What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Best Ref Ever

OPS

Juniors
Messages
55
Ive been watching the game since mid 70s and Greg Macallum is the best ref i have seen.Harrigan is close behind but these 2 are miles in front of any others.Macallum was in the middle in a great era of RL late 80s to middle 90s he rarely made a mistake even in the fastest of games.
 

Calixte

First Grade
Messages
5,428
I'll preface this post with the comment that I generally like David Morrow as a commentator. He has real passion for the game.

The 1990 Kangaroo Tour produced one of the best Test series ever played.

All three tests were refereed by Alain Sablayrolles, the Frenchman. French referees generally have a fairly poor reputation - some of it deserved, some not.

The fact is Sablayrolles put in a superb performance across the three Tests for a man who did not speak English and had to communicate with two English speaking captains in Meninga and Hanley.

The odd decision was incorrect, but he took excellent control of the teams and the result was glorious football...

Sablayrolles was castigated by both Morrow and Graeme Hughes in the commentary box. Both were clearly feeling the pinch in the 1st and 2nd Tests when their team (Australia) looked like going down in the series.

This manifested itself in Morrow particularly accusing Sablayrolles of not having a clue about the game.

I mention the example as one which shows that even a pretty good football judge can lose the plot when it comes to referees in the right context.

I am also not saying Sablayrolles was the best ref ever. But he had a superb series in trying circumstances (including a right blast from Fulton after the First Test - who then showed the referee was the last issue at fault by making wholesale changes before the second Test).
 

Loudstrat

Coach
Messages
15,224
Good call Calxite. That was a fantastic series

Recall another Frog, Julian Rasganere (sp?) who reffed some Trans Tasman tests, who did a great job too.

ON that vein - how come there are no French, PNG or Kiwi referees in the NRL/ESL or international calendar?
 

Calixte

First Grade
Messages
5,428
Clearly we as an international sport need look no further than FIFA in this regard.

Neutral refs for international games must be a standard in rugby league.

The fact we don't have them is another example of how we as Australians continue to maintain an uneven playing field at international level in TGG.
 
Messages
12,700
I like the way McCullum used to tell players to f**k OFF. Before sports ears came out in 97 though of course LOL. He clearly told Ricky Stuart (and I think Laurie Daley too) to f**k OFF during the 94 GF when they were questioning him about a disallowed try. He then told Meninga to come over, and told him what was up. I find it hilarious every time.
 
Messages
1,186
McCallum... argh!

He hated us. Or maybe he just rubbed us out in 1992 because a few weeks earlier him and the touchies awarded Wishy a kick that he actually missed from almost in front!
 
Messages
12,700
Ian Russell was a f**kin gun ball playing lock in that Illawarra side. Johnny Simon was a damn good player too.
 

Calixte

First Grade
Messages
5,428
Loved Hampson's and Gregory's short (concurrent) stretches at the Steelers too...

Both quality players as well.
 

Latest posts

Top