3rd Test: Australia v South Africa at Perth Nov 30-Dec 4, 2012

[chrisD]

Was a noise.

 

[hineyrulz]

What bullshit. Smith did the EXACT SAME THING the last test and they give that fat merkin a second life.

Not a single bit of evidence showed he hit that, yet he's still given

agreed, load of crap the rulings are too inconsistent.

 

[Red&BlackBear]

That's bullocks decision, no conclusive evidence that he hit it and its advantage to the batsmen unless there is evidence of any kind. Inconsistent decision considering pop'n'fresh got off on the same sort of appeal/reserve decision last test.

 

[Danish]

There was a noise for Smith too

 

[Gidley Up]

Disgraceful shot from Warner. How can people defend that rubbish?

 

[umina panther]

Robbed.....whats the point of the review

 

[chrisD]

That's not how it works, they need conclusive evidence to overturn the decision.

 

[JW]

4 down for f**k all.

 

[some11]

4/35 lol.

 

[hineyrulz]

Lyon now gone, hopefully we pass 47.

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Don Clarke to save the day again. Steyn with 3.

 

[Red&BlackBear]

Hughes in for Lyon obviously...

 

[Danish]

That's not how it works, they need conclusive evidence to overturn the decision.

.... unless its a South African

 

[Hutty1986]

oh my f*cking god. f*cking embarrassing

 

[Canard]

Steyn revelling here. He was always going to be dangerous on this pitch.

All the evidence pointed to Warner being out.

Surely Clarke can't keep saving us!

 

[BDR]

One of these two must stick around or the match could be in serious trouble by stumps.

 

[BunniesMan]

Only people defending Warner are people who don't understand the review system.

Firstly, he knew he hit it or he would have called for the review without hesitation. So that alone is unsportsmanlike.

Secondly, during the review because the umpire gave it out there must be CONCLUSIVE proof of a mistake. The slowmo showed no obvious gap between bat and ball. Hotspot was inconsclusive because of the suns glare right where the ball went past the bat.

There was no proof the umpire made a mistake. So it didn't get overturned.

Warner should be ashamed of himself, he knew he hit it.

 

[hineyrulz]

Disgraceful shot from Warner. How can people defend that rubbish?

Waits for him to fail then you comment, where were you last test???

Blind Freddy can see it was a poor shot.

 

[some11]

Surely Clarke can't keep saving us!

Clarke and Hussey just need to do it one more time

 

[woodyk2]

We got this.