What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

7 tackle try - NQ dudded again!

Messages
17,550
Under no circumstances should either ref be allowed to work for the remainder of the season. The NRL should be ashamed if they do.

Missing the entirety of next season should be a consideration also.

Cronulla supporters on this forum are not covering themselves in glory right now. But this current crass behaviour appears to be their style anyway.

I agree with the first part, however you are full of shit on the last point
 

juanfarkall

Coach
Messages
10,071
Under no circumstances should either ref be allowed to work for the remainder of the season. The NRL should be ashamed if they do.

Missing the entirety of next season should be a consideration also.

Cronulla supporters on this forum are not covering themselves in glory right now. But this current crass behaviour appears to be their style anyway.

I am no friend to the Shire Scum but disagree with this point.
 

Stagger Lee

Bench
Messages
4,931
The biggest issue is that none of the 6 officials could keep count. Every single one of them should be counting the tackles to make sure this never happens.

Yep

As I posted earlier one of the officials should have corrected the ref during the set in his earpiece
 
Messages
17,550
I don't want or need your apology, however perhaps you should comment on the many posts by non Shark supporters saying the same thing.

Most Shark supporters agree the referees got it horribly wrong. It was disgraceful, however it's not like our team did anything wrong. They played the whistle and ref calls, just as any side would do.

You are generalizing about our supporters without justification.
 

Shorty

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
15,555
I just feel like what's the point in getting upset about it? It was a stupid error but its done.
I'm more annoyed that a foot inside the line would have won us the game.
 

2012....Sharks Year

First Grade
Messages
5,816
While I commiserate with the cowboys on their close loss the error occurred in the 7th minute. The cows had 73 mins to overcome the error. All the players interviewed said they didn't even realise the error till after the game. I would feel far more sorry for them had the error happened in the last 5 minutes when they may not have had a chance to overcome the error . Up up Cronulla!
 

Mr Saab

Referee
Messages
27,762
The game could get 10 billion next deal...wont matter.....the game is a comedy but not hah hah funny.
 

PR_SHARK

Juniors
Messages
258
What about when Graham went up for that kick on the Cowboys line and got penalized for contesting, the Cowboys go down the field and score?

There's dud decisions all the time, this one is just a different and rare one and the Cowboys were just unlucky.
 

Nerd

Bench
Messages
2,827
At least one of the refs and the video ref should be gone for the rest of the finals.
 

Charlie124

First Grade
Messages
8,509
While I commiserate with the cowboys on their close loss the error occurred in the 7th minute. The cows had 73 mins to overcome the error. All the players interviewed said they didn't even realise the error till after the game. I would feel far more sorry for them had the error happened in the last 5 minutes when they may not have had a chance to overcome the error . Up up Cronulla!

I'm so sick to death of hearing bullshit like this, the point is we shouldn't have had to overcome the error in the first place as first grade referees should be able to f**king count!!! Why do we have to constantly overcome refereeing decisions to to win games of football? We were the better team tonight and the scoreline would've shown that if not for this f**kwit in pink. It makes no difference what minute it happens in, reffing f**k ups costing/gifting teams points and putting one team behind the eight ball shouldn't be something that's accepted as just part if the game.

It was the same last year, "oh but manly were the better team anyway" WHO f**kING CARES! They were given the game. Maybe the best team on the day doesn't always win, that's what's great about our code, anyone can pull anything out of the bag and produce a win.

But anyway, here we are again about to receive another apology from the referees boss and an assurance that this wont happen again blah blah blah... Heard it all before and it counts for shit in the end, doesn't fix the damage.

Matt Bowen deserved more than for that to be his farewell from the nrl.
 

Trentosaurus

Juniors
Messages
171
Matt Bowen deserved more than for that to be his farewell from the nrl.
This.

We've seen one of the game's most exciting players and a genuine good guy have has career ended by an unforgivable refereeing mistake. I love rugby league more than anything but I can't defend a sport that allows this to happen.
 

Canard

Immortal
Messages
35,787
What about when Graham went up for that kick on the Cowboys line and got penalized for contesting, the Cowboys go down the field and score?

There's dud decisions all the time, this one is just a different and rare one and the Cowboys were just unlucky.

That was one tackle after Carney dropped the ball in the play the ball and was allowed to play it again because he "passed it?"
 

PoWdErFiNgEr84

Juniors
Messages
68
I'm no cowboy's fan but with 2 ref's on the field & 2 video ref's messing up the tackle count is a mistake that should never ever happen. Who cares if it happens in the 1st min or the 80th min it is the one mistake that the ref's should never make & there is no excuse for it. It's not a case of human error nor interpretation.
 

muzby

Village Idiot
Staff member
Messages
45,971
2i8asue.png
 

Usain Bolt

Bench
Messages
3,740
NRL used their favourite line again when faced with a crisis..

"There will be an inquiry"

There's been inquiries into salary cap deals, the Ben Barba situation and now the refs. They'll need to hire more staff soon to handle these inquiries
 

Latest posts

Top