What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Benji Marshall ?

bottle

Coach
Messages
14,126
Do we have a spare dressing room for him?

Maybe he's been humbled a little by this experience and modified his expectations a bit, who knows? Can only hope he doesn't expect to run the situation as was reputed to be the case at the Tiges.

I'm undecided on whether he brings a benefit.
Those stating a case for citing increased desire and better attitude might be right.
Those stating a case against citing age, loss of form and ability might be right.
Only one way to find out.

Won't address the longer term issue. Would give both Williams and Style an opportunity for further development and a chance to show they can dominate in the lower grades if they have it.
 

blacksafake

First Grade
Messages
9,718
Me i'm in two minds.:?
Pluses ability,experience,takes pressure of widdop,as stated before very marketable(kids love him),redemption,confident is his ability to play whats in front of him without price coaching it out of him & hes better than what we have as well as who'll be on the market next year as well.
Minuses,ego,attitude although he may be a bit more humble now.If he does or doesn't sign i wont be slashing my wrists.
 

kit66

Bench
Messages
4,126
I've only just heard of this developement now, haven't seen anything online other than here. If it's true it could be a good thing for the team but he'll look very strange in a Saints jersey I reckon.
I hope we keep Williams on board and work hard with him because that kid has a lot of potential and I thought, deserved more than a couple of fg games to show his worth.
So we will now have a quality back up hooker ( Witt ) to throw on the bench if Rein ( who is playing well anyway ) needs some support.
Just a thought, can Benji play hooker ?
 

DRAGONSNZ

Bench
Messages
2,696
Under the radar - but favourites from what I am hearing in NZ.
good chance he signs with Dragons.

Best mix between Salary, Chance of winning and lifestyle for Marshall.

Im in NZ too and where the hell did you hear that? cause all im reading over here is he is either going to the Sharks or Storm. Don't get me wrong it would be great to have Benchy in the team but its highly unlikely as I have heard he has said he wouldn't join the Dragons (manager doesnt like and wonttalk to Doust).
 
Messages
11,938
I've only just heard of this developement now, haven't seen anything online other than here. If it's true it could be a good thing for the team but he'll look very strange in a Saints jersey I reckon.
I hope we keep Williams on board and work hard with him because that kid has a lot of potential and I thought, deserved more than a couple of fg games to show his worth.
So we will now have a quality back up hooker ( Witt ) to throw on the bench if Rein ( who is playing well anyway ) needs some support.
Just a thought, can Benji play hooker ?

If they are trying to sign Marshall to play back-up hooker, then he ain't coming here, surely.

And I agree with earlier posts, re Tauber, he won't deal with Doust, so can't see how a signing is even remotely possible.
 

to_ddeath

Coach
Messages
11,932
Just great. If we do end up landing Bumji, & he breaks a fingernail spending 3 months on the sidelines then Saintsified will have another scapegoat ready as a reason to keep chinless for another fking season :lol:


T.
 

kit66

Bench
Messages
4,126
If they are trying to sign Marshall to play back-up hooker, then he ain't coming here, surely.

And I agree with earlier posts, re Tauber, he won't deal with Doust, so can't see how a signing is even remotely possible.

I wasn't implying that that's why we're siging him - that wouldn't make any sense - even for the Dragons management.
I was just asking, randomly, if he can play hooker.
 

Saintsified

Bench
Messages
3,558
Just great. If we do end up landing Bumji, & he breaks a fingernail spending 3 months on the sidelines then Saintsified will have another scapegoat ready as a reason to keep chinless for another fking season :lol:




T.

I love you too clueless
 

The Nick

Bench
Messages
2,660
What if we sign him today, NZ name him in their squad for the test and then he does his shoulder or an ACL without even playing for us!?
 

Latest posts

Top