Agree.re Dufty's position..but genetically suited is not enough to guarantee you a 1st grade spot either.
Take Dufty playing wing out of the conversation cause it wont and should not happen and he may go to ISP if fullback is his only spot..thats life.
This is not about the wing so much. It is about wishing for unproven reserve grade people to hopefully step up and push someone back to ISP who may of fact improved over the off season and for the large portion of last year was 1st grade standard.
And I include Periera in the conversation for his part he played..what has he done wrong.
I dont get the throw the 2 imports in the 17 because we perceive they have got blistering 1st grade speed. Have they really against...tried and proven 1st graders?. What else do they have?
Possm..says size and speed.
Well I wait with baited breath to say how or this unfolds this year
Of course I am a Dufty fan but also a realist and if Widdop is a better fullback.for 2019....Ok ISP if that is where he wants to play cause you cant have 2...but still I think Mary will start with Lomax & Periera on the wings, Aitken & Laf in the centres if Widdop 1.
Not my preferred option but as I have said before they have painted themselves into a corner with recruitment re the flanks. If all these reserve graders (i.e. Rav, Jonus, Maranta & Charly) dont work out which is a big possibility to 1st grade standard he will have to go that way. Boy we beter hope for someone to step up..If injury strikes out in the backs we are stooffed.
In relation to Dufty, what I was implying with the genetically suited comment, was that it’s like a culling process, with the minimum standard being having a body size/strength to do the hard carries, and than you cull further from there ie speed, skill etc.
I agree with you re Pierra, if his off-season is good, he should start on one wing. Lomax should start as centre. Form will then decide who is picked on a week to week basis.
Im changing a little, I’m leaning towards the notion that our wingers won’t be as big an issue. At first I was concerned at losing two experienced wingers but I think there is some real good wingers amongst that remaining group who may even oust Pierra by seasons end. I M O It’s the control and combinations of the play makers, the spine and the centres that will ultimately win or lose us games. I think getting those combinations right will be the bigger influence.