What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Alex McKinnon possibly Quadriplegic - Mclean guilty of dangerous throw - 7 weeks

How many weeks?

  • 1-2

    Votes: 53 42.7%
  • 3-4

    Votes: 25 20.2%
  • 5-6

    Votes: 10 8.1%
  • 7-8

    Votes: 10 8.1%
  • 9+

    Votes: 26 21.0%

  • Total voters
    124
Status
Not open for further replies.

STORM.99/07

Bench
Messages
2,857
47 posts about a player James Ackerman who died after a tackle in a Qld cup Match . The silence from all the expert residents of league Unlimited is deafening.
 
Last edited:

macavity

Referee
Messages
20,653
yep. And then you back it all up by signing a player who sends naked photos of his ex girlfriend to his mates.

Stay classy, Newcastle.

When another club introduces tactics into the game that end up severely injuring people, you might find some moral equivalency.

Until then your mob solely own the scum club moniker.

Chicken wings, crushers, karate kicks, Jarrod McCracken, Alex McKinnon.... quite a laundry list of wilful endangerment.

But yeah, some pingers and a couple of stupid blokes we moved on are totally equivalent.
 

Maximus

Coach
Messages
13,884
McKinnon needs to cut the crap. Smith had no idea and did what captains do.

If that is true, he was the only player. All of the other players/refs/trainers were concerned for McKinnon's welfare.

He said he couldn't watch as McKinnon was put into a neck brace and stretchered from the field, with scans at a Melbourne hospital later confirming a fracture.

Chambers said it was tough to see any player suffer a serious injury in a tackle.

?I walked away last night when it happened because you hate to see people in that situation,? he said.

?You don't want to look. It's a scary thought, and I stayed away from it.?

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/spo...-mckinnon-tackle/story-fnca0von-1226864540282

So Will Chambers could tell it was serious, but Smith had no idea? You really believe that?
 

Maroon4life

Juniors
Messages
1,654
This is all just further proof Smith is a sneaky, grubby piece of shit. Wonder if the refs will wake up to him now. Doubt it.

Rofl, you are no different to your mate beaver the way you both take time out from nobbin eachother to sink the boot into any storm or qld player.

Drink draino and don't put any further stress on our already over burdened emergency services with your pleas for help.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
70,123
Lol like no player at any other club has done all those things and worse. Only thing, and I say this as a Storm member, I really dislike is the wrestling Storm brought in and every other club quickly adopted. The NRL needed to stop it as soon as it started and ban any wrestling coach going near a nrl club. Everything else I have seen plenty others doing and some worse.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
70,123
If that is true, he was the only player. All of the other players/refs/trainers were concerned for McKinnon's welfare.



http://www.theaustralian.com.au/spo...-mckinnon-tackle/story-fnca0von-1226864540282

So Will Chambers could tell it was serious, but Smith had no idea? You really believe that?

Maybe smith was doing his job as capt getting in the refs ear so was unaware exactly what was going on? Or maybe not, either way his actions afterwards to do what he could to support him need to be taken into account before casting rocks at him. He's no angel but you don't become the club, state and country captain without having something others respect. I doubt there are many fans on here who could genuine,y say they wouldn't have wanted him at their club over the last few years.
 

Desert Qlder

First Grade
Messages
9,446
To bring some context into what Newcastle fans celebrate in their footballers, while at the same time fingering others for crippling McKinnon, let's take a trip down memory lane:

[youtube]RzCTX7lcqfc[/youtube]
 

The Rosco

Bench
Messages
2,909
They were discussing this on MMM Sydney this morning. Dell, Dan Ginane, Billy Birmingham . . . I think. Was doing some painting and had the radio on in the background.
They interviewed a bloke who was either a Storm club bloke or Smith's manager . . . again, background and not paying complete attention.
This bloke's argument went along the lines of " waiting to get the timing right for Cammy to apologise. All the while defending Smith on the basis that "it's not in his character".
He also trotted out that unfortunately McKinnon contributed to his plight by tucking in his head.
By this stage I had stopped painting and was starting to hurl stuff at the radio.
Dell and those other 2 were towing the party line and constantly referring to it not being in Smith's character. I think Rothfield was there as well, and at least he had the nuts to stand up to this clown from Smith's camp and ridicule him for suggesting an 18 month wait to apologise is socially acceptable.
All reference to it not being Smith's go . . . or any other bullshit phrase that means the same thing . . . should be removed from his defence . . . and then I'd love to see how he justifies himself.
And lastly . . . as far as Alex tucking in his head . . . those Storm tacklers had started to rotate him mid air, looking for all money that they were going to continue to spin him and land him on his back. Alex tucked his head so they would complete the revolution and he would be safe when he landed.
He didn't figure the merkins were going to stop the rotation and drive him into the ground on his head.
Watch the replay. It is so blatantly obvious. But I hope Mclean got some counselling, you know, to help him through what would have been a difficult time for him.
With all this media attention, Cammy might re-visit the timing issue and get around to apologising for being such a Cameron Smith.
 

Haffa

Guest
Messages
16,600
ITT butthurt knights fans take their angst of backing a piece of fkn shit club out on Cameron Smith. Average footballer sustained a very unfortunate injury that any footballer can still sustain, no apologies required from Smith to wheels.

Stay classy.
 

Haffa

Guest
Messages
16,600
To bring some context into what Newcastle fans celebrate in their footballers, while at the same time fingering others for crippling McKinnon, let's take a trip down memory lane:

[youtube]RzCTX7lcqfc[/youtube]

Who celebrated that? :roll:
 

Maximus

Coach
Messages
13,884
Maybe smith was doing his job as capt getting in the refs ear so was unaware exactly what was going on?

That says more about him than anything. Someone is injured and all he cares about is arguing with the ref (because apparently that's what a captain has to do) even when they tell him to leave it until after McKinnon is treated.

Or maybe not, either way his actions afterwards to do what he could to support him need to be taken into account before casting rocks at him. He's no angel but you don't become the club, state and country captain without having something others respect. I doubt there are many fans on here who could genuine,y say they wouldn't have wanted him at their club over the last few years.

What has Smith really done? Wore a different jersey number? Wow Thurston, Inglis, Hayne, Ennis, Lyon and Farah all did that as well? Didn't the NRL request that they do it? Smith couldn't exactly refuse.

He and a bunch of other players apparently requested to see McKinnon in hospital, but he cared so much that he never bothered to follow it up afterwards. Mclean has spoken to him, so it's not like it hasn't been possible.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
70,123
Yeah because that's on par with crippling someone.

you honestly think he went out to deliberately cripple him? Or even deliberately spear him? Come on we've seen 30 plus of these tackles since that injury, it was an accident, it happens in games, it still happens in games, it will continue to happen in games. Either there is some intent in these type of tackles, in which case the NRL is failing miserably in its duty of care given how lenient the punishments, or accidents happen in high speed collision sports like ZrL and sometimes players end up in bad positions.
 

Canard

Immortal
Messages
35,719
But it's not comparable, apparently. f**k knows why.

Late and after the whistle, but the NRL ruled that both players had no case to answer for.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top