I go with Bellamy as the better coach. Bennett basically had QLD SOO teams playing for him in Brisbane, plus a NSW origin prop and all time great in Lazarus.
In addition to number of GF’s Bellamy has also made the prelim 16 times vs Bennett with 14.
16 prelim finals shows Melbourne don’t just make the finals, they have the quality to go deep.
I think that’s more impressive than the number of times they’ve made the final.
That said, your point is valid; he’s lost more than he’s won and now just lost 2 in a row…