Iamback
Referee
- Messages
- 20,458
People said similar about alamoti.....
For 1/4 the price great value.
Stefano on elite money. No thanks
People said similar about alamoti.....
Wait what Cartwright have we signed that I don't know about1. Edwards
2. To'o
3. Tago
4. Alamoti
5. McLean
6. Talagi
7. Cleary
8. Leota
9. Kenny
10. Smith
11. Papali'i
12. Martin
13. Yeo
14. Questionable, I'd run first with Toelau.
15. Henry
16. Sorro
17. Garner
I believe Alamoti wants to play centre so he gets first rights. Toelau was too green to stick with through the finals but showed promise and could develop given a season to do so. Garner on the bench so he can cover centre if a shuffle is needed.
Not much to sort really. We are probably deeper than ever imo with Cole, Laurie, Cartwright, Patea, Huth, Mclean2 all looking decent enough fill ins.
For 1/4 the price great value.
Stefano on elite money. No thanks
Bellamy will work him hard and make him a rep forward. They also rarely over pay.
That is the market these days. Their pack is soft so they had to improve it, That is the cost of it
Cameron MUNCHER!!Everything depends on Nathan’s body for us can’t see them beating us if we are at full strength. They played their best game of season and were lucky to only lose 3 try’s to 1. Beginning to think it’s not the body inside the pink shirt but the winner mentality.
As far as Melb future success if you compare our 2020 side it s**t all over their 2025 team. They have a no name 3/4 line, Papps best is behind him, Munster is old now, spare parts pack other than Kotoa or Grant. Hughes will never play better. Being Gypsies is only impediment in the drive for 5.
Those people aren't me, therefore moronsPeople said similar about alamoti.....
That's the difference with Ivan / Panthers. All the other clubs are looking for a quick fix, not prepared to bring players along in terms of development. As someone else said, suprised Ciraldo didn't see Alamoti's potential.Those people aren't me, therefore morons
Braithe on 360 mentioned this also, allamoti was a superstar rookie, that never converted into a 1st grade
.....Ivan fixed that
Another GF. Amazing. What a club! Whatever happens in the ‘24 decider Penrith Panthers have achieved greatness already. That’s undeniable.
Looking ahead and making some off season discussion. What’s your 17 + 18th man for round 1 - 2025 and most of the season if everyone is fit?
Backs:
Edwards
To’o
Tago
C.McLean
Alamoti
Halves:
Laurie
Cleary
Forwards:
Leota
Kenny
Smith
Garner
Martin
Yeo
Bench:
Talagi
Sorensen
Henry
Papali’i
Patea - 18th
I think the NSW Cup team will be much stronger in 2025 as well. There’s some gems who have had another season of experience ready to rock next year. Depth will be overall better due to being a year older.
Thoughts?
Meaney, Averillo, Alamoti - decent centres that have gone on to better things - recurring trend that seems to be happening.That's the difference with Ivan / Panthers. All the other clubs are looking for a quick fix, not prepared to bring players along in terms of development. As someone else said, suprised Ciraldo didn't see Alamoti's potential.