3rd Test: Australia v South Africa at Perth Nov 30-Dec 4, 2012

[chrisD]

The shit thing about the review is snicko is the best evidence in that situation.

 

[Hutty1986]

Warner inexplicably back in the pavilion despite no evidence he even nicked it. massive wicket due to a flawed system

 

[hineyrulz]

Only people defending Warner are people who don't understand the review system.

Firstly, he knew he hit it or he would have called for the review without hesitation. So that alone is unsportsmanlike.

Secondly, during the review because the umpire gave it out there must be CONCLUSIVE proof of a mistake. The slowmo showed no obvious gap between bat and ball. Hotspot was inconsclusive because of the suns glare right where the ball went past the bat.

There was no proof the umpire made a mistake. So it didn't get overturned.

Warner should be ashamed of himself, he knew he hit it.

So he Definately should have been given not out then........

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Phillip J Hughes would have walked.

 

[Canard]

Anyone notice since the first test there hasn't been anything close to a no ball on the reviews?

Was it the pitch (run up area) or they have just adjusted?

 

[Red&BlackBear]

Anyone notice since the first test there hasn't been anything close to a no ball on the reviews?

Was it the pitch (run up area) or they have just adjusted?

Didn't Tahir get/didn't get a wicket off a no ball in Adelaide?

 

[Red&BlackBear]

These two need to have a 50+ run partnership, followed by who ever is in with Hussey. If we can reach 200+ with only 5 or 6 down, we can launch an assault with Wade/Hastings/Johnson

 

[Canard]

Plum as plum

 

[JW]

5 down now, lol.

 

[Red&BlackBear]

This collapse is rubbish.

 

[hineyrulz]

At least we've passed the follow on.

 

[Xfactor1979]

No referrals left

5 for <50

 

[some11]

No faith in Ponting, probably get out for a duck in his last innings.

 

[Danish]

Only people defending Warner are people who don't understand the review system.

Firstly, he knew he hit it or he would have called for the review without hesitation. So that alone is unsportsmanlike.

Secondly, during the review because the umpire gave it out there must be CONCLUSIVE proof of a mistake. The slowmo showed no obvious gap between bat and ball. Hotspot was inconsclusive because of the suns glare right where the ball went past the bat.

There was no proof the umpire made a mistake. So it didn't get overturned.

Warner should be ashamed of himself, he knew he hit it.

Unless of course you are a south african

 

[Xfactor1979]

time for the magnificent 300 run 5rpo hussey/clarke partnership

 

[Danish]

If one of these blokes gets out in the next 5 overs we'll be lucky to see triple digits from the innings

 

[Gidley Up]

SOS Quiney

 

[Xfactor1979]

Ooh ... trouble

 

[Canard]

I would go so far too say we've lost this match already.

 

[Hutty1986]

a nightmare farewell for ponting looming.