What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Brett Stewart found not guilty of sexual assault

Garts

Bench
Messages
4,360
I cannot believe Manly fans are still defending him.

I am not defending him. If he is guilty he will get what he deserves, however at the moment he is not. I do not know all the facts, so I will not cast judgement. I am hoping he is innocent or whatever happened is very, very minor and he is not rubbed out of the game for good.
 

Moffo

Referee
Messages
23,986
it means that they have grounds enough to charge him. manly denied that anything happened. dna test anyone?
 

Lambretta

First Grade
Messages
8,689
Excuse me for being a bit dim... but are you saying it's perfectly acceptable to randomly crash tackle someone potentially half your own bodyweight. Fair dinkum, you may have some good points in your argument, but you've thrown them out the door in your illogically written post.

Prank or no prank, if you crash tackle someone unexpectantly they could hit their head on cement, suffer major internal bleeding, and either die or face long term injuries. I don't think there's a funny side to a 'prank' like that.

No I'm not. I was crash tackled by someone - in an unsuspecting manner - and I got injured from it. Whilst I could have pressed charges (as it was an extremely stupid thing for the drunken idiot to do) I didn't. I laughed it off, even with a huge bloody bruise on my leg.

What I was more referring to - was that being jumped on unexpectedly by a drunken idiot isn't assault in my book. It's an act of stupidity - not maliciousness. Had I been female I could have had the bloke up on sexual assault charges. Yep - touching any female body part - an invasion of personal space like that can be "sexual assault".

I was saying that on the initial report - he'd dragged the girl into a darkened stairwell and he was discovered when she screamed and ran to a neighbours unit for help.

That is sinister in the extreme and doesn't smack of drunken stupidity. But as more reports came to light - it didnt appear to be as awful as was first reported.


However all that aside - Brett Stewart has been charged with assault and as such he should do the right thing and step down until after the charges are withdrawn or the matter goes to court.

If he doesnt do the right thing and step down himself - the club should stand him down. No if's no buts. There's no pretending nothing happened now that he's been charged.
 

Lambretta

First Grade
Messages
8,689
I am not defending him. If he is guilty he will get what he deserves, however at the moment he is not. I do not know all the facts, so I will not cast judgement. I am hoping he is innocent or whatever happened is very, very minor and he is not rubbed out of the game for good.

All malicious jealousy against a club people don't support aside - I think this is the feeling alot of people have.

We all hope that the allegations are not true. It's a sad day if they are.

But in the meantime, I think Brett should stand down and allow the legal process to take place. It's morally the decent thing to do - even if he believes he's done nothing wrong.
 

Ice Ice Brady

Juniors
Messages
2,470
I am not defending him. If he is guilty he will get what he deserves, however at the moment he is not. I do not know all the facts, so I will not cast judgement. I am hoping he is innocent or whatever happened is very, very minor and he is not rubbed out of the game for good.

Exactly.

You don't know ANYTHING about what happened. All we have are a series of media speculation.

What we do know is that the police believe they can prosecute for an offence. Of course he could come out of this innocent though.

However, we know nothing. Remain impartial. I am remaining impartial until I see a Brief on April 7 of the alleged facts.
 

wittyfan

Referee
Messages
29,999
They said 5-7 days yesterday for the DNA test results, getting them today seems a bit too quickly.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,992
how about the poor girl?

Legally cannot be identified and should not be either. She should not be subject to media scrutiny unless she or her family have been found to have fabricated it after the case is heard in April or later.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,992
Nothing has been said about the DNA tests in relation to the charges, the DNA results have already been said to not be in until Saturday.

The charge was made based on Stewart's statement to police this evening.
 

Lambretta

First Grade
Messages
8,689
i gather the dna tests were done quickly, hence the charges ..

ps .. michael bani will a top fullback ..

DNA tests proving what exactly? That there was bodily contact between two people or that there was sperm inside her?

I don't think there was any doubt that he touched her. It's more the manner in which she was touched that is in question surely?

Anyway - it will be interesting to see how this pans out.
 

Garts

Bench
Messages
4,360
Exactly.

You don't know ANYTHING about what happened. All we have are a series of media speculation.

What we do know is that the police believe they can prosecute for an offence. Of course he could come out of this innocent though.

However, we know nothing. Remain impartial. I am remaining impartial until I see a Brief on April 7 of the alleged facts.

Nor do you. My view is to let him play if he is in the right state of mind until judged innocent or guility.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,992
Ice Ice Brady... you've been far from impartial in this thread :lol:
 
Messages
21,880
What does interest me here is to find out what makes this sexual assault as opposed to just plain assault.

Im only guessing here but it seems like this will be towards the minor end of the scale.

In saying that though there is no excuse for that type of behaviour no matter how minor. ( if he did do it)
 

Ice Ice Brady

Juniors
Messages
2,470
Ice Ice Brady... you've been far from impartial in this thread :lol:

I've stated facts.

I've not stated he is guilty or innocent. But under the law he is innocent until he is proven guilty.

Until the case is finished, I believe he should be stood down from the NRL because it is the right thing to do.

If a politician had similar charges, there is no way he would be attending question time.
 
Messages
3,818
Nor do you. My view is to let him play if he is in the right state of mind until judged innocent or guility.
PMSL...spoken like a manly supporter...let him play!..your kidding yourself.....can you imagine the pressure being put on manly right now from the NRL to drop him...it will happen tomorrow
.."in the interests......" or"in light of......"
 

sting

Bench
Messages
3,936
He will never be allowed to work in the UK or enter the US as well as being under close scrutiny in places like Thailand and China.

you don't know what you're on about. even if he gets proven guilty there may not definitely be a conviction recored which means he will eventually be allowed to enter the US and would mostly be able to one day work in the UK.

i don't know about china, but thailand? have you ever been there? you're clueless mate.

stop talking sh*t about things you know nothing about.
 

Latest posts

Top