8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13

[adamkungl]

I'm a Raider's fan and Shillo is about as handy as c**k flavoured lollypop

This. Personally I would give Shillo more points if he didn't play.

 

[adamkungl]

8. FPN - 7
9. J Aubusson - 7
10. Ryles - 7
11. M Aubusson - 8
12. Cherrington - 7
13. Myles - 8

44. IMHO

 

[Non Terminator]

Haha, forgot about Myles.

 

[perverse]

8. Ben Cross - 7
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
10. Mark Taufua - 5
11. Simpson - 7
12. Taia - 9
13. Hilder - 7

43 by my count. our front row needs help...

then you have the likes of houston, paterson, tuimavave and fa'aoso on the bench... who all outrate mark taufua as a player... yet will not crack the starting side for the first round at least. our coaches (and most of our fans, for some reason) want to boof the big T... it's his big pearly smile i think.

 

[Sans Souci Sainter]

Weyman - 8
Fien - 6
Prior - 6.5
Creagh - 8.5
Smith - 7
Young - 6.5
D.Hunt - 6
J.Saffy - 5.5

 

[Sans Souci Sainter]

Im going to cheat a little and include a fully fit Sika Manu

Fully fit pack

Tolman - 7
Smith - 9.5
White - 6.5
Blair - 8.5
Manu - 8.5
Hoffman -7.5

47.5

Season opener

Tolman - 7
Smith - 9.5
Lima - 7
Blair - 8.5
Hoffman - 7.5
Lowrie - 6

45

Do your team then do another team, maybe your rivals.

Parramatta

Moi Moi - 8.5
Keating - 6
Cayless - 6.5
Hindmarsh - 8
Smith - 6
Mateo - 7.5

42.5

Tolman - 7??, Hindmarsh - 8??

More like Tolman 6, Hindmarsh 8.5.

 

[Cockadoodledoo]

8. Shillington - 9 (Kangaroo, could probably give him 10 tbh)
9. Tongue - 5 (As a hooker - as a lock he'd be 7-8)
10. Tilse - 7 (Improving)
11. Harrison - 9 (Kiwi rep, best off loading forward in the world)
12. Learoyd-Lahrs - 9 (Powerhouse NSW rep, will play for Roos this year if fit)
13. Miller - 7 (tough as nails)

46 IMHO.

Shillington a possible 10.. I guess cannabis has been decriminalised in ACT hasn't it.. Must be getting some good stuff.. Let alone the rest of your ratings..

 

[Serc]

then you have the likes of houston, paterson, tuimavave and fa'aoso on the bench... who all outrate mark taufua as a player... yet will not crack the starting side for the first round at least. our coaches (and most of our fans, for some reason) want to boof the big T... it's his big pearly smile i think.

He'll show you just you wait!

Though thats a better assessment of our forwards than Baron Vo Emo on the previous page (though I'd almost consider giving Hilder an 8 he is that good)

 

[Cockadoodledoo]

Based on your assesment i will go,
8. Asotasi - 10
9. Luke - 10
10 Burgess - 10
11. Taylor -10
12. Pettybourne - 10
13. Crocker - 10

:lol:

Taylor would be a 14, Burgess 27.

 

[bubblesunlimited]

8. Gibbs - 5
9. Farah - 9
10. Galloway - 8
11. Ellis - 9
12. Heighington - 6
13. Fulton - 6

I am tipping

8. Galloway 8
9. Farah 9
10. Cayless 7
11. Payten 7
12. Ellis 9
13. Heighnington 7

47/60

 

[mxlegend99]

Not entirely sure who will partner Petero in the front row to start the season, but most of our options are similar quality anyway.

8. Tim Grant - 6
9. Kevin Kingston - 7
10. Petero Civoniceva - 9
11. Frank Pritchard - 8 (could be a 10, could be a 6 - depends on his mood)
12. Trent Waterhouse - 7.5
13. Luke Lewis - 9

Total - 46.5

 

[perverse]

He'll show you just you wait!

Though thats a better assessment of our forwards than Baron Vo Emo on the previous page (though I'd almost consider giving Hilder an 8 he is that good)

i considered giving hilder an 8, however his attack game lets him down... and i didn't want the big girls blouse brigade to start whinging.

i love our pack, tbh. i don't expect it to be the same in round 1 as it will be mid year, injuries disregarded. we'll probably find simmo come to the bench as he winds down in favour of starting houston... and the front row will definitely see some changes.

 

[Sleep]

Souths have the best forward pack in the comp and it isn't even close.

 

[perverse]

Not entirely sure who will partner Petero in the front row to start the season, but most of our options are similar quality anyway.

8. Tim Grant - 6
9. Matt Keating - 7
10. Petero Civoniceva - 9
11. Frank Pritchard - 8 (could be a 10, could be a 6 - depends on his mood)
12. Trent Waterhouse - 7.5
13. Luke Lewis - 9

Total - 46.5

er.. matt keating?

wasn't it kevin kingston that you bought? lol.

 

[Bobby DIGital]

Shillington's a roo - I can justify giving him a high rating on that alone.

Chur.

 

[Ike E Bear]

Poore - 8
Keating - 7
Cayless - 7
Hindmarsh - 8.5
Smith - 7
Mateo - 8
Starting Total = 44.5

I don't see the point of assessing a pack without looking at the bench, to be honest.

Moi Moi - 9
Mannah - 7
Shackleton - 7
K Keating - 7
Total = 74.5

I also have a big soft spot for the Rabbitohs, who my late father followed, so I'll rate them too.

Asotasi - 7.5
Luke - 8
Stuart - 8.5
Taylor - 7.5
Pettybourne - 7.5
Burgess - 8
Starting Total = 47

The scary thing here is that I tried to avoid rating many of these guys on their potential. Luke, Taylor and Pettybourne all have room to grow. They could be anything. Meanwhile, Burgess has to prove that he can live up to the hype week-in week-out.

Ross - 7
Geddes - 6.5
Crocker - 7
Capewell - 6
Total = 73.5

 

[Noa]

Tolman - 7??, Hindmarsh - 8??

More like Tolman 6, Hindmarsh 8.5.

You could be right, leave Tolman at 7, he is getting pretty good, and Hindmarsh 8.5. I couldnt give him 9, leave that for best couple in that position

 

[NGR]

Shillington's a roo - I can justify giving him a high rating on that alone.

Chur.

so was shannon hegarty...

 

[Baron Vo Mandor]

Plucked straight from my arse...

8. Luke Stuart - 8
10. Roy Asotasi - 8.5

Luke Stuart is a 6. Solid player but nothing special

Roy over the last 2 years is an 5 @ best, his been dreadful when not injured.

 

[Pazza]

cayless - 7
keating - 6
poore - 8
hindmarsh - 9
shacklton - 6
mateo - 8

mannah - 6
moi moi - 9
smith - 7

66