season to gel with the Roosters and they are the best of the best.
Exactly It's the safe prediction without having to look to hard at the roster and surrounding context. Sounds like Girds is trying to be like the mainstream journos more than anything.
I love Girds and I’m not insinuating he has a vendetta or anything, I’m sure he is giving his honest opinions but I know he wasn’t happy with the way the hook/Cleary thing went down, he is probably not going to have my optimism which is understandable.
I have no concerns long term just it will take atleast a season for combinations to develop and Luai/Burton getting used to FG. Same with outside backs Naden will be better. Crichton too even if he starts the year in Flegg (As unlikely as it is)
Yep there are a lot of young guys looking to claim their spots hopefully the staff can manage it well because some of these guys can be really good players.
Cleary has this label of not being super creative but he really is an excellent half and has developed each year he has been in first grade.
Luai may not look like every other 5/8 in the game but that’s what I like about him, you can’t tell what he is going to do.
He can’t be a worse defender than jimmy and if he fails May and Burton are waiting for a chance.
Some halves have players around them that only need half a chance to score a try.
We don’t have that. mansour, Edwards and Whare need to be handed a gift to score and are still a good chance of bombing it.
It’s a team sport, the halves have to set up tries but their job is so much easier if you have a fullback who is a threat, a lattrel or Sivo causing angst for defenders.
For a while last year we became a good “team”, the players were fighting for each other.
We can do it again this year, but everyone is accountable, not just the halves.
There’s things Nathan does very well, but creating try scoring opportunities for the team isn’t one of them. And that’s the main role of a half. He admits himself that he regressed last year.
I know I’ve covered this ground a lot, but he just doesn’t have that genuine X factor a top level half has.