Brian Smith must be sacked RIGHT NOW!!!!!

[Misty Bee]

For the last few seasons, the Smith lovers, namely HJ, have defended our massive underachievement to rediculous levels. Jast year, we were shit because of injuries. Tonight, we were at full strength. Hell, we even bought about a tonne of muscle to our pissweak forwards could go forward. Everyone bagged Dykes, and some numbnuts even suggested signing upSmith for life!

Well, tonight, there are no excuses. Apart from Dykes, Grothe, Cannings and Sideshow, the side was a total complete and utter disgrace to the club. (and possibly poor old Killer, left alone in defence because Smith kept Vaealiki on the bench while playing poor old Sideshow out of position against a rising Country and Western star).

And what is this Luke Burt shit at fullback? We got rid of one small fullback because he kept getting smashed (although he played like the champ that he is in the Tigers jumper this arvo). And we replace him with another one? What was the friggin point with that????

As for the forwards, Cannings can turn up for training, and the rest (even Hindy was crap) can go and f*ck off after that performance.

What friggin use is Vella in the forwards anymore? When the game was quick in '01, a pacey prop was a good tactic. Now this ex winger finds himself utterly usurped in every department. The C & W debutant ran over himlike he was the neihbours cat!

As for the Llama, he is less use than a sponge at a flood. Brian Smith would be better served to plant a tree midfield and put a no 6 jumper on it! At least the tree would create oxygen. hell, you could even bounce the balloff the trunk toward the centres - a position I'm damn sure the Llama has no friggin idea of it's existence.

Some positives: Eric Grothe - champions have great games when the rest of the side is gettnig smashed. Well done. Great to see Dykes run the show in the second half. Put Witty beside him, tell Cayless, Hindy et all to keep their fat traps shut in attack, and let him go. Without him, we are South Sydney like.

And Cannings had a dig, didn't he. But a point- all season we discussed how big we were, and tonight none of em stacked up against Mason and Johnny Cash - The Poxtel Morons Daley and Freeman alerady have him pegged as the best Kiwi ever!

Brian Smith - the archiatect of this team, must be sacked tonight. The Smith lovers will ask "but who do we replace him with?" Easy - after toniht, there are 19,999,999 people in Australia who could do better. Hell, even HJ, between fashion parades and AA meetings, would do better!

Smith - it's an utter disgrace. Leave now!

 

[Chipmunk]

For the last few seasons, the Smith lovers, namely HJ, have defended our massive underachievement to rediculous levels. Jast year, we were sh*t because of injuries. Tonight, we were at full strength. Hell, we even bought about a tonne of muscle to our pissweak forwards could go forward. Everyone bagged Dykes, and some numbnuts even suggested signing upSmith for life!

Well, tonight, there are no excuses. Apart from Dykes, Grothe and Sideshow (and possibly poor old Killer, left alone in defence because Smith kept Vaealiki on the bench while playing poor old Sideshow out of position against a rising Country and Western star).

And what is this Luke Burt sh*t at fullback? We got rid of one small fullback because he kept getting smashed (although he played like the champ that he is in the Togers jumper this arvo). And we replace himwith another one?

As for teh forwards, Cannings can turn upfor training, and the rest (even Hindy was crap)can go and f*ck off after that performance.

What friggin use is Vella in the forwards a nymore? When the game was quick in '01, a pacey prop was a good tactic. Now this ex winger finds himself utterly usurped in every department. The C & W debutant ran over himlike he was the neihbours cat!

As for the Llama, he is less use than a sponge at a flood. Brian Smith would be better served to plant a tree midfield and put a no 6 jumper on it! At least the tree would create oxygen. hell, you could even bounce the balloff the trunk toward the centres - a position I'm damn sure the Llama has no friggin idea of it's existence.

Some positives: Eric Grothe - champions have great games when the rest of the side is gettnig smashed. Well done. Great to see Dykes run the show in the second half. Put Witty beside him, tell Cayless, Hindy et all to keep their fat traps shut in attack, and let him go. Without him, we are South Sydney like.

And Cannings had a dig, didn't he. But a point- all season we discussed how big we were, and tonight none of em stacked up against Mason and Johnny Cash - The Poxtel Morons Daley and Freeman alerady have him pegged as the best Kiwi ever!

Brian Smith - the archiatect of this team, must be sacked tonight. The Smith lovers will ask "but who do we replace him with?" Easy - after toniht, there are 19,999,999 people in Australia who could do better. Hell, even HJ, between fashion parades and AA meetings, would do better!

Smith - it's an utter disgrace. Leave now!

Tell us how you really feel Misty Bee!

 

[Ron Jeremy]

I agree with most of what you said Misty.....but the our senior players where absolutely shit house.

Hindmarsh- Shit
Vella - Shit
Burt- Shit
Lyon- Shit


These 4 players we depend on so much.....and they have totally mocked our club tonight.

f**k RL!!

 

[Chipmunk]

I too agree with alot of what you said.

I really dont think we have replaced the players that we let go last year with ones that are really that much better. Grothe went well, deserved his try. I must say looking at him after he scored that try he had a look on him like he was thinking "What have I done coming back here!"

Cannings is a good buy and I think Muckert will be the same, Thorman should turn OK and Stapleton didnt go too bad

But, I couldnt agree with this post more! I was saying it twelve months ago. Come on, where are the Smith Lovers tonight! They have been very quiet, Come on, get your butts in here.....NOW!!

 

[Ron Jeremy]

There is no way HJ can offer excuses.....he has to show some balls and provide critisim where it is due.

It's a side day for our club....espically when you look at the so called " Great players " we have.

Hindmarsh shouldn't be excused from critisism either!.....his performance was the worst i've ever seen from him.....great player yes!!...but tonight disgusting!!!

 

[Y2Eel]

id have to agree with you on this one misty i was a smith supporter last season and even up to 8:00pm tonight.... but when i saw the team he had posted to play the bulldogs i knew we were no hopers.... the team was crap thats all i can say and smith had better hope next week comes quickly to get a top team up the to qld to beat the broncs as i think that game is his last chance.......


why the hell play peterson at outside centre and a tiny fullback behind a huge defence and a massive opposition what was he ment to do???????



next weeks team better be alot different.... hopefully like this....

1: vielekie
2. grothe
3.lyon
4. whoever beside peterson.... mayb luke odwyer
5. wise he did all right
6. dykes
7 witt/thorman
8. Corey PEARSON
9. morris
10. cannings/ armit
11 hindy
12 cayless
13 who know but not wagon armit??

14. webster we need some one to take the ball around the ruck
15 Michael VELLA
16 Adam PEEK
17 Dean WIDDERS

 

[wittyz chick]

i agree with Misty
all the Smith lovers r probably out getting drunk to think of another excuse :x
but i guess outta the hole mess of a game tonight there was 1 funny moment when Sideshow went off for a run with Willie behind him and Big Willie pulled Sideshows hair so Sideshow threw the ball at him :lol: that was dumb...Willie couldve flattened him in 1

 

[strider]

I'll defend Smithy - cos he wasn't out there dropping balls every damn set of six and standing still while the doggies ran round him......it was the bloody players!!!

You are all being hypocritcal twits.....one minute Smithy is to blame for buying the players - BUT Cannings is a star - well who frickin bought him? ...Stapleton also had a strong game.

I'm not saying Smithy is blameless - obviously we weren't ready for the onslaught tonight and that is primarily the coaches fault.....he's gotta get hold of the guys and give em a bloody big kick up the arse this week!!!


Its the stars at our club that need to take a good look at themselves tonight...Lyon and several defensive lapses 2 of which that led to the first 2 doggies tries - and you try to blame Lyons problems on Peterson??? - grow a brain, they play on opposite sides of the field!!! - don't get me wrong, Jamie is my favourite player, but he didn't have a good game at all.....Vella looked lost.....Hindy and Caylo seemed to try, but were well below their best.

As for Grothe - I like him, he'll be a good player for us this year.....BUT someone tell him which way we r running......he made about 200m tonight running from one side of the field to the other.

I think the players have to have a good hard look at em selves after tonight...realise theres a shitload of work to be done and stand up to be counted.

 

[Chipmunk]

Did anyone see the game on Fox or go to the game? Every time they showed a shot of Smith who he got booed!! Bring It On! He must go!

 

[Y2Eel]

Did anyone see the game on Fox or go to the game? Every time they showed a shot of Smith who he got booed!! Bring It On! He must go!

 

[wittyz chick]

well if parra dont improve against the broncos i will certainly be booing him at parra

 

[Redback71]

have to agree also but dont forget its not the coach out there whos playing sure he picks the players and puts them in there postions, buts its the bloody players who were shit house today not the coach the coach is just shit because he depended on this sorry excuse of a team to play like they were ment to.

forwards my flamin 5 yr old son could defend better

 

[Eelectrica]

Whilst Smith didn't drop the ball that lead to a lot of Dogs tries, he would have set the defensive pattern that constantly saw the dogs go length of the field on us. He did select Wagon at 5/8th who apart from throwing a couple of Dummies did nothing in attack.
I counted 3 touches of the ball for Lyon - One out of dummy half, one where he had no choice but to knock the bal dead and one hit up that ended in a dropped ball. Lyon HAS to get the ball one way or the other.

It will be very interesting to see what happens to Smith if we don't put on a better display against the Broncos. Might be a commentator for Fox sports for the Newcastle game.

 

[THE KEGG]

Mysty Bee,

I agree with a lot of your comments...

but are u a moderator here?, your language and abusive swear words are very poor examples of a "moderator"

 

[strider]

There was nothing wrong with the "defensive pattern" - it was the lack of commitment in defense that set the doggies free......and the players have to take most of the responsibility for that.....it'll be Smithies job to give em hell this week for playing touch footy.

 

[GoParra]

Certainly changes his tune pretty fast though don't you Misty, I'm glad I don't hang around these boards anymore to watch everybody lapse into tears when our boys play crap, and yes thats what they played CRAP even the big guns of Cayless, Hindmarsh Lyon etc but sure once again lets all throw the blame at 1 solitary guy. Don't bother flaming me Misty and feel free to ban me for what it's worth because i hardly waste my time here. I'll follow my Parra until i breathe no more, be it that we come 1st or last, Sure i don't enjoy losing it grates at me like a potato peeler across my bare skin, but i sure as hell don't sit around and whine like a kicked puppy and point the finger at 1 man who gives his bloody all to our club !!!

 

[Chipmunk]

There was nothing wrong with the "defensive pattern" - it was the lack of commitment in defense that set the doggies free......and the players have to take most of the responsibility for that.....it'll be Smithies job to give em hell this week for playing touch footy.

Smith came up with that ingenius Defensive Pattern that partnered Adam Dykes and Matt Petersen together.

Smith is in charge of the Recruitment and Retention of players. So he came up with the players he wanted and the ones he wanted to let go and also the ones he wanted to keep.

Smith picks a team that doesnt have a Half-Back. Sure Dykes was in the number 7, but he still played like he was still playing at Five-Eighth. We looked disorganised. Strangely enough, that happens when you dont have anyone in your 'organisers' position

Smith plays a player at Five-Eighth who is not capable of passing a ball, which ensures that our Centre's never get the ball

Smith is in charge of motivation of the team and the players that leaves to the lack of commitment in defence. Defence is all about ATTITUDE. This Club once had a catch cry in 2001 known as PARRAMATTITUDE. I ask, what ever happened to this PARRAMATTIUDE

Smith is in charge of our attacking game plan. Yes, he buys bigger players, anyone can buy bigger players. But he is trying to play one out football and have bigger players to run over the top of players that are only slightly smaller than our 'bigger players'. This is NRL first grade not an Under 13 Club football game. The size and speed of the players is not the only ingredient to winning.

Smith is responsible for alot more, but for how much longer is anyone's guess!!!

 

[Misty Bee]

I'll defend Smithy - cos he wasn't out there dropping balls every damn set of six and standing still while the doggies ran round him......it was the bloody players!!!

You are all being hypocritcal twits.....one minute Smithy is to blame for buying the players - BUT Cannings is a star - well who frickin bought him? ...Stapleton also had a strong game.

I'm not saying Smithy is blameless - obviously we weren't ready for the onslaught tonight and that is primarily the coaches fault.....he's gotta get hold of the guys and give em a bloody big kick up the arse this week!!!


Its the stars at our club that need to take a good look at themselves tonight...Lyon and several defensive lapses 2 of which that led to the first 2 doggies tries - and you try to blame Lyons problems on Peterson??? - grow a brain, they play on opposite sides of the field!!! - don't get me wrong, Jamie is my favourite player, but he didn't have a good game at all.....Vella looked lost.....Hindy and Caylo seemed to try, but were well below their best.

As for Grothe - I like him, he'll be a good player for us this year.....BUT someone tell him which way we r running......he made about 200m tonight running from one side of the field to the other.

I think the players have to have a good hard look at em selves after tonight...realise theres a shitload of work to be done and stand up to be counted.

Strider, that is the most stupid post this century! Al llast year you Smith lover churned out this crap after each flogging. "PoorSmithy - he doesn't dropbalsormiss tackles" Oh no, but after 8 friggin years you would have thought he could have taught 'em how to hold on to the bloody thing!!!

Maybe you are not a complete moron after all! aybe it IS the players faul. Hey, why don't we change a heap of 'em, and buy a heap of new ones? Well, pal, we id that last season. Remember?

The players, with our wonderful transit lounge of aclub, are not the common denominator. The common denominators are 1) incessant floggings, and 2) brian smith.

You work ou the rest of the story, ay!!!

 

[Ron Jeremy]

Matt Peterson was on Sonny Bill Willams

Jamie Lyon was on Willie Tonga

This is for you Strider.

Both had poor games....but Sonny Bill was walking all over Peterson it made me cringe.

 

[strider]

Call it the stupidest post this century id u like - but u never actually argued against anything I said....just your usual mindless dribble blaming one person for it all.

Yeah I defend smithy, but as I said "Smithy is not blameless", it is his responsibilty to get teh team ready, but I can't say whether he does a decent job of it or not - I am not at training, I don't hear what he says.....so until I see/hear it first hand I'll be blaming the entire coaching and playing staff.