What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Coaching preference for 2024

What are you hoping for in our next coaching appointment?

  • Rookie Coach

    Votes: 21 14.5%
  • Premiership Winning Coach

    Votes: 105 72.4%
  • NRL Experience coach with no Premiership wins

    Votes: 6 4.1%
  • Coach from Overseas

    Votes: 5 3.4%
  • Extend Current coach

    Votes: 8 5.5%

  • Total voters
    145

Captn

Juniors
Messages
28
2 WINS does not change anything about Hook. Still indifferent performances, still indifferent use of bench and swapping of starting line ups? Still talk of player unrest. Had his chance, time to go. More time same story. Move now before best candidates have contracts for 2024.
 

Ghostrider22

Juniors
Messages
559
I do t understand why Hornby’s name doesn’t get a mention. Has servered a great apprenticeship under Bennett and now demitriou. South’s are a well run club with good pathways. I’d be happy for this legend to come back
Cussy your right except for one thing 2 boards on a joint venture don’t get on and do not work for the same thing everyone on here wants so badly.

Remember we had Coach running the football Club and no one I mean no one would go against Coach. Remember Doust stated I can sleep at night because of Wayne. There is so much politics in a football club. Having 2 boards don’t work period. Look at the tigers what a basket case that joint is.
 

dungay dragon

Juniors
Messages
1,323
Last edited:

dragon thomo

Juniors
Messages
1,224
Griffin has to go due to losing parts of the shed.
If Hunt pushes the fact he would leave due to Griffin departure then so be it.
But as it has been mentioned he is under a pretty good contract.
As for Haas I would rather have a crack at big Nelson. I think he would be a great leader for our pack.Imagine our young forwards grow in confidence if we signed him.
 

BLM01

First Grade
Messages
9,864
Griffin has to go due to losing parts of the shed.
If Hunt pushes the fact he would leave due to Griffin departure then so be it.
But as it has been mentioned he is under a pretty good contract.
As for Haas I would rather have a crack at big Nelson. I think he would be a great leader for our pack.Imagine our young forwards grow in confidence if we signed him.
NAS to rugby most likely
 

SEAT 1A

Bench
Messages
3,353

Got no issue with Hunt giving his opinion on club matters however, the club hasn't reached the finals in god knows let alone the top four and a chance of winning the competition. Making the finals would show the club has gone forward with Griffin.

Hook did sign Liddle, Big Ben and the Manly dudes for Woods which has made the team go forward but his job is to make the eight.
 

Dragon David

First Grade
Messages
9,135
Got no issue with Hunt giving his opinion on club matters however, the club hasn't reached the finals in god knows let alone the top four and a chance of winning the competition. Making the finals would show the club has gone forward with Griffin.

Hook did sign Liddle, Big Ben and the Manly dudes for Woods which has made the team go forward but his job is to make the eight.
...and the only way that Hook can get the job done and make the top 8 at the end of the 2023 comp is by remaining as the coach for the duration of the year. Hunt sees that with Hook being banished and sent to oblivion midway through the comp will destabilise the team ..“If we get four or five weeks down the road and we start again, it will set this club back a couple of years,”.

Hook is contracted to the end of the year and Hunt wants him to keep going I guess.
 

ChocOConnor

Juniors
Messages
448
I don’t mind Hook I think he really loves the club. But Benny mate if the club thinks it can move forward with someone else don’t you think you being the club captain should not force the clubs hand and threaten with leaving. If that’s the case I’d put you at 9 move Bud to 7 and if pan for next year cause I’ll open the door for you to walk out if you don’t want to be here cause may be you should think what’s best for the club not just yourself you selfish P!!!!k
 

Coffs dragon

Bench
Messages
4,386

Mojo

Bench
Messages
4,000
IMO Hunt is a very good individual player, but not a great hooker or halfback and not a great team player or captain. He excels at rep level because having great players around him really suits his individual style of play. He scores Dally M points at club level because his individual skills really stand-out. However, I think we're feeling the effects of the excessive reliance we've invested in him - on the field but also, especially, off the field, since he came to us in 2018.

He seems to be very 'political'. There's been such a sequence since he came to the club: Mary and McInnes exit, Hook employed, McGuire, McCullough, Mbye recruited. Hunt, McGuire, McCullough all played in the 2008 Brisbane Broncos Toyota Cup premiership winning side. Mbye and Corey Norman also came through the Qld junior sides and into the Broncos around that time. Hunt's first grade career really started in 2010. Hook coached that Toyota Cup side and took over from Ivan Henjack as 1st grade coach in 2011. He had a pretty good coaching record, which got even better, in fact, it was very good, while he was at Penrith.

It's very noticeable that Hunt and Mbye have spoken publicly in support of Hook. It's also starkly obvious that all of these guys are rusted on to each other. No doubt they're justifiably proud of their past achievements and it seems they really have faith in Hook as a coach - but their real high-point with Hook was 15 years ago now!

Also, no doubt, coaching the Dragon's has been an absolute prick of a job. I think it's just very obvious that this 'Qld mates' thing has made the task much more difficult (even though they think they've 'got this') and the challenge has been compounded by the fact that the favouritism, which, let's be honest, has been stubbornly on full display, must have been incredibly demotivating for everyone else.

Whether it's been with the best of intentions or poor judgment, it hasn't worked at all. It's time to face the facts. They might have been a great team 15 years ago, but not any more.
 
Top