Fifita finished up as a depth player here, Woods had well and truly passed him and Groat was in the team over him. The only reason we are feeling his loss is because we left ourselves short front rowers. If we could keep 1 of Fifita/Woods we definitely made the right call. Letting Gibbs go was just dumb, we persisted with him for years of mediocrity (2006-2008) then mid 09 he started to come good, and by 2011 he was a quality front rower, not to mention well liked across the squad, a club junior with plenty of experience. Getting rid of him was a massive c**k up, and the guy who was meant to replace him was a flop.