JJ said:
ok -where was his bat in the ashes?
I'll take one scratchy series for all the magnificent knocks he's played before and after that. Also, I think any player who made one of the most important centuries in his career doesn't really have to prove anything to anyone about his batting efforts. There were a few other blokes who could have taken a bit more on themselves in that series. Not everything is to be blamed on Ponting's batting.... Just to refresh your memory...
http://content-aus.cricinfo.com/australia/content/story/216142.html
England v Australia, 3rd Test, Old Trafford, 5th day
Ponting finds his feet, and Freddie's heroics
On the ball with S Rajesh and Arun Gopalakrishnan
August 15, 2005
Throughout the series,
Ricky Ponting had been struggling for runs, but he put it all together under serious adversity to score what is easily his most significant Test innings to date. It wasn't a typical Ponting effort - he began scratchily, taking 105 balls to reach his half-century, but from there, it kept getting better: his next 50 took just 64 balls, and he needed only 78 more to get to 150.
Ponting's problem so far on tour had been his footwork; here, it showed vast improvement. He wasn't very dominant off the front foot, but he made the bowlers pay whenever they pitched short. And he was only caught on the crease 18 times, a sign that he is slowly regaining his best form.
Ponting's fantastic knock thwarted a wholehearted effort from England, led by Andrew Flintoff. Flintoff has been in devastating form with both bat and ball in this series, and what's been especially impressive is the manner in which he has bowled to the left-handers in the Australian line-up. On the final day at Old Trafford, Flintoff proved once again that he had the measure of the left-handers, dismissing three of them - Matthew Hayden, Simon Katich and Adam Gilchrist - and conceding just 18 runs from the 60 balls he bowled at them.
Flintoff's confidence in his ability shone through in the manner in which he attacked the batsmen. He switched from over the wicket to round the wicket regularly, but seldom erred in direction while doing so, keeping it on a good length around off stump most of the time. The way he shackled Adam Gilchrist was quite outstanding - in 22 balls, Gilchrist managed only a single before eventually falling to him for the third time in the series. Flintoff's effectiveness against left-handers can also be gauged by the number of false strokes he induced from them - 15 times the ball took the edge or beat the bat. Even Ponting did not take too many liberties against him, scoring only 19 from 49 deliveries.
