Saints have plenty of good choices for coaches at the moment in Ryles, Hornby, Hasler, Flanno and Maguire. Would anyone really be too upset if any of these guys got the nod compared to what they had for the last 12 seasons? The only guy I think the fans will be upset about is Young, only because he has had the least success in his apprenticeship than Hornby or Ryles. If the Cowboys were flying this year maybe a different story but it is clear that last year they over achieved. Copping 66 points against the last placed Tigers and being the defence coach really would not look good on your resume. They have been awful this year.
I know Ryles has not been to much better at the Chooks this season, but has been in a system that won comps in the Storm which edges out Hornby and especially Young. The other 3 experience coaches speak for themselves. If Saints get anyone else out of the 5 good candidates then that would be crazy.