Commentators your best and worst

[TruSaint]

I like Vossy, Warren Smith and especially Ginane. Rabs was No.1 and will always be a favourite of mine. The rest are ok. They are no way near as biased as Fatty was that is for sure. Sick of him saying "Go Manly" most of the times. If I was a Rooster fan I would hate that as he played for them when Manly did not want him anymore and you would never of known with his commentary.

As for commentators bagging Saints, the last few years can you blame them? They have been terrible to watch under Mary. This year they are getting some occasional good stuff spoken about them but the bad has been deserved most times because they have done some pretty ordinary stuff. The Anzac game capitulation was terrible, losing to the Tigers and Warriors undid all the good work of the 4 good wins. The bad decision that went against us they mostly agreed and were confused as everyone else at the terrible call.

I don't mind Vos, but Smith is crap.

Just watch the 2010 GF on 9 v Fox. His call was pathetic.

This was when we were going well, so the adage of " how can you blame them " is moot.

 

[SBD82]

This thread is sorely lacking in Matt Nable montages.

 

[muzby]

This thread is sorely lacking in Matt Nable montages.

What do you mean? I’ve been reading the whole thread in my best Matt Nable voice..

 

[The Villain]

ABC Grandstand commentators the best by a mile. Best on tv is Voss. The rest are the worst.

 

[Dragsters]

As for callers:

Vossy best hands down.

Rabs was the best but is past it.

Peter Psaltis on 9 is ok, can't cop the other bloke.

Hadley worst with Smith a close second

Commentators, well they're all shite except Sterlo really...

 

[Dragonssupporter]

Again tonight-the bias against the Dragons from Ch 9 is unbelieveable.Last week against Melbourne almost made me throw up.But this week with that pig Gallen making comments-at our home ground too-wow i hope to get to watch someone punch his lights out in the ring.
So sick of the media treating us so badly

 

[dragons girl]

Alexander, anasta, Warren Smith, Andrew Johns, Matthew johns all crap.
Sterlo the best.

Braith Annasta the worst.I don't think ha has ever gotten over losing in 2010 to the Mighty dragons was not much of a player and has carried that over into commentary

 

[Como Connection]

I like Thirsty Marrow, Stelo, Gus, Ennis and Blocker.
Warren Smith, Andrew Moore, Ray Warren and Alexander are my worst.
CC

 

[Walpole]

Today, in a coup for Fox, they trotted out the worst commentator of all time on the Manly, Parra game. A man so bad, so f**king useless, so atrociously bad at putting two words together, a man destined forever to serve as a reminder that concussions have a lasting effect.

I give you one Mark "Spud" Carroll. If only they'd had the foresight to put an actual spud on the sideline and ask for its input the coverage would have been far superior. The first time in ages I've switched back to Nine. Well done Spud, you are the winner.

 

[currumbinsaint21]

To be fair to spud he can play a mean piano

 

[mighty red and whites]

Hadley the worst by the length of the straight

 

[aussie7798]

Blocker is the worst followed closely by hadley, spud and anasta.

the rest of the fox crew are pretty shit

ABC is hands down the best

Today, in a coup for Fox, they trotted out the worst commentator of all time on the Manly, Parra game. A man so bad, so f**king useless, so atrociously bad at putting two words together, a man destined forever to serve as a reminder that concussions have a lasting effect.

I give you one Mark "Spud" Carroll. If only they'd had the foresight to put an actual spud on the sideline and ask for its input the coverage would have been far superior. The first time in ages I've switched back to Nine. Well done Spud, you are the winner.

Spuds relentless self gratification about how he is having a chat with all these players before games and shit is sickening

 

[getsmarty]

Sterlo....made some excellent points today re all the unnecessary rule changes ....

 

[getsmarty]

Broncos bring in Ikin to help turn last-placed club's fortunes around

Former premiership-winning five-eighth Ben Ikin has been appointed Broncos' head of football as part of the sweeping changes at the club in the wake of their second successive struggling season.

www.nrl.com

 

[BBTB]

Again tonight-the bias against the Dragons from Ch 9 is unbelieveable.Last week against Melbourne almost made me throw up.But this week with that pig Gallen making comments-at our home ground too-wow i hope to get to watch someone punch his lights out in the ring.
So sick of the media treating us so badly

Yes the bias towards the Dragons is bad.
Guess they never got over 11 straight.