Well you were discussing your teams achievements, which I might add were in a time when the current Wests Tigers weren't ever around.
So we saw the typical sidestep, How many Premierships have the Raiders won since the Wests Tigers have been around?
Canberra's first 5 years in the comp saw them pick up a wooden spoon (and one of the worst performances by a team in a season), and one finals game (a play off for fifth with Souths, which they lost by 19 points.
Wests Tigers have yet to touch a wooden spoon, and they may end up gaining their first finals match this year.
I can't see how you can state either team is a dud. They are fairly evenly matched.