What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2024 Origin II - TONIGHT - NSW v QLD @ MCG

Series: NSW v QLD

  • New South Wales

  • Queensland

  • Draw after Golden Point


Results are only viewable after voting.
Messages
14,429
i'd swap Gagai in for Gapewell.

Gagai is a specialist three quarter. Capewell is a backrower who can also play centre. As such, for a bench spot, Capewell provides Qld greater versatility. If you left out Capewell for Gagai in your 17, you'd wind up with a hooker, a back, and only two forwards on your bench. Not a wise strategy in my book.
 

Diesel

Referee
Messages
21,783
NSW looks stronger than game 1, bit taking anything away from Robson but why isn’t Api in the side
 

mozza91

Coach
Messages
13,226
I’m pretty sure Capewell is only in the side for the glory hole jokes. He’s a terrible player at this stage and he started at shit.
 

beave

Coach
Messages
15,627
Gagai is a specialist three quarter. Capewell is a backrower who can also play centre. As such, for a bench spot, Capewell provides Qld greater versatility. If you left out Capewell for Gagai in your 17, you'd wind up with a hooker, a back, and only two forwards on your bench. Not a wise strategy in my book.
Capewell got absolutely torched in the centres in the 2021 series. He is even slower now, the only way it works is if Nanai moves to the centres (where I actually think he could play full time) and have Capewell in the back row.

If Capewell is playing in the centres we will get destroyed.
 

Munky

Coach
Messages
11,062
Capewell got absolutely torched in the centres in the 2021 series. He is even slower now, the only way it works is if Nanai moves to the centres (where I actually think he could play full time) and have Capewell in the back row.

If Capewell is playing in the centres we will get destroyed.

Since 2020 NSW have lost:

Game 3 2020
Game 1 2023
Game 2 2023
Game 1 2024

In large part due to having non specialist outside backs defending in the centres.

Amazing really.

2021 NSW shredded the QLD defence out wide.
 
Messages
14,429
Since 2020 NSW have lost:

Game 3 2020
Game 1 2023
Game 2 2023
Game 1 2024

In large part due to having non specialist outside backs defending in the centres.

Amazing really.

2021 NSW shredded the QLD defence out wide.

That was more so because of the coach choosing the wrong players to be in the centres when those injuries occurred (e.g. Hynes and Cook, a specialist half and a specialist hooker respectively).
 

Diesel

Referee
Messages
21,783
Capewell got absolutely torched in the centres in the 2021 series. He is even slower now, the only way it works is if Nanai moves to the centres (where I actually think he could play full time) and have Capewell in the back row.

If Capewell is playing in the centres we will get destroyed.
Seems a strange selection, he had rib cartilage injury earlier in the year and hasn’t been playing well. Had a bit of a rest, due to the injury but hasn’t played much this season
 
Top