8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13

[mxlegend99]

er.. matt keating?

wasn't it kevin kingston that you bought? lol.

haha my bad. No idea how i made that mistake.

 

[Coaster]

8. Bailey - 7.5
9. Friend -8
10 Myers - 7
11 Lafrancri -7
12 Minochello - 7
13 Harrison - 7.5

44

 

[Marshall_magic]

Bryce Gibbs 6.5
Robbie Farah 9
Keith Galloway 8
Gareth Ellis 9
Chris Heighington 6.5
Liam Fulton 6

Total: 45

 

[NGR]

Luke Stuart is a 6. Solid player but nothing special

Roy over the last 2 years is an 5 @ best, his been dreadful when not injured.

so you think cross is better than asotasi? :lol:

Luke stuart played for city last year, guess that makes him special doesnt it?

 

[Ike E Bear]

Luke Stuart is a 6. Solid player but nothing special

Roy over the last 2 years is an 5 @ best, his been dreadful when not injured.

You're a harsh marker.

 

[Firey_Dragon]

8. Shillington - 9 (Kangaroo, could probably give him 10 tbh)
9. Tongue - 5 (As a hooker - as a lock he'd be 7-8)
10. Tilse - 7 (Improving)
11. Harrison - 9 (Kiwi rep, best off loading forward in the world)
12. Learoyd-Lahrs - 9 (Powerhouse NSW rep, will play for Roos this year if fit)
13. Miller - 7 (tough as nails)

46 IMHO.

Thank you, I LOL'd

 

[Big Pete]

My scale is completely different to everybody elses...

Here's mine...
Nick Kenny - 6
Andrew McCullough - 5
Ashton Sims: 5
Ben Te'o - 4
Sam Thaiday - 7
Corey Parker - 5

Total: 32

 

[petetheileet]

I think everyone is getting a little too excited over souffs

Asotasi hasn't had a great game in 2 years (i rate Stuart higher)

Taylor is still raw and needs a lot more good games under his belt

Burgess...hmmm i dont think we can mark him yet, doubt he will be a world beater. If he is as good as Ellis was las year i will be a little surprised

Its a good pack, but i think everyone is getting a little too excited too early

 

[PJ Marshal]

Cayless - 7
Keating - 6
Moi Moi - 9
Hindmarsh - 9
Smith - 5
Mateo - 8

Poore - 8
Shackleton - 7

Keating well he can be a 6 and sh*thouse as a 4 at the best of times

 

[Firey_Dragon]

8. Weyman - 8.5
9. Fien - 6
10. Prior - 6
11. Creagh - 8
12. Smith - 8 (before injury, not so sure this year)
13. Young - 5

Total - 41.5

So many unknowns in our pack this year, Scott may move back to 2nd row, Greenfield has bucketloads of potential, Hunt could step up etc etc.

 

[MacDougall]

Keith Galloway - 7.5
Robbie Farah - 8.5
Bryce Gibbs - 6
Gareth Ellis - 8.5
Todd Payten - 5.5
Chris Heighington - 5.5

41.5

 

[Coaster]

I cant believe Tigers fans rate Heighington so low, everytime i have seen him he has been one of your best on field

 

[Eelementary]

You could be right, leave Tolman at 7, he is getting pretty good, and Hindmarsh 8.5. I couldnt give him 9, leave that for best couple in that position

Hindy IS the best.

 

[Eelementary]

Cayless - 7
Keating - 6
Moi Moi - 9
Hindmarsh - 9
Smith - 5
Mateo - 8

Poore - 8
Shackleton - 7

Keating well he can be a 6 and sh*thouse as a 4 at the best of times

IMO that's about right. And Mannah would score a 7 imo.

 

[MacDougall]

I cant believe Tigers fans rate Heighington so low, everytime i have seen him he has been one of your best on field

He is a stats player. He has no real impact. I haven't seen him bust a tackle in 3 years. He makes 22 5 metres hit ups per game by running at the markers and shoving them back a few steps.

 

[PJ Marshal]

Mannah is a tough one , definetly floating around 6 and 7 but he does go mia in games

 

[Noa]

My scale is completely different to everybody elses...

Here's mine...
Nick Kenny - 6
Andrew McCullough - 5
Ashton Sims: 5
Ben Te'o - 4
Sam Thaiday - 7
Corey Parker - 5

Total: 32

Sure is, you over-rate your players ;-).

 

[Tom Ace]

8. Shillington - 9 (Kangaroo, could probably give him 10 tbh)
9. Tongue - 5 (As a hooker - as a lock he'd be 7-8)
10. Tilse - 7 (Improving)
11. Harrison - 9 (Kiwi rep, best off loading forward in the world)
12. Learoyd-Lahrs - 9 (Powerhouse NSW rep, will play for Roos this year if fit)
13. Miller - 7 (tough as nails)

46 IMHO.

:lol:

Best laugh I've had all day.

 

[DRAGONZ_RULE]

8. Dan Hunt -- 6 .. on the rise
9. Nathan Fien -- 6 .. probably falling
10. Michael Weyman -- 8 .. on the rise
11. Matt Prior -- 6 .. on the rise
12. Ben Creagh -- 8.5 to 9
13. Jeremy Smith -- 8

14. Dean Young -- 3 as a hooker, 7 as a backrower
15. Neville Costigan -- 7
16. Michael Greenfield -- 4 given he hasn't played, could be 7 by end of season
17. Jarrod Saffy -- 5.5

Current total: 43 + 19.5-23.5 (depending on what position Young plays) = 62.5 - 66.5

We have a lot of extra depth though .. some solid enough First Graders like Green, Thorby and a couple of others and some super-exciting potential in Merrin, Hancock, Marketo (these three most notably).

Player for player we don't have the best pack, but when they play together as a group they are a lot better than the sum of their parts.

 

[GB!]

Inspired from the playmaker thread, just rate your team's forwards individually out of ten.

Manly
8. King - 6
9. Ballin - 6
10. Kite - 7
11. Watmough - 9
12. Bailey - 6
13. Stewart - 8

Total - 32

:crazy:
way off and how does that = 32?

Manly:
king = 7.5
ballin = 7.5
perry = 7
watmough = 9
gulavou/t-rex/kite/bailey/rodney = 6.5
stewart = 8

45.5