2024 Prediction Thread

[Gary Gutful]

Surprise packet?
Morgan Harper

I got this right. He's been surprisingly more shit than he was at Manly.

 

[Avenger]

I got this right. He's been surprisingly more shit than he was at Manly.

Take it back.

 

[Gazzamatta]

Is it against the rules to reassess our predictions given a massive handbrake has now been removed from the equation?

 

[Sensei Cobra]

Who is it ?

 

[the phantom menace]

 

[the phantom menace]

View attachment 83336Interesting prediction

This media prediction didn't age well... Lussick now demoted to Cup

 

[JokerEel]

Where will we finish?
13th

If we don’t win it, who will?
Broncos

Our best player?
Gutho

Our biggest disappointment?
Paulo

The first rookie to make NRL debut?
Martyn

Surprise packet?
Martyn

Breakout year?
Martyn

Best retention?
No one

The biggest name we let go?
Paulo

Biggest signing?
No one

Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
Panther miss the 8

Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
No

I am going ok so far ffs

 

[King-Gutho94]

This media prediction didn't age well... Lussick now demoted to Cup

Tbf most of us didnt expect Lussick to be this horrible.

I certainly didnt.

I thought he was decent signing coming back at the time to do a simple job.

Unfortunately its turned out to be a disaster.

 

[Twizzle]

Tbf most of us didnt expect Lussick to be this horrible.

I certainly didnt.

I thought he was decent signing coming back at the time to do a simple job.

Unfortunately its turned out to be a disaster.

same here, I was happy to see him come back

it was all pretty much downhill from there

 

[Noise]

Tbf most of us didnt expect Lussick to be this horrible.

I certainly didnt.

I thought he was decent signing coming back at the time to do a simple job.

Unfortunately its turned out to be a disaster.

Some of us did mid last year:

Besides Hopgood, have a look at the complete trash BA has brought to the club this year, and will be clogging up our top 30 for future years too:
Hodgson
Momoisea
Murchie
Doorey
Lumelume
Davey
Lussick
Asi

On Doorey and Lussick when MJC said I was being harsh on them calling them reserve graders:

Both genuine reserve graders.

On Lussick:

He sure is. I said it a couple of weeks ago. He’s a reserve grader.

 

[Incorrect]

I am going ok so far ffs

I reckon you're on the money with about 3 of those calls.... Not sure that constitutes OK?! lol

 

[JokerEel]

I reckon you're on the money with about 3 of those calls.... Not sure that constitutes OK?! lol

Baldy not being coach is the big prize ffs

 

[King-Gutho94]

Top 8 for mine

Manly are the bolter with Brooks going there i think he will raise his game to another level with a fresh start and it make the tigers fans feel more sick watching him play finals while they flounder in the bottom half for another year.

I can't leave Melbourne out of the top 4 until they completely drop off the cliff. You keep waiting for it to happen but until it does i just have to have them in there they are too professional for 3/4 of the competition.

Brisbane will have a bit of GF hangover for mine too good to miss out but will finish bottom half.

Dolphins will make the finals & i expect North Qld to win enough games at Home to scrape into the 8.

1 - Penrith
2 - Roosters
3 - Storm
4 - Manly
5 - Parramatta
6 - Brisbane
7 - North Qld
8 - Dolphins

Outside of deciding to follow the heart with these dipshits in the blue & gold to come 5th.

I feel like i might be pretty close with the rest of my top 8 with 7 weeks to go.

I think Brisbane will come home hard and make a run into the bottom half of the 8

Think the Dolphins may slide out for them though.

Cowboys are 50/50 not sure what to make of them.

Manly to possibly edge out the Sharks in the top 4 if they win tomorrow night they were my smokey at the start of the year to make top 4.

 

[chiefy1]

 

[Hindmarshisgod2]

No one predicted the spoon bowl.....

 

[Scootsie]

No one predicted the spoon bowl.....

Well, nobody predicted Parra would be in contention for the spoon.

The other worst prediction for the season was all the media jockeys picking the Wahs for either top 4, GF or Premiership. Beaten only by Brisbane in terms of underperformance.

 

[EelEtric]

Well, nobody predicted Parra would be in contention for the spoon.

The other worst prediction for the season was all the media jockeys picking the Wahs for either top 4, GF or Premiership. Beaten only by Brisbane in terms of underperformance.

And us and Souths.

 

[Gary Gutful]

Where will we finish?

3rd

If we don’t win it, who will?
THE PENRITH PANTHER

Our best player?

RCG

Our biggest disappointment?

Moimesea

The first rookie to make NRL debut?
Mataele

Surprise packet?

Lussick

Breakout year?
Morretti

Best retention?

Morretti


The biggest name we let go?

SIVO


Biggest signing?

Taylan May


Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
CLEARY ALREADY THE G.O.A.T


Will BA coach them in 2025 ? Y/N
Y

Mr 8.5%

 

[Gary Gutful]

Where will we finish?


7th or 8th

BA lover.

 

[DaveMc]

Pazza calls it in the very first post:

Non-eels, biggest controversy ?
Benji flop